Huascar & Co. Bakeshop Reviews

Chinello Nwakwesi 2026.07.12

     

choco chip cookie so good that I ate it in one sitting (no regrets). The cookie is so good that I had to bring one back to Toronto for my mom and then another back to my boyfriend living in London. Both thought it was the best cookie they’ve ever had. We’re gutted this bakery is based in NYC and we don’t have everyday access.

Useful Report

Gregor J. Rothfuss 2026.07.07

     

The energy cookie is pretty good.

Useful Report

Jeffrey James Keyes 2026.06.14

     

Huascar & Co. is my favorite bakery in the city. Huascar is a master baker and his cupcakes are truly the best in the city. I have so many favorites, including the Confetti, Strawberry Champagne, and Vanilla Extrovert. Ask about his coquito, it’s to die for.

Useful Report

Tara Hurley 2026.06.12

     

Absolutely delicious cupcakes! So flavorful and moist. The flavors are unique and fun. And the decor is adorable. Can't wait to come back.

Useful Report

Megan Mackenzie 2026.06.08

     

The cookies are amazing! And the carrot cake cupcake wowed me. What a gem of the neighborhood. Lovely spot and owners.

Useful Report

Seema Korumilli 2026.06.01

     

I’ve lived nearby for almost a year and can’t believe it took me so long to find this gem 😭 the sweets are drop dead amazing, especially the spiked tres leches and the mango passionfruit pastry.

Useful Report

Reply from Huascar & Co. Bakeshop 2026.06.06

Thank you so much, Seema: I’m happy our paths finally crossed! Thank you for supporting us with your very kind review.
Chef Huascar & Team

anastasia munshell 2026.05.28

     

We order here pretty often or just stop in for a delicious cupcake but last night really went above and beyond! Ordered a cake last minute for a dinner party (day before) they were able to fulfill my order with a very reasonable rush fee and made it extra beautiful which I did not expect. It was the absolute bell of the dinner party! I always recommend them!

Useful Report

Reply from Huascar & Co. Bakeshop 2026.06.06

Thanks so much for this kind review and for being our customer, Anastasia!

Maddie Messinger 2026.05.19

     

Amazing customized birthday cakes 🍰 we loved the dulce de leche for my boyfriends birthday. I forgot to take a photo and it was completely gone quickly at the party. it was so delicious it didn’t stand a chance!!

Useful Report

Reply from Huascar & Co. Bakeshop 2026.06.06

Thank you, dear Maddie, for being our customer, and for your kind support!

Chef Huascar & Team

Deb L 2026.03.11

     

The prices are on par with some of the bigger bakeries in the area; but the flavors are better, and the packaging is more thoughtful. I tried the nutella cupcake and loved it so much that I went back the next day for more. Will try some of the other eventually.

Useful Report

Reply from Huascar & Co. Bakeshop 2026.06.06

Dear Deb,

Thank you for being our customer and for supporting us with your very sweet review!

Warm regards,
Chef Huascar & Team

Erika D 2026.02.09

     

This was my first visit to Huascar’s. The decor was cute and the bakery case was well stocked, clean, and everything looked delicious. The shop is TINY but full of personality. I ordered a classic flan and the banana pudding with salted caramel. Took off one star because both desserts were a little too sweet for my taste. Aside from that, quite delicious!

Useful Report

Reply from Huascar & Co. Bakeshop 2026.06.06

Thanks for stopping by, Erika and for this nice review!

Warm regards,
Chef Huascar & Team

TuxedoKat Imaginarium 2026.02.08

     

We stopped in on our adventure walk around Hell's Kitchen on our way to see The Daily Show! LOVE the disco mirror facade btw... it captured us from afar. We got a cookie and a hot chocolate for the cold winter walk. The man who helped us was very friendly and made a great hot chocolate! Highly recommend for anyone with a sweet tooth!

Useful Report

Reply from Huascar & Co. Bakeshop 2026.06.06

Dear TuxedoKat,

Thank you for being our customer and for taking the time to give such a nice review!

Warm regards,
Chef Huascar & Team

Anthony Ponder 2026.01.30

     

Best bakery cakes and everything is great ! Small space but fr the services and the great products I’ll deal with it

Useful Report

Reply from Huascar & Co. Bakeshop 2026.06.06

Thank you so much for being our customer, Anthony, and for your supportive review!

Best wishes,
Chef Huascar & Team

Jordan Johnson 2026.01.15

     

Thank you, Huascar's Bakery, for the beautiful custom cake you created for my partner’s birthday! The flavors were absolutely delicious, and the design was immaculate. I couldn’t have asked for a better experience. Thank you for such a professional and seamless experience — I will definitely be back for more of your tasty treats and custom cakes.

Useful Report

Reply from Huascar & Co. Bakeshop 2026.01.26

Thanks for being our customer, Jordan, and for taking the time to support us with your kind review!
Warm regards,
Chef Huascar & the Team

Alek 2026.01.08

     

Lovely little bakeshop with incredible treats. Got the Lemon and Earl grey cupcake and the Mango passion fruit cheesecake and both were out of this world

Useful Report

Reply from Huascar & Co. Bakeshop 2026.01.26

Thanks, dear Alek, for your very kind review and for being our customer!
Warm regards,
Chef Huascar & the Team

Richard H 2026.01.07

     

Delicious cupcake and cheesecake! The owner was fabulous! Highly recommended.

Useful Report

Reply from Huascar & Co. Bakeshop 2026.01.26

Dear Richard,
Thanks for taking the time to write this kind review and thanks for being our customer! We look forward to seeing you again!
Warm regards,
Chef Huascar & the Team

Ricardo Barrett 2026.01.04

     

Useful Report

Reply from Huascar & Co. Bakeshop 2026.01.05

Thanks for being our customer, Ricardo, and for showing your support! Happy New Year from all of us! Chef Huascar & Team

Matthew Cuevas 2025.12.16

     

Beautiful, delicious, and fresh cupcakes. I'll never pass up an opportunity to visit.

Useful Report

Reply from Huascar & Co. Bakeshop 2026.01.05

Thank you, Matthew!
We appreciate your taking the time to show your support!
Chef Huascar & Team

T Carroll 2025.11.16

     

Useful Report

Reply from Huascar & Co. Bakeshop 2026.01.05

Thank you so much, T! Happy New Year!
Chef Huascar & Team

Jamin Enquist 2025.11.16

     

Useful Report

Reply from Huascar & Co. Bakeshop 2026.01.05

Thank you, Jamin, for being our customer and for showing your support! Happy New Year!
Chef Huascar & Team

Moriah Reyes 2025.11.15

     

Love this place! This is my go-to for all birthday desserts and everyone always loves it. They have so many different cupcake flavors and I haven’t found one I didn’t like.

Useful Report

Reply from Huascar & Co. Bakeshop 2026.06.06

Thank you for being our customer, Moriah! Your support and kind review means so much to us!

Best wishes,
Chef Huascar Aquino