Mailstar Reviews

Tiffany Paine-Cirrincione 2026.11.01

     

Abby and this team really came through for me this week. They helped me get an important mailer out the door in a short amount of time, perfectly printed, and into mailboxes just before the deadline. They made this so easy for me and it was cheaper than I was quoted by other (not local) companies. Highly recommend this company!

Useful Report

Fred Endres 2026.10.28

     

Such a nice staff to work with. Highly recommended!

Useful Report

Anne LeBlanc 2026.10.05

     

Mailsstar just pulled off something that I still can't believe. They always do a good job: the enclosures are enclosed, the print looks nice, and the addresses are right. But this time I couldn't give them something until Friday morning because of my computer problems. And I was in a real hurry. Somehow, they got the job to the post office that afternoon so it arrived in my recipients' mailboxes today, Monday. And they didn't skimp on quality. They did the same high quality they usually do. I don't know how they pulled it off, but they did. Kudos to Mailstar.

Useful Report

Laurie A. Murray 2026.05.28

     

We have been using Mailstar for a very long time in our real estate & vacation rental business. From start to finish, the experience is leagues above anywhere else. When we heard Cathy was retiring, we were a little conflicted because, while we were really happy for her, we didn't know what that meant for the future of Mailstar. She put us in contact with Abby and Sim - and it's been absolutely the same superior level of quality customer care, communication, and support. Couldn't be happier!

Useful Report

Reply from Mailstar 2021.12.14

Thank you so much for the kind words, Laurie! We take great pride in our work and in treating all of our customers like our own friends; we're so glad that your experience has reflected this.

Mallory Giambra 2026.05.26

     

Having been working with Mailstar for a few years - they always provide speedy, professional service!

Useful Report

Domenic Argentieri 2026.05.05

     

Great team that delivers!

Useful Report

عمرالدین عبدالصمد 2026.04.16

     

Useful Report

Karen White 2025.07.09

     

The team at Mailstar is outstanding. They are helpful to novices because they are great listeners! Every step of the printing, mailing, and billing process was easy. You won't be disappointed working with Mailstar.

Useful Report

Reply from Mailstar 2025.07.09

Thanks so much for taking the time to leave us a review, Karen! It was a pleasure working with you on your project. Cheers to many more partnerships in the future!

betsy musshafen 2025.06.18

     

Exceptional communication regarding my order with fast responses on any questions, and fast turnaround times on proofs. Everyone was outstanding and all of my job was handled very professionally.

Useful Report

Reply from Mailstar 2025.07.02

Hi Betsy! Thanks so much for your review. It was a pleasure working with you, and we look forward to potentially partnering in the future!

Jay Shaw 2025.03.29

     

Easy, fast, and top-quality! 🎩 🪄

Useful Report

Reply from Mailstar 2025.07.02

Thanks so much for leaving a review Jay! We're so glad we were able to help with your job. Always happy to help out with whatever you may need!

Ray King 2025.03.22

     

An easy company to work with! Creative and very responsive.

Useful Report

Reply from Mailstar 2025.07.02

Thank you Ray! It was a pleasure working with you! Good luck with the new business ventures - we're always happy to help with whatever design/printing needs you may have 😁

Meghan Callan 2024.11.27

     

The team at Mailstar is very helpful in statically maximizing my budget for print appeals. Very helpful!

Useful Report

Reply from Mailstar 2024.12.24

Hi Meghan, thanks so much for your review! We were happy to help with your appeal mailings this year - we always want to help our customers get the most bang for their buck! Here's to many more successful campaigns in 2025!

Capstone IT 2024.11.25

     

We have always printed our physical newsletter through Mailstar and they turn it around and have it delivered so quickly and my prints are always perfect!

Useful Report

Reply from Mailstar 2024.12.24

Always a pleasure to work with you over at Capstone! Thanks for taking the time to leave a review for us. Cheers to many more newsletters in 2025!

Ronald Sabernick 2024.10.18

     

Mailstar made it so easy! They are very professional, and quick to respond. I called them because I had a time sensitive advertisment for my fire department and they rose to the occasion! I barely had to do anything. Thank you Mailstar for your help!

Useful Report

Reply from Mailstar 2024.10.29

Thanks so much for your review, Ron! It was a pleasure working with you. We're happy we were able to make the whole process as easy and painless as possible - that's always our goal here at Mailstar!

Anika Skarzynski 2024.09.24

     

I've worked with Mailstar for a couple nonprofits over the years and I'm consistently impressed by their attention to detail, efficient production schedule and quality of work. The team is easy to work-all of their staff is friendly, helpful and excels at customer service. Mailstar is a partner in our nonprofit work!

Useful Report

Reply from Mailstar 2024.10.29

Hi Anika! Thanks so much for taking the time to write a review for us. It's alway appreciated, and always a pleasure to work with you! We love the long-standing relationships we've been able to build with some of our contacts. Cheers to many more years of mailings!

Charlotte Melenric 2024.04.12

     

I’ve worked with Mailstar on many projects for years and always impressed with their service and products. Highly recommend them, especially for designing new material!

Useful Report

Michele Quinn 2024.01.21

     

We have worked with Mailstar for well over 10 years and have never been disappointed in the quality and attention to details. Their service is prompt, dependable and they truly want to satisfy you the customer. Cathy is so friendly and give us such great advice, she takes time to explain better way to achieve a goal, yet keep our budget in mind. Being a nonprofit these things all mean a great deal to us. Thank you to all the team at Mailstar and especially Katarina who recently did a phenomenal job for us.

Useful Report

Aaron Martin 2023.04.26

     

Cathy and her team are dynamite. Attention to detail, good communication, quality printing and quick turnaround. Highly recommended!

Useful Report

Melinda M 2023.02.13

     

Useful Report

Max Stwertka 2023.02.02

     

Mailstar has been phenomenal to work with. On multiple occasions Cathy and Jay have made it possible for our small shop non-profit to send out high quality materials that we simply could not have done without their incredible attention to detail. Choose them if you want professionalism and high quality customer service at an affordable price.

Useful Report