Putnam's Pub & Cooker Reviews 2025 | Trustindex.io

Write a review

Reviews

4.4 | 990 total

5 stars

603 pcs

4 stars

234 pcs

3 stars

89 pcs

2 stars

29 pcs

1 star

35 pcs

Source filter

990 pcs

Verified

Nick Felker 2025.12.17

We came here on a Wednesday during Negroni Week. We noticed there was a comedy show happening downstairs, we were more eager for food. I got a mac & cheese and a Negroni. The entree was very cheesy and a great companion to my cocktail.

Useful Report

Reply from Putnam's Pub & Cooker 2025.12.18

Thanks Nick. Come back again soon - we're serving traditional Negronis all year & currently have a smokey Fireside Negroni!

Jahmal Julien 2025.12.13

Phenomenal. One of the best steaks I've had for the price. That peppercorn au jus is to live for. Simply sensational. I got my favorite spot to sit at and everything.

Useful Report

Reply from Putnam's Pub & Cooker 2025.12.13

Thank you Jahmal. Agreed on the steak and peppercorn sauce! So glad that you discovered it. See you again soon.

Jane Solis 2025.12.07

Great service! Been going here for years now and always have a great time and great drinks! Have also been to a couple birthday parties here at the atmosphere and service is always 10/10!

Useful Report

Reply from Putnam's Pub & Cooker 2025.12.07

Thanks Jane! We appreciate the feedback :) come back again soon

Matthew Greenway 2025.12.03

Useful Report

Reply from Putnam's Pub & Cooker 2025.12.03

Thanks Matthew. Hope to see you again soon.

K A D 2025.11.25

I went here for an early Saturday dinner, it was my first time and it won't be my last time . It's a nice place with a nice atmosphere, they were playing great music at just the right volume so you can still have a conversation and enjoy the music with your dinner. The service was good, my server ( Skinny and tall I think his name was Jake) was really attentive and welcoming. I couldn't ask for anything better. He recommended the steak and the dessert, which were both very enjoyable. Their NY strip steak with the au poivre sauce was really good .I also had some oysters and I tried the molten chocolate lava cake, served with a scoop of vanilla ice cream and crushed peanuts, for dessert and it was a perfect way to top off my meal. The only criticism I have for them is the fish and chips, we didn't enjoy it at all, it had way too much batter for our liking but everything else was so great I still gave them 5 stars but please guys, that fish and chips recipe needs overhauling.

Useful Report

Reply from Putnam's Pub & Cooker 2025.11.25

Thanks KAD! We're very happy to have you as a customer. See you again soon. Thanks for all of your feedback - it means a lot.

Nicolette Anthony 2025.11.25

super cozy neighborhood spot. tasty food, very kid friendly.

Useful Report

Reply from Putnam's Pub & Cooker 2025.11.25

Thanks Nicolette!

Ahmad El-Sheemy 2025.11.18

Useful Report

Reply from Putnam's Pub & Cooker 2025.11.18

Thank you Ahmad. We look forward to having you back soon!

Alena Williams 2025.11.10

I came here for my cousin's wedding reception and I was highly disappointed with the service, drinks and food. The bartender was rude slow and made terrible drinks. the service was so terrible people had to go upstairs to the restaurant to order drinks. The Buffalo wings were slimy and just wack. Overall it is a great place to take pictures but that's it I will not be back

Useful Report

gary scott 2025.11.05

Great local place

Useful Report

Reply from Putnam's Pub & Cooker 2025.11.06

Thanks Gary. Hope to see you again soon.

Stephen Sandberg 2025.11.05

Artichoke salad was so amazing, really great spot to hang out as well

Useful Report

Reply from Putnam's Pub & Cooker 2025.11.06

Thanks Stephen! Glad that you loved the salad.

cimberly hajdari 2025.10.28

James was amazing… we came on a night where he was by himself and he was on the ball the entire time… made me and my company feel welcomed and appreciated to be there, service was nothing short of top tier !! Must come on a day he is here !!

Useful Report

Sindy J 2025.10.28

Did not expect to be blown away by the service at this place, James was an amazing host, he was very attentive and sweet for being the only one working. Would definitely recommend, the food was a 11/10 as well.

Useful Report

Reply from Putnam's Pub & Cooker 2025.10.30

Thanks Sindy! Come back soon