Sagaponack Reviews

Excellent rating

4.6 | 1686 reviews

Verified Company

www.saganewyork.com Visit this website

Reviews

4.6

| 1686 total

5 stars

1252 pcs

4 stars

304 pcs

3 stars

98 pcs

2 stars

17 pcs

1 star

15 pcs

Source filter

1686 pcs

Verified

Zen 2025.11.30

The place is very clean, simple and elegant. The waiters are attentive and informative. I just wish the advertised the fact that it’s not AYCE oysters, it’s up to 12 $1 oysters… Besides that their specialty oysters were good and a fun to experience. I would return to try more in the menu.

The place is very clean, simple and elegant. The waiters are attentive and informative. I just wish the advertised the fact that it’s not AYCE oysters, it’s up to 12 $1 oysters…

Besides that their specialty oysters were good and a fun to experience. I would return to try more in the menu.

The place is very clean, simple and elegant. The waiters are attentive and informative. I just wish the advertised the fact that it’s not AYCE oysters, it’s up to 12 $1 oysters…

Besides that their specialty oysters were good and a fun to experience. I would return to try more in the menu.

The place is very clean, simple and elegant. The waiters are attentive and informative. I just wish the advertised the fact that it’s not AYCE oysters, it’s up to 12 $1 oysters…

Besides that their specialty oysters were good and a fun to experience. I would return to try more in the menu.

The place is very clean, simple and elegant. The waiters are attentive and informative. I just wish the advertised the fact that it’s not AYCE oysters, it’s up to 12 $1 oysters…

Besides that their specialty oysters were good and a fun to experience. I would return to try more in the menu.

The place is very clean, simple and elegant. The waiters are attentive and informative. I just wish the advertised the fact that it’s not AYCE oysters, it’s up to 12 $1 oysters…

Besides that their specialty oysters were good and a fun to experience. I would return to try more in the menu.

The place is very clean, simple and elegant. The waiters are attentive and informative. I just wish the advertised the fact that it’s not AYCE oysters, it’s up to 12 $1 oysters…

Besides that their specialty oysters were good and a fun to experience. I would return to try more in the menu.

The place is very clean, simple and elegant. The waiters are attentive and informative. I just wish the advertised the fact that it’s not AYCE oysters, it’s up to 12 $1 oysters…

Besides that their specialty oysters were good and a fun to experience. I would return to try more in the menu.

The place is very clean, simple and elegant. The waiters are attentive and informative. I just wish the advertised the fact that it’s not AYCE oysters, it’s up to 12 $1 oysters…

Besides that their specialty oysters were good and a fun to experience. I would return to try more in the menu.

The place is very clean, simple and elegant. The waiters are attentive and informative. I just wish the advertised the fact that it’s not AYCE oysters, it’s up to 12 $1 oysters…

Besides that their specialty oysters were good and a fun to experience. I would return to try more in the menu.

Joaquim Rabinovitch 2025.11.22

Kristy Smolen 2025.11.16

Indy Life with Lexus 2025.11.16

Seasonal soup was so good , coconut ginger cream was soft, a bit sweet and small crispy from pumpkin seed is was perfect match. I love its. Salmon taco also very good , served with chips and chili sauce for dipping was so good. 2 pieces of salmon taco also very, such a big portion, made me so full form both menu. Atmosphere was so good not too busy and feels comfortable. Bar staff, he was so nice, good service and helpful. Recommend this place and I will come back again.

Seasonal soup was so good , coconut ginger cream was soft, a bit sweet and small crispy from pumpkin seed is was perfect match. I love its.
Salmon taco also very good , served with chips and chili sauce for dipping was so good. 2 pieces of salmon taco also very, such a big portion, made me so full form both menu.
Atmosphere was so good not too busy and feels comfortable. Bar staff, he was so nice, good service and helpful.
Recommend this place and I will come back again.

Seasonal soup was so good , coconut ginger cream was soft, a bit sweet and small crispy from pumpkin seed is was perfect match. I love its.
Salmon taco also very good , served with chips and chili sauce for dipping was so good. 2 pieces of salmon taco also very, such a big portion, made me so full form both menu.
Atmosphere was so good not too busy and feels comfortable. Bar staff, he was so nice, good service and helpful.
Recommend this place and I will come back again.

Seasonal soup was so good , coconut ginger cream was soft, a bit sweet and small crispy from pumpkin seed is was perfect match. I love its.
Salmon taco also very good , served with chips and chili sauce for dipping was so good. 2 pieces of salmon taco also very, such a big portion, made me so full form both menu.
Atmosphere was so good not too busy and feels comfortable. Bar staff, he was so nice, good service and helpful.
Recommend this place and I will come back again.

Seasonal soup was so good , coconut ginger cream was soft, a bit sweet and small crispy from pumpkin seed is was perfect match. I love its.
Salmon taco also very good , served with chips and chili sauce for dipping was so good. 2 pieces of salmon taco also very, such a big portion, made me so full form both menu.
Atmosphere was so good not too busy and feels comfortable. Bar staff, he was so nice, good service and helpful.
Recommend this place and I will come back again.

Seasonal soup was so good , coconut ginger cream was soft, a bit sweet and small crispy from pumpkin seed is was perfect match. I love its.
Salmon taco also very good , served with chips and chili sauce for dipping was so good. 2 pieces of salmon taco also very, such a big portion, made me so full form both menu.
Atmosphere was so good not too busy and feels comfortable. Bar staff, he was so nice, good service and helpful.
Recommend this place and I will come back again.

Seasonal soup was so good , coconut ginger cream was soft, a bit sweet and small crispy from pumpkin seed is was perfect match. I love its.
Salmon taco also very good , served with chips and chili sauce for dipping was so good. 2 pieces of salmon taco also very, such a big portion, made me so full form both menu.
Atmosphere was so good not too busy and feels comfortable. Bar staff, he was so nice, good service and helpful.
Recommend this place and I will come back again.

Seasonal soup was so good , coconut ginger cream was soft, a bit sweet and small crispy from pumpkin seed is was perfect match. I love its.
Salmon taco also very good , served with chips and chili sauce for dipping was so good. 2 pieces of salmon taco also very, such a big portion, made me so full form both menu.
Atmosphere was so good not too busy and feels comfortable. Bar staff, he was so nice, good service and helpful.
Recommend this place and I will come back again.

Suneel Kabadi 2025.11.16

Amazing happy hour, very chill vibe and no one ruhes you which is amazing. I could see my self coming back here often due to the fresh food, good prices, and staff that just want to see you have a good time at your own pace. I got the happyhour oysters and the spicy margarita. Both were phenomenal and I would reccomend

Amazing happy hour, very chill vibe and no one ruhes you which is amazing. I could see my self coming back here often due to the fresh food, good prices, and staff that just want to see you have a good time at your own pace.

I got the happyhour oysters and the spicy margarita. Both were phenomenal and I would reccomend

David Shellhamer 2025.11.14

I really wanted to like the oysters during the happy hour, since they were only $1, but most of mine had sand/grit in them. This might have just been an outlier but I’ll probably wait for my normal place to be open in future visits.

M Larson 2025.11.14

Amazing food and service 🥰

Jason Kwan 2025.11.09

Went here for a dinner with friends. Food and service were solid. I could see this place being very consistent. We really liked the oysters that we had to start. The cocktails were very good. The prices were very reasonable - 3 of us had oysters to start, an entree, dessert and multiple cocktails/beers for just under $250, not including tip. If you're looking for a casual seafood place to go and catch up with friends, Sagaponack would be great for that. It would definitely be a great brunch or lunch place.

Vy Le 2025.11.07

Favorite restaurant in the city. My coastal Asian parents approve. $1 happy hour oysters are a must

Linda Kafexholli 2025.11.03

such a cute place tho

Mathieu RYCKEWAERT 2025.11.01

The best Tuna I have had. Just magic.

IG 2025.10.27

Audrey Guittard 2025.10.23

Superbe découverte, happy hour à battre toute concurrence. 1 euro l'huitre et service impeccable, cuisine excellente, là on est vraiment à NY! J'ai adoré!

Jason C 2025.10.22

Great to find a decent dollar oyster happy hour. Didn't know there were any left!

avery Isernia 2025.10.19

Came in with my dad on a Saturday night and we were blown away by this meal. The staff were extremely friendly, knowledgeable and attentive. The real star of the show for us was the Chili Oysters- a truly unique and flavorful take. We got two more before leaving. We also really enjoyed the fluke tartare and mussels- the sauces on both of these dishes had us drinking them like soup! We both had the Salmon and were absolutely stuffed by the end of the meal. Will definitely be back:)

Came in with my dad on a Saturday night and we were blown away by this meal. The staff were extremely friendly, knowledgeable and attentive. The real star of the show for us was the Chili Oysters- a truly unique and flavorful take. We got two more before leaving. We also really enjoyed the fluke tartare and mussels- the sauces on both of these dishes had us drinking them like soup! We both had the Salmon and were absolutely stuffed by the end of the meal. Will definitely be back:)

Came in with my dad on a Saturday night and we were blown away by this meal. The staff were extremely friendly, knowledgeable and attentive. The real star of the show for us was the Chili Oysters- a truly unique and flavorful take. We got two more before leaving. We also really enjoyed the fluke tartare and mussels- the sauces on both of these dishes had us drinking them like soup! We both had the Salmon and were absolutely stuffed by the end of the meal. Will definitely be back:)

Came in with my dad on a Saturday night and we were blown away by this meal. The staff were extremely friendly, knowledgeable and attentive. The real star of the show for us was the Chili Oysters- a truly unique and flavorful take. We got two more before leaving. We also really enjoyed the fluke tartare and mussels- the sauces on both of these dishes had us drinking them like soup! We both had the Salmon and were absolutely stuffed by the end of the meal. Will definitely be back:)

Came in with my dad on a Saturday night and we were blown away by this meal. The staff were extremely friendly, knowledgeable and attentive. The real star of the show for us was the Chili Oysters- a truly unique and flavorful take. We got two more before leaving. We also really enjoyed the fluke tartare and mussels- the sauces on both of these dishes had us drinking them like soup! We both had the Salmon and were absolutely stuffed by the end of the meal. Will definitely be back:)

Came in with my dad on a Saturday night and we were blown away by this meal. The staff were extremely friendly, knowledgeable and attentive. The real star of the show for us was the Chili Oysters- a truly unique and flavorful take. We got two more before leaving. We also really enjoyed the fluke tartare and mussels- the sauces on both of these dishes had us drinking them like soup! We both had the Salmon and were absolutely stuffed by the end of the meal. Will definitely be back:)

Reply from Sagaponack 2025.10.21

Hi Avery,

Wow, thank you! We’re thrilled you and your dad had such a memorable night 🦪✨. So glad the Chili Oysters stole the show — nothing makes us happier than hearing guests go back for seconds! We’re also delighted you enjoyed the fluke tartare, mussels, and salmon. Can’t wait to welcome you back for another ocean-to-plate adventure soon!

Cheers,
Team Sagaponack

H C 2025.10.18

他們 Happy Hour 的 $1 生蠔真的超值，新鮮肥美、完全無腥味！酒的選擇也不少，價格相當親民。不過其他 HH 小點就比較普通，多半是預製品，薯條也不夠酥脆。整體環境優雅、氣氛不錯，很適合小酌聊天。

他們 Happy Hour 的 $1 生蠔真的超值，新鮮肥美、完全無腥味！
酒的選擇也不少，價格相當親民。
不過其他 HH 小點就比較普通，多半是預製品，薯條也不夠酥脆。
整體環境優雅、氣氛不錯，很適合小酌聊天。

他們 Happy Hour 的 $1 生蠔真的超值，新鮮肥美、完全無腥味！
酒的選擇也不少，價格相當親民。
不過其他 HH 小點就比較普通，多半是預製品，薯條也不夠酥脆。
整體環境優雅、氣氛不錯，很適合小酌聊天。

他們 Happy Hour 的 $1 生蠔真的超值，新鮮肥美、完全無腥味！
酒的選擇也不少，價格相當親民。
不過其他 HH 小點就比較普通，多半是預製品，薯條也不夠酥脆。
整體環境優雅、氣氛不錯，很適合小酌聊天。

他們 Happy Hour 的 $1 生蠔真的超值，新鮮肥美、完全無腥味！
酒的選擇也不少，價格相當親民。
不過其他 HH 小點就比較普通，多半是預製品，薯條也不夠酥脆。
整體環境優雅、氣氛不錯，很適合小酌聊天。

他們 Happy Hour 的 $1 生蠔真的超值，新鮮肥美、完全無腥味！
酒的選擇也不少，價格相當親民。
不過其他 HH 小點就比較普通，多半是預製品，薯條也不夠酥脆。
整體環境優雅、氣氛不錯，很適合小酌聊天。

他們 Happy Hour 的 $1 生蠔真的超值，新鮮肥美、完全無腥味！
酒的選擇也不少，價格相當親民。
不過其他 HH 小點就比較普通，多半是預製品，薯條也不夠酥脆。
整體環境優雅、氣氛不錯，很適合小酌聊天。

他們 Happy Hour 的 $1 生蠔真的超值，新鮮肥美、完全無腥味！
酒的選擇也不少，價格相當親民。
不過其他 HH 小點就比較普通，多半是預製品，薯條也不夠酥脆。
整體環境優雅、氣氛不錯，很適合小酌聊天。

他們 Happy Hour 的 $1 生蠔真的超值，新鮮肥美、完全無腥味！
酒的選擇也不少，價格相當親民。
不過其他 HH 小點就比較普通，多半是預製品，薯條也不夠酥脆。
整體環境優雅、氣氛不錯，很適合小酌聊天。

他們 Happy Hour 的 $1 生蠔真的超值，新鮮肥美、完全無腥味！
酒的選擇也不少，價格相當親民。
不過其他 HH 小點就比較普通，多半是預製品，薯條也不夠酥脆。
整體環境優雅、氣氛不錯，很適合小酌聊天。

他們 Happy Hour 的 $1 生蠔真的超值，新鮮肥美、完全無腥味！
酒的選擇也不少，價格相當親民。
不過其他 HH 小點就比較普通，多半是預製品，薯條也不夠酥脆。
整體環境優雅、氣氛不錯，很適合小酌聊天。

他們 Happy Hour 的 $1 生蠔真的超值，新鮮肥美、完全無腥味！
酒的選擇也不少，價格相當親民。
不過其他 HH 小點就比較普通，多半是預製品，薯條也不夠酥脆。
整體環境優雅、氣氛不錯，很適合小酌聊天。

Martin Pool 2025.10.17

Reply from Sagaponack 2025.10.21

Hi Martin,

Thanks for the feedback! Happy you enjoyed the eats and service — we’ll work on making the atmosphere just as amazing next time 🌟.

Team Sagaponack

Alyssa Caprio 2025.10.12

Amazing food and service 🌸 Oysters are amazing

Reply from Sagaponack 2025.10.21

Hi Alyssa,

Thank you so much! We’re thrilled you enjoyed the oysters — they’re our little ocean treasures 🌊🦪. So glad the food and service hit the mark, and we can’t wait to welcome you back for another amazing meal!

Best,
Team Sagaponack

Marianne Grandjean 2025.10.11

sanjana agarwal 2025.10.10

The cocktails and appetizers were good.

Reply from Sagaponack 2025.10.21

Hi Sanjana,

Thank you for the kind words! We’re glad you enjoyed the cocktails and appetizers. Can’t wait to welcome you back for another great experience!

Best,
Team Sagaponack

Company activity

Claimed Profile
Displaying Reviews
Replies To Reviews In Weeks
Replied to 82% of reviews
Top Rated Certificate

About Sagaponack

Sagaponack

TOP 5 Trustindex Features

100+ Review Platforms

40 Breathtaking review widgets

Easy review collection

Review image generator

Review e-mail signatures

Create a Free account