Popei's Reviews 2026 | Trustindex.io

Write a review

Reviews

4.6 | 2405 total

5 stars

1817 pcs

4 stars

413 pcs

3 stars

95 pcs

2 stars

27 pcs

1 star

53 pcs

Source filter

2405 pcs

Verified

sandra g 2026.04.04

Decided to go because of a Facebook post. Food was good. A lot of their dishes have the "crab meat" stuffing, there really is no crab meat, It's a lot of stuffing instead. That's the only disappointment that I had. Drinks were OK, I am pretty much the bartender at home during holidays so unfortunately, no one makes the drinks as good as me… Good atmosphere , great service very attentive . I would go back and I do recommend This restaurant.

Useful Report

Reply from Popei's

Thank you very much Sandra, next time you’re in, please let me know. I’m going to personally make you a crab meat stuffing you’ll never forget.!!! Yum!!!!

Frugal Cyclist 2026.04.04

SEAFOOD SENSATION 🥇🥇 MADNESS: The glorious clam bake goes for $39.99 on Monday (usually $55). You get a full lobster, clams, mussels, & shrimp. It also comes with a side dish of pasta, waffle fries, or salad. Paired well with the Sauvignon Blanc. The complimentary garlic bread is superb 👍. The waitresses are friendly and gave us good recommendations. Thank you 🙏🏻 Janice. Popei’s serves quality seafood at reasonable prices. Much value to be had here.

Useful (1) Report

Reply from Popei's

Thank you so much frugal. The clam bake is definitely one of my favorites also

Ursula Forte 2026.04.01

I would highly recommend this restaurant. Went for dinner with another couple. Three of us ordered from the pick two menu and another ordered the broiled combo. Everything was absolutely delicious and the service was top notch.

Useful Report

Reply from Popei's

Thank you so much, Ursula, look forward to seeing you again, sorry I missed you tonight!! Joe

Louis Ciolino 2026.03.27

Useful Report

Reply from Popei's

Thank you very much

Veronica Binick 2026.03.22

Just celebrated our 51st anniversary. Kristina made me a chocolate martini that was absolutely delicious!! Should be on the menu as a martini egg cream! She is the sweetest server!! Food delicious as usual. Been going sine youngesson played red devil.

Useful Report

Reply from Popei's

Happy anniversary! So glad you enjoyed everything chocolate martinis are one of my favorites!!

Peter Bessler 2026.03.21

Definitely my go to seafood spot. Portions are huge and prices are fair. I would 10/10 come here over red lobster where the prices are higher and don’t have near as big as a selection. I def recommend the shell fish dishes here like the muscles steam pots, linguine with the works, and the Cajun seafood boils. You can’t honestly go wrong with whatever you pick though. Might I say one of the best ceasar salads it’s my favorite. Huge shout out to gabby the amazing server there who goes above and beyond to make sure you leave happy.

Useful (1) Report

Joann Coleman 2026.03.19

Useful Report

Reply from Popei's

Thank you very much

Martinez Lyles 2026.03.07

Useful (1) Report

Reply from Popei's

Glad you enjoy everything Martinez! We look forward to seeing you again!!

Phil B 2026.03.05

Useful (1) Report

Reply from Popei's

Thank you very much, Phil

natalie kwok 2026.03.02

went here with my date and was treated extremely unwell very disrespectful staff and unnecessary small remarks about orders

Useful Report

Reply from Popei's

Natalie, I would love to discuss this further. Something does not sound right here. My employees are trained to treat our guests with utmost respect. I apologize I would like to discuss this further. Please reach out to me at joe@popeisbethpage.com
You were At Popeis seafood in Bethpage, correct?

elizabeth mack 2026.02.28

Love it

Useful Report

Reply from Popei's

Thank you very much, Elizabeth. Glad you enjoyed everything.

Jax Man 2026.02.24

Useful (1) Report

Reply from Popei's

Thank you very much, Jays. Glad you enjoyed it all.

A O 2026.02.21

Listen folks this incredible restaurant is open for dinner. Call up and make a reservation! Absolutely amazing every time! The young lady who waited on our table was wonderful. I believe she said she has been with the restaurant for a year and a half. She also can sing Happy Birthday really well. Desert was also over the top!

Useful (1) Report

Reply from Popei's

Thank you very much!

marlon velasco 2026.02.20

Useful Report

Reply from Popei's

Thank you very much, Marlon. I’m glad you enjoyed everything. Hope to see you again soon.

shepherd 2026.02.15

food was fine, but an older white waitress spent her entire time making my date uncomfortable. was extremely impatient over dietary restrictions that i had checked previously with the host about. will not come back.

Useful Report

Reply from Popei's

Shepherd I like to discuss this further. Please contact me at joe@popeisbethpage.com

Tmoney Nice Papers 2026.02.08

Always good for dinner, never disappointed leaving here. The steak is delicious as well.

Useful (1) Report

Reply from Popei's

Thank you so much. I’m glad you enjoyed the steak. Yum.

Jay Burrowes 2026.02.08

Great EVERYTHING here... if i said anything was BAD I'd be lying. Other customers, ladies at the door and waitresses were ALL great! Made reservations for 7:45pm (i wanna say 7:30pm) got there 6:38pm and was swiftly seated. Ordered appetizers and they came out FAST like they knew I wanted them. Entrees came out but that BANGIN' bread came around twice and how could I have said NO to it! My wife and I definitely enjoyed everything here and ourselves without our kids hanging on to us. Would definitely go back

Useful (1) Report

Reply from Popei's

Thank you so much. I’m glad you enjoyed everything. We look forward to seeing you again.

Christina Mitchell 2026.01.27

The entrance doors are not handicap accessible. The entrance is also too narrow for oversized wheelchair. Their bathroom has a grab ball but it's too small for oversized wheelchair, especially with the baby changing table inside. I had a problem squeezing the inside. I will not be returning there ever ♿👎🏾.

Useful (1) Report

michelle zambrano 2026.01.22

My friend Dana recommend me this place , I was craving king crabs legs from long time . I finally was able to visit and eat here the food is delicious , the service was excellent our waitress Janice was excellent , she is very nice and sweet took good care of me and my fiancé . In overall I recommend this place.