The Tin Fish Newburgh

The Tin Fish Newburgh Reviews

Excellent rating
     
4.5 | 1342 reviews
Trustindex Verified Company
The Tin Fish Newburgh
Write a review

Reviews

Trustindex

4.5

| 1342 total

913 pcs
277 pcs
81 pcs
42 pcs
29 pcs
Source filter
Joey McBride
Joey McBride 2026.08.24
     
Very nice staff and their seafood is on point.
Jenna Hancock-Wargel
Jenna Hancock-Wargel 2026.08.07
     
We love the food here wish we had one on westside just saying:)
Tim Orrick
Tim Orrick 2026.08.05
     
Ordered the seafood grill a the fish way over cooked so it was very dry. I couldn’t tell which fish was which because it had so much Cajun seasoning on it.
Susan Stalion
Susan Stalion 2026.07.15
     
I decided to try the crab cakes. So disappointing! Hard to tell if it was crab or some other fish, and the spices disguised the crab flavor. It was not lump crab. Definitely will not get again.
Randall
Randall 2026.07.11
     
Excellent food. A bit spicy if you prefer mild, but I enjoyed it. It is "seat yorself" after ordering. Mahi Mahi was good portions sized. I felt the fried oysters were a small portion for the price. Waitstaff were friendly.
Jennifer Meyer
Jennifer Meyer 2026.07.05
     
Wide variety. Great service. Blackened red snapper and Mahi Mahi were tasty.
Karen F.
Karen F. 2026.07.01
     
Trustindex Verified
I had a shrimp salad sandwich about two weeks ago that i cannot stop thinking about!!! Absolutely delicious! Everyone should try whatever special TinFish has ! I will be back!
Steve D
Steve D 2026.06.28
     
Helpful staff. Clean restarant. Most important, they know how to perfectly cook seafood. Best oysters I've had outside louisiana. This place is worth going out of your way.
Lora Becker
Lora Becker 2026.06.18
     
A relaxing place to catch up with good friends. Order at the register, then sit back and enjoy!
Benton Frisse
Benton Frisse 2026.06.16
     
Great local dining spot with lots of seafood options. The cole slaw is delicious, along with their famous fish sandwhich. Portion sizes aren't gigantic which I'm not mad about, they're sensible portion sizes. Good beer on tap, too. Fish and chips are also delicious!
Mrs. P
Mrs. P 2026.05.17
     
This was our first time stopping in. My husband got the chicken tenders & waffle fries. The tenders were fresh and good but also very thin. Waffle fries were good but could use some seasoning. I got a salmon taco that was very good and then a shrimp taco that could've been a lot better had they deveined the shrimp. Very odd not to devein shrimp at a restaurant and gross, in my opinion. The service was lacking as no one ever came to check on us after they brought our food. I had to wave down someone walking around for a to-go box. Also a big heads up, do not expect to pay prices you see on their menu shown online. I paid double for the tacos than what is shown.
Margaret Dennis
Margaret Dennis 2026.05.09
     
Wonderful food. You can’t go wrong with any of their dishes. They are known for their fish sandwich and fish and chips, as well as for their great cocktails.

Skyrocket Your Sales with Customer Reviews. No coding required.

Create a Free Account