Sotto Le Stelle Reviews

K Moser 2025.12.07

     

If you want to taste ITALY go here for pizza. It’s DIVINE. It’s very pricy but well worth the $$$. The only thing negative thing I can say is that they are too heavy handed with the basil but that’s remedied by asking them to leave it off. PS - I now have had three of their pasta dishes and OMG!!!! Each dish was masterfully made, just right and the portion was a good size. Enough to make me feel guilty!! It’s amazing that you can grab a dish here for just a bit more than a fast food place but get 10000 times the quality and you’re eating fresh food!!!

Useful Report

Reply from Sotto Le Stelle 2024.12.09

Thanks, Kim! So glad you loved the pizza—it truly is a taste of Italy! We appreciate your feedback on the basil and will definitely keep it in mind. Hope to see you again soon!

Suhrab Hadjimetov 2025.12.01

     

Useful Report

Reply from Sotto Le Stelle 2025.12.01

Thanks for the fantastic review, Suhrab! We're thrilled to hear you enjoyed your experience at Sotto Le Stelle. Did you try our wood-fired pizza? It’s made with authentic Neapolitan techniques that really bring out the flavors! We can't wait to welcome you back for another delicious meal soon!

Ana Maria 2025.11.28

     

Useful Report

Reply from Sotto Le Stelle 2025.12.01

Thank you, Ana Maria! We’re thrilled to hear you enjoyed your experience at Sotto Le Stelle. Did you try our classic Neapolitan pizza? It's a crowd favorite! We can’t wait to welcome you back for another delicious meal.

Jose antonio carrion 2025.11.25

     

Useful Report

Reply from Sotto Le Stelle 2025.11.25

Thank you, Jose Antonio! We're thrilled to hear you enjoyed your experience at Sotto Le Stelle. Our team takes pride in bringing authentic Neapolitan flavors to your table. Did you try our handmade pizzas? They’re a crowd favorite! We can’t wait to welcome you back for another delicious meal soon.

Matt Benjamin 2025.11.23

     

They sent me Chef Boy R See spaghetti and meatballs I think What is this???

Useful Report

Reply from Sotto Le Stelle 2025.11.24

Matt, we’re sorry to hear that your experience didn't meet expectations. We appreciate your feedback and will work to improve. Thank you for letting us know.

Shamanthy R. 2025.11.23

     

Great food and hospitality! Will return no doubt.

Useful Report

Reply from Sotto Le Stelle 2025.11.26

Thanks, Shamanthy! So glad you enjoyed the food and hospitality. Can’t wait to welcome you back!

Jonathan Vadnos 2025.11.18

     

Fantastic local restaurant to enjoy. Excellent service and food! Thanks and will be back again!

Useful Report

Reply from Sotto Le Stelle 2025.11.19

Thanks, Jonathan! So glad you enjoyed the food and service. Can't wait to see you again soon! 🍕✨

Francesco La Rosa 2025.11.16

     

My favorite napoletan pizza in Queens. Fresh ingredients and high quality dough. Worth the wait.

Useful Report

Reply from Sotto Le Stelle 2025.11.16

Thanks, Francesco! So glad you love our Neapolitan pizza. Fresh ingredients and quality dough are what we’re all about! Can’t wait to see you again! 🍕✨

John Joseph (JJCTYR) 2025.11.15

     

Very busy and a little confined but got settled out back where it was quieter. Food came out quickly and was delicious. Calamari was cooked perfectly and both pizzas were divine. Will definitely go back

Useful Report

Reply from Sotto Le Stelle 2025.11.17

Thanks, John! So glad to hear you enjoyed the food and found a nice spot to relax. Can’t wait to have you back for more delicious pizzas and calamari! 🍕✨

Christos Marinakis 2025.11.08

     

Useful Report

Sergio Serrano 2025.11.03

     

First time here, the food was delicious and the drinks amazing. Great service! The desserts yummy. Definitely recommend this place. Thank you for all that you do!!

Useful Report

Reply from Sotto Le Stelle 2025.11.04

Thanks so much, Sergio! We're thrilled you enjoyed your first visit and loved the food, drinks, and desserts. Your recommendation means a lot to us! Come back anytime!

Marco Almeyda 2025.10.26

     

Useful Report

Victor Ocando 2025.10.25

     

Hidden gem! Service, food, atmosphere 5⭐️

Useful Report

Reply from Sotto Le Stelle 2025.10.27

Thanks a ton, Victor! We’re thrilled you enjoyed the service, food, and atmosphere. Can’t wait to have you back for more Neapolitan goodness! 🍕✨

Marc-Albert Michaud 2025.10.23

     

Useful Report

Kim Ponce 2025.10.19

     

Useful Report

N Chang 2025.10.18

     

This restaurant is truly authentic Italian, and the food quality is exceptional. We ordered the Prosciutto & Arugula Pizza and the Diavola Pizza. The crust is classic Neapolitan style — thin with a slight chew — and honestly, it’s all about that crust. The sauce was full of flavor, perfectly balanced with just the right amount of cheese and a little kick. The prosciutto pizza was equally delicious. The Seafood Pasta was on another level. The dish is prepared in a pan, then topped with a thin layer of pizza dough and baked in the oven to form a perfect dome. At the table, you peel back the dome and dip it into the rich, flavorful sauce — OMG, it was incredible. From now on, I’ll be comparing every seafood pasta to this one. If you love seafood pasta, this is a must-order dish. I only wish I lived in New York so I could visit Sotto Le Stelle more often. The service was outstanding, and it’s clear the Sotto Le Stelle team takes great pride in the food they serve. Our server, Bigo, was wonderful — friendly, attentive, and added to the overall experience. We definitely will be back.

Useful Report

Reply from Sotto Le Stelle 2025.10.19

Thanks so much, N! We're thrilled you loved the Prosciutto & Arugula and Diavola pizzas, especially that crust! The Seafood Pasta is a fan favorite, and we’re glad it wowed you. Bigo will be super happy to hear your kind words! Can't wait to welcome you back whenever you're in town! 🍕✨

Philip To 2025.10.10

     

Great food and nice atmosphere. Staff were nice and friendly.

Useful Report

Reply from Sotto Le Stelle 2025.10.10

Thanks, Philip! We're thrilled you enjoyed the food and atmosphere. Our team loves making you feel welcome. Come back soon!

Anna Li 2025.09.26

     

Not a bad place for social and weekend vibes and a cute little spot in the neighborhood but I think the food was expensive. Pizza was great though, the dough was very fresh. Otherwise nothing else really blew me away.

Useful Report

Reply from Sotto Le Stelle 2025.09.26

Thank you for your feedback, Anna. We're glad to hear you enjoyed the pizza and found our spot inviting for social gatherings. We appreciate your thoughts on pricing and will consider them as we strive to improve. Hoping to impress you more on your next visit!

Rosalie Deluca 2025.09.21

     

Useful Report

Victor Boehringer 2025.09.16

     

Useful Report