Verified
This is our spot! Frequent this location, often during celebrations and Veterans Day and other yearly experiences. The food is always on point. The pancakes are always fat and the waitress is sometimes funny depending on their mood at the time of your visit.
This is a hidden gem in a community. Sometimes we can get a few looks when we walk into the building from guest like we were unicorns. But, There's a lot of diversity among the staff and we enjoy being there and feeling welcome by them.
Was suggest to try this diner by a local
Got the create your own omlette
Ham,sausage and cheddar
Cooked to perfection
Hash browns....crispy
Side order of bacon....very crispy as requested
Biscuit warm from the oven
Coffee was hot and fresh and pretty tasty
Could not have asked for a better waitress/waitresses
Food came out quick
Reply from Pelham Diner
2026.06.23
Thanks for trusting that local's suggestion—clearly a person of impeccable taste! Glad your create-your-own omelette turned out egg-actly how you dreamed it: ham, sausage, and cheddar all getting along perfectly in there. Those hash browns hitting the crispy threshold, extra-crispy bacon obeying orders, and that fresh-from-the-oven biscuit? We're basically running a breakfast crime syndicate over here—everything's guilty of being too good.
Super happy the coffee kept you fueled and the service was speedy (our waitresses do move like they've had three cups already). Come back soon and let us ruin your standards for every other diner forever.
See you next time you're craving that perfect plate!
Super happy the coffee kept you fueled and the service was speedy (our waitresses do move like they've had three cups already). Come back soon and let us ruin your standards for every other diner forever.
See you next time you're craving that perfect plate!
The pancakes are excellent and very large.
Reply from Pelham Diner
2026.06.23
Haha, our pancakes have entered the chat... and they brought reinforcements!
Glad those massive flapjacks hit the spot — we like to make sure when you order pancakes at Pelham, you’re committing to a full-on breakfast Everest. Excellent taste (both yours and the pancakes’).
Come back soon and tackle the next stack. Warning: they might demand a surrender flag halfway through.
See you for round two!
Glad those massive flapjacks hit the spot — we like to make sure when you order pancakes at Pelham, you’re committing to a full-on breakfast Everest. Excellent taste (both yours and the pancakes’).
Come back soon and tackle the next stack. Warning: they might demand a surrender flag halfway through.
See you for round two!
We went there for the first time and it was amazing!! We had lunch and everything was delicious!!
Reply from Pelham Diner
2026.06.23
Thank you so much! We're glad your first visit was a success. We like to think our food has a way of turning first-timers into regulars, so consider this your official warning. 😄 We appreciate the kind words and look forward to serving you again soon!
I would take the 6 hour drive and come back here. The food is amazing. The price is unreal cheap. Wish we had a place like this back home.
Reply from Pelham Diner
2026.06.23
Wow! A 6-hour drive is one thing, but a 12-hour round trip for diner food might be the best compliment we've ever received. 😄 We're glad you enjoyed the food and the prices. If you ever make the trip again, let us know, we may need to reserve you a parking spot and a booth!
The staff was very friendly and make you feel like family. The food is amazing, the taste of home cooking. Great place to eat. You have to check it out.
Reply from Pelham Diner
2026.06.23
Thank you for the wonderful review! We believe good food tastes even better when it's served with a smile, so we're glad you felt right at home. Around here, we treat everyone like family, just without asking you to help wash the dishes. We appreciate the kind words and look forward to seeing you again soon!
I have eaten here several times but last Friday I got a really substandard meal. A 14.95 meat and 3 I got to go. The mashed potatoes were so thin, the fork would not hold them. The carrots smelled like mold and were salty and the meatloaf sauce was like jar spaghetti sauce and super sweet. I was shocked. I could not believe it. I didn't open it till I got home and tried calling right away, no answer. I emailed them a few times no answer. The cobbler was good. I wanted a refund but they do seem to be interested in talking to me. Anyway, not going back. I understand there can be an off meal, but no reply is not good.
Reply from Pelham Diner
2026.05.27
This is Toni, owner of Pelham Diner, I sincerely apologize that your recent meal did not meet the standards you’ve come to expect from us. I understand your frustration and disappointment, especially after being a returning customer. I did respond within the hour of receiving your email so you may want to go back and check. It will not let me put a screenshot of my reponse with date/time stamp in this reply, but I would be happy to show you. I offered to provide you with a full refund, as customer satisfaction is very important to me. I also take our food quality very seriously. I appreciate your feedback and regret that this experience left you feeling unheard.
Great place ! The cinnamon rolls are amazing. If you are passing by like we were stop in and have some good food
Reply from Pelham Diner
2026.05.30
Thank you, Dustin, for your wonderful feedback! We're delighted to hear you enjoyed our cinnamon rolls. If you're ever nearby again, we'd love to serve you more of our delicious treats.