Verified Company
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Sicily Osteria delivered an outstanding dining experience! The food was authentic, flavorful, and beautifully presented. From the fresh pasta to the delicious seafood dishes, everything tasted amazing. The atmosphere was warm and elegant, and the staff provided excellent service throughout the evening. Perfect place for a family dinner or special night out. Highly recommend Sicily Osteria and will definitely be coming back!
"Found this place by chance and it was a great find. The seating is a bit tight, but the food more than made up for it—the carbonara was excellent. Our server was attentive even though they were slammed for the pre-theater rush. Definitely worth a stop if you want a quality meal that isn't a tourist trap."
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Unser Besuch im Sicily Osteria war von Anfang bis Ende ein wunderbares Erlebnis. Bereits der Empfang war ausgesprochen freundlich, aufmerksam und den Gästen sehr zugewandt.
Wir waren gleich zwei Mal dort essen und wurden an beiden Abenden mit hervorragendem Service verwöhnt. Die Speisen waren frisch zubereitet, qualitativ erstklassig und äußerst köstlich. Besonders begeistert haben uns der Caesar Salad als Vorspeise, die Rigatoni alla Vodka, die Linguine Vongole sowie der Branzino – alles perfekt zubereitet und geschmacklich hervorragend abgestimmt.
Auch die überschaubare, aber sehr gut ausgewählte Weinkarte hat unser kulinarisches Erlebnis wunderbar ergänzt.
Ein großes Dankeschön gilt dem Herrn am Empfang sowie unserem Kellner Roberto, die beide mit ihrer herzlichen und professionellen Art maßgeblich zu zwei vergnüglichen Abenden beigetragen haben. Ebenso möchten wir der Küche unseren Dank aussprechen, die unsere Gaumen auf höchstem Niveau verwöhnt hat.
Wer im Theater District ausgezeichnet speisen möchte, sollte dieses Restaurant unbedingt besuchen. Eine Reservierung ist definitiv empfehlenswert!
We went yesterday for Mother’s Day, had a terrific evening! The food was excellent, our server Roberto was wonderful, especially with my dad. We were not rushed at all and had a lovely celebration. It was not our first time and it never disappoints!
Reply from Sicily Osteria
2026.05.11
Hi there,
Thank you for spending Mother’s Day with us! We’re so happy you had a lovely celebration and enjoyed Roberto’s service.
Thank you for spending Mother’s Day with us! We’re so happy you had a lovely celebration and enjoyed Roberto’s service.
The whole family came here after our Harry Potter broadway show. From the moment we walked in, the staff was warm and welcoming. Roberto was exceptional! The food was delicious. Highly recommend!
Reply from Sicily Osteria
2026.05.11
Hi Amy,
Thank you! We’re so glad you enjoyed the food and Roberto’s service!
Thank you! We’re so glad you enjoyed the food and Roberto’s service!
I went here for the first time with my dad’s fiancé after seeing little shop of horrors and to be honest, it was a rough day for me all around. But, with the great food and great atmosphere and the hospitality of our server, Roberto, my day got turned around
Reply from Sicily Osteria
2026.05.11
Hi Jessica,
Thank you! Roberto will be delighted to hear this!
Thank you! Roberto will be delighted to hear this!
