AY GUEY NYC Reviews

Jean 2026.10.06

     

First time at this wonderful neighborhood spot, and we aren’t even from the neighborhood (wish we were, I’d be here all the time!). The happy hour cocktails were delicious and the food was on point (especially the seafood tower!). There were a lot of other dishes I wanted to try so will need to come back. A sweet and delicious touch at the end when we ordered churros and they gave them to us on the house. Such a simple but wonderful gesture, which does not go unnoticed in today’s economy. We’ve been to other larger establishments recently that didn’t even acknowledge a birthday in anyway, so kudos to the team here all around for making this Monday night dinner feel like a special occasion!

Useful (1) Report

Reply from AY GUEY NYC 2026.10.06

Jean, thank you so much for taking the time to write such a thoughtful review! We're so glad your first visit had you feeling like part of the neighborhood, even if you're not local to Woodside. It means a lot that the happy hour cocktails and dishes hit the mark, and we loved getting to add a little something extra with the churros to make your Monday night feel special. We think good mexican food and genuine hospitality should go hand in hand, and it sounds like our team nailed that for you. Can't wait to have you back to try more of the menu soon!

Matt 2026.09.25

     

Local spot I like for food and drink

Useful Report

Reply from AY GUEY NYC 2026.09.25

Thanks, Matt! Glad Ay Güey has become a go-to spot for you here in Woodside. We love having you in for good Mexican food and drinks, see you again soon.

Julien Chong 2026.09.22

     

Great mexican food,service and atmosphere feel you are in Mexico really enjoyed it

Useful Report

Reply from AY GUEY NYC 2026.09.23

Thank you, Julien! We're so glad you felt that authentic vibe with us, it's exactly what we aim for at Ay Güey NYC. Glad you enjoyed the Mexican food and the atmosphere. Come back and see us again soon here in Woodside!

Kris V Alva 2026.09.17

     

I’ve been wanting to try this restaurant for the longest time and I finally made it here, and WOW… I’m so glad I did! 😭 Everything we ordered was seriously SO good. The food was cooked perfectly, full of flavor, and the drinks were amazing too! The birria tacos were definitely my favorite, SO flavorful, juicy, and just chef’s kiss 🤌🏽 I’m already craving them again! Our waitress was also an absolute rockstar! She was so sweet, attentive, and made sure we had everything we needed. She definitely made an already great experience even better! I’m already looking forward to coming back because there are so many more things on the menu I want to try. This was definitely one of those “why didn’t I come here sooner?” moments! 🥹❤️

Useful Report

Reply from AY GUEY NYC 2026.09.17

Kris, thank you so much for this amazing review! We're so happy you finally made it in and that the birria tacos hit the spot, they're a favorite of ours too. Our waitress Talia, also an amazing bartender!, will be thrilled to hear your kind words about her service. Thank you for choosing us for your Mexican food craving, we can't wait to welcome you back to Woodside soon to try more of the menu!

Makhan Singh 2026.09.17

     

Useful Report

Reply from AY GUEY NYC 2026.09.17

Thank you so much for the 5 stars, Makhan! We really appreciate you stopping by Ay Güey NYC in Woodside and hope to see you again soon for more Mexican food and good times.

Stacy 2026.09.06

     

Useful Report

Reply from AY GUEY NYC 2026.09.07

Thanks so much for the 5 stars, Stacy! We're glad you enjoyed your visit to AY GUEY in Woodside. Hope to see you back soon for more Mexican food and drinks at the bar!

Jay Lee 2026.09.05

     

Great food (mole and the guac with chorizo is excellent) Great atmosphere Great service. Staff is so thoughtful and sweet

Useful Report

Reply from AY GUEY NYC 2026.04.17

Jay, we’re truly grateful to know you enjoyed both the flavors and the warmth of our team during your visit. Moments like yours inspire us to keep bringing people together through good food in a welcoming space.

Thank you for sharing your experience—AY GUEY! Mexican Restaurant

James Cassel 2026.09.05

     

Useful Report

Reply from AY GUEY NYC 2026.09.06

Thanks so much for the 5 stars, James! We really appreciate you taking the time to visit AY GUEY! in Woodside. Hope to see you again soon for more Mexican food and good times at the bar!

Yady Florencio 2026.08.27

     

Useful Report

Reply from AY GUEY NYC 2026.08.29

Thank you so much for the 5 stars, Yady! We really appreciate you taking the time to leave us a review. Hope to see you again soon at AY GUEY! in Woodside for more Mexican food and good times.

Nate Brown 2026.08.26

     

Lovely neighborhood spot with a tasty menu and some very good cocktails. Menu is simple but very well done with several options across different categories (tacos, aguachiles, mains, etc.) very friendly staff - a little understaffed as of writing, but little to no delay and a really relaxing atmosphere

Useful Report

Reply from AY GUEY NYC 2026.08.26

Nate,

It’s wonderful to hear you enjoyed both the relaxed vibe and the thoughtful range of dishes and drinks during your visit. Your understanding about our team’s efforts on a busy night truly means a lot, and we’re glad it all came together for a laid-back experience.

With appreciation,
AY GUEY! Mexican Restaurant

Lee Espinoza 2026.08.23

     

Away from the train, but a spot you shouldn't miss. Although I havnt tried the seafood, the Ay Guey nachos with chicken is extremely good. As for the drink I think the Mezcal Mule hits a really good note for a cocktail. The interior of the place has a home feel to it mixed with colorful prints/leaf decorations. I'd be willing to try something different the next time I stop by.

Useful Report

Reply from AY GUEY NYC 2026.08.24

Lee,

We’re glad you found our nachos and that Mezcal Mule to be just right, and it’s great to hear the atmosphere made you feel comfortable and welcome. It’ll be a pleasure to have you back to explore more from the menu whenever you’re ready for something new.

All the best from AY GUEY! Mexican Restaurant

Andres Cardona 2026.08.22

     

Useful Report

Reply from AY GUEY NYC 2026.08.22

We're over the moon about your 5-star rating! Making sure you're happy is our number one goal. Hope to see you again soon!

Wilghen Santos 2026.08.19

     

Love it. Small business , good food. Good cocktails.

Useful Report

Reply from AY GUEY NYC 2026.08.22

Wilghen,

It’s wonderful to hear that you appreciate what we’re doing, especially when you mention both our food and the drinks. Your support for our small spot truly encourages us.

All our thanks,
AY GUEY! Mexican Restaurant

Tena Bugarin 2026.08.10

     

Useful Report

Reply from AY GUEY NYC 2026.08.22

Overwhelmed by your 5-star rating! This fires us up to keep doing a great job. See you soon.

Helene 2026.07.17

     

I ordered a salad, and while it looked fresh and appealing, it lacked flavor. The ingredients seemed fresh, but the overall taste was pretty bland and could have used more seasoning or a more flavorful dressing. It has potential, but I was disappointed that it didn’t live up to its appearance.

Useful Report

Reply from AY GUEY NYC 2026.07.17

Helene,

Thank you for sharing your thoughts with us; it’s clear you were hoping for a dish that matched its vibrant appearance in taste as well. We’ll be taking your feedback to heart as we look for ways to bring more flavor and excitement to our salads moving forward.

Sincerely,
The AY GUEY! Mexican Restaurant Team

Ruby Fernandez (Ruby1985) 2026.07.10

     

Useful Report

Reply from AY GUEY NYC 2026.08.22

We're joyous over your 5-star rating! Thanks for your approval. Eagerly waiting for your next visit.

Niara Calliste 2026.07.06

     

High price, small portions. Ordered a mole which was just ok, a bit sweet and very small portions, like it could've been an appetizer small. Normally I have a small appetite but I was still hungry when I got home. Food was just ok. I can say I tried it but would not return again.

Useful Report

Reply from AY GUEY NYC 2026.07.06

Niara,

Thank you for sharing your thoughts with us; we’re genuinely sorry that your meal left you wanting more in both flavor and satisfaction. Your feedback will be thoughtfully considered as we look for ways to better meet the needs of guests who, like you, hoped for a more fulfilling dining experience.

Sincerely,
The AY GUEY! Mexican Restaurant Team

Mina Reynoso 2026.07.06

     

Loved the yuca fries. Great place to sit, relax and have a good dinner.

Useful Report

Reply from AY GUEY NYC 2026.08.22

Mina,

It’s wonderful to know you enjoyed your dinner and found our spot comfortable for unwinding. Hearing you liked the yuca fries truly brings us joy.

All our best,
AY GUEY! Mexican Restaurant

EBRAHIM ELSAYED 2026.07.03

     

Useful Report

Reply from AY GUEY NYC 2026.08.22

Your stellar review has us grinning from ear to ear! Thank you. We're excited to welcome you back.

Teresa M 2026.07.01

     

Great local spot for fresh seafood and Mexican dishes. The seafood tower is awesome and the flaming shrimp too. Great margaritas!

Useful Report

Reply from AY GUEY NYC 2026.07.01

Hi Teresa,

It’s wonderful to hear that you enjoyed both our seafood specialties and the margaritas, as we take real pride in creating meals that feel special and lively. We appreciate your support and look forward to welcoming you back for more evenings like this.

All our best, AY GUEY! Mexican Restaurant