NYC Wholesale Diamonds Reviews

Excellent rating

5.0 | 264 reviews

Verified Company

www.nycwholesalediamonds.com Visit this website

Reviews

5.0

| 264 total

5 stars

263 pcs

4 stars

0 pc

3 stars

0 pc

2 stars

0 pc

1 star

1 pc

Source filter

264 pcs

Verified

Tatiana Tabacek 2025.11.03

Update!!! We got married on 10/25/25 and of course had to go back to Keith for our wedding bands… and he knocked it out of the park! Thanks again Keith, we are customers for life! After an unsuccessful trip to our premier local jeweler in Annapolis, my fiancé and I took a trip to New York for our birthdays and we decided to make a stop in the diamond district. While doing research beforehand, I quite literally googled “wholesale diamonds in NYC” and Keith’s aptly titled business popped up. I couldn’t believe his reviews! When I looked into his website further I realized that I had seen his TikTok’s before and I felt like I already knew him! I made an appointment for our last day in the city and it couldn’t have gone more perfectly. My fiancé had been a little hesitant at our previous ring appts due to large price tags attached to less than impressive stones. Keith showed us 3 stone options, the final being absolutely perfect and even better—within our budget! I had told him my specifications for the stone and setting and he more than exceeded them! Look no further when shopping for an engagement ring, Keith is your man!

Update!!!

We got married on 10/25/25 and of course had to go back to Keith for our wedding bands… and he knocked it out of the park! Thanks again Keith, we are customers for life!

After an unsuccessful trip to our premier local jeweler in Annapolis, my fiancé and I took a trip to New York for our birthdays and we decided to make a stop in the diamond district. While doing research beforehand, I quite literally googled “wholesale diamonds in NYC” and Keith’s aptly titled business popped up. I couldn’t believe his reviews! When I looked into his website further I realized that I had seen his TikTok’s before and I felt like I already knew him! I made an appointment for our last day in the city and it couldn’t have gone more perfectly. My fiancé had been a little hesitant at our previous ring appts due to large price tags attached to less than impressive stones. Keith showed us 3 stone options, the final being absolutely perfect and even better—within our budget! I had told him my specifications for the stone and setting and he more than exceeded them!

Look no further when shopping for an engagement ring, Keith is your man!

Update!!!

We got married on 10/25/25 and of course had to go back to Keith for our wedding bands… and he knocked it out of the park! Thanks again Keith, we are customers for life!

After an unsuccessful trip to our premier local jeweler in Annapolis, my fiancé and I took a trip to New York for our birthdays and we decided to make a stop in the diamond district. While doing research beforehand, I quite literally googled “wholesale diamonds in NYC” and Keith’s aptly titled business popped up. I couldn’t believe his reviews! When I looked into his website further I realized that I had seen his TikTok’s before and I felt like I already knew him! I made an appointment for our last day in the city and it couldn’t have gone more perfectly. My fiancé had been a little hesitant at our previous ring appts due to large price tags attached to less than impressive stones. Keith showed us 3 stone options, the final being absolutely perfect and even better—within our budget! I had told him my specifications for the stone and setting and he more than exceeded them!

Look no further when shopping for an engagement ring, Keith is your man!

Update!!!

We got married on 10/25/25 and of course had to go back to Keith for our wedding bands… and he knocked it out of the park! Thanks again Keith, we are customers for life!

After an unsuccessful trip to our premier local jeweler in Annapolis, my fiancé and I took a trip to New York for our birthdays and we decided to make a stop in the diamond district. While doing research beforehand, I quite literally googled “wholesale diamonds in NYC” and Keith’s aptly titled business popped up. I couldn’t believe his reviews! When I looked into his website further I realized that I had seen his TikTok’s before and I felt like I already knew him! I made an appointment for our last day in the city and it couldn’t have gone more perfectly. My fiancé had been a little hesitant at our previous ring appts due to large price tags attached to less than impressive stones. Keith showed us 3 stone options, the final being absolutely perfect and even better—within our budget! I had told him my specifications for the stone and setting and he more than exceeded them!

Look no further when shopping for an engagement ring, Keith is your man!

Update!!!

We got married on 10/25/25 and of course had to go back to Keith for our wedding bands… and he knocked it out of the park! Thanks again Keith, we are customers for life!

After an unsuccessful trip to our premier local jeweler in Annapolis, my fiancé and I took a trip to New York for our birthdays and we decided to make a stop in the diamond district. While doing research beforehand, I quite literally googled “wholesale diamonds in NYC” and Keith’s aptly titled business popped up. I couldn’t believe his reviews! When I looked into his website further I realized that I had seen his TikTok’s before and I felt like I already knew him! I made an appointment for our last day in the city and it couldn’t have gone more perfectly. My fiancé had been a little hesitant at our previous ring appts due to large price tags attached to less than impressive stones. Keith showed us 3 stone options, the final being absolutely perfect and even better—within our budget! I had told him my specifications for the stone and setting and he more than exceeded them!

Look no further when shopping for an engagement ring, Keith is your man!

Update!!!

We got married on 10/25/25 and of course had to go back to Keith for our wedding bands… and he knocked it out of the park! Thanks again Keith, we are customers for life!

After an unsuccessful trip to our premier local jeweler in Annapolis, my fiancé and I took a trip to New York for our birthdays and we decided to make a stop in the diamond district. While doing research beforehand, I quite literally googled “wholesale diamonds in NYC” and Keith’s aptly titled business popped up. I couldn’t believe his reviews! When I looked into his website further I realized that I had seen his TikTok’s before and I felt like I already knew him! I made an appointment for our last day in the city and it couldn’t have gone more perfectly. My fiancé had been a little hesitant at our previous ring appts due to large price tags attached to less than impressive stones. Keith showed us 3 stone options, the final being absolutely perfect and even better—within our budget! I had told him my specifications for the stone and setting and he more than exceeded them!

Look no further when shopping for an engagement ring, Keith is your man!

Reply from NYC Wholesale Diamonds 2023.11.27

Thank you so very much Tatiana for your beautiful words! Assisting you and Billy, and witnessing your amazing love was a complete and total joy!!

Eric 2025.10.09

Working with Keith was an incredible experience. I recently proposed to my fiancée, and the ring he helped me create was absolutely perfect. My fiancée was completely blown away. The diamond, the setting and the craftsmanship was stunning. It turned out even better than I imagined, and we've had so many of our family and friends comment on how beautiful and eye-catching it is. From the start, Keith was patient, honest, and incredibly knowledgeable. He took the time to walk me through everything, from understanding GIA certifications to what really matters when choosing a diamond and setting. I came into this process knowing very little, and he made sure I felt confident every step of the way. What could have been a very stressful experience ended up being really enjoyable and unforgettable. Huge thanks to Keith for helping make such an important moment even more special. I’ll absolutely be coming back for anything else I need. Can’t recommend him enough!

Working with Keith was an incredible experience. I recently proposed to my fiancée, and the ring he helped me create was absolutely perfect. My fiancée was completely blown away. The diamond, the setting and the craftsmanship was stunning. It turned out even better than I imagined, and we've had so many of our family and friends comment on how beautiful and eye-catching it is.

From the start, Keith was patient, honest, and incredibly knowledgeable. He took the time to walk me through everything, from understanding GIA certifications to what really matters when choosing a diamond and setting. I came into this process knowing very little, and he made sure I felt confident every step of the way. What could have been a very stressful experience ended up being really enjoyable and unforgettable.

Huge thanks to Keith for helping make such an important moment even more special. I’ll absolutely be coming back for anything else I need. Can’t recommend him enough!

Reply from NYC Wholesale Diamonds 2025.10.17

Thank you for very kind words Eric, it was my true honor and pleasure to play my small part in your happiness

Jason Re 2025.10.09

Keith is an excellent provider and resource for allthings diamonds, and an even better person! He is dedicated to delivering the best for his clients, while also teaching them along the way. I just wanted to thank you, Keith, so much for all the help/guidance through this process, for all the expertise, and for being a part of our story. We’re absolutely thrilled, and we couldn’t be happier with the ring and your role (not only will we recommend you, of course, but I think my fiancee has a couple projects in mind down the road). Five stars!!

Keith is an excellent provider and resource for allthings diamonds, and an even better person! He is dedicated to delivering the best for his clients, while also teaching them along the way. I just wanted to thank you, Keith, so much for all the help/guidance through this process, for all the expertise, and for being a part of our story. We’re absolutely thrilled, and we couldn’t be happier with the ring and your role (not only will we recommend you, of course, but I think my fiancee has a couple projects in mind down the road). Five stars!!

Keith is an excellent provider and resource for allthings diamonds, and an even better person! He is dedicated to delivering the best for his clients, while also teaching them along the way. I just wanted to thank you, Keith, so much for all the help/guidance through this process, for all the expertise, and for being a part of our story. We’re absolutely thrilled, and we couldn’t be happier with the ring and your role (not only will we recommend you, of course, but I think my fiancee has a couple projects in mind down the road). Five stars!!

Keith is an excellent provider and resource for allthings diamonds, and an even better person! He is dedicated to delivering the best for his clients, while also teaching them along the way. I just wanted to thank you, Keith, so much for all the help/guidance through this process, for all the expertise, and for being a part of our story. We’re absolutely thrilled, and we couldn’t be happier with the ring and your role (not only will we recommend you, of course, but I think my fiancee has a couple projects in mind down the road). Five stars!!

Reply from NYC Wholesale Diamonds 2025.10.10

Thank you Jason for your trust, and extremely kind words. I will always be here for you both

Casey Davern 2025.10.06

Keith was an absolute pleasure to work with. He offers knowledge, insight, patience, and outstanding products at an incredible value. I would never have a single hesitation in recommending his business to anyone searching for some mineral magic and joy! My new diamond stud earrings are show stoppers, and beyond anything I could dream of owning. I walk around like a movie star now! I feel like I have a friend in the Diamond District now. Thanks so much Keith!

Reply from NYC Wholesale Diamonds 2025.10.06

Such an honor and pleasure to assist such a special lady as you Casey!

Brendan Carroll 2025.09.02

Went to NYC wholesale diamonds to get an engagement ring for my now fiancé, truly an incredible experience from start to finish. From the first interaction Keith and his whole team make you feel welcome and use their immense knowledge to help get your perfect ring. I will, and already have, recommend them to anyone I know in need of a jeweler. Easiest 5 star review I have ever given!

Reply from NYC Wholesale Diamonds 2025.09.03

You are a true gentleman Brendan, it was my honor and pleasure to asisst

Michaelangelo Gerardi 2025.08.18

Found Keith on Tiktok, and happy I did. My fiancée loves her ring. Thank you Keith

Reply from NYC Wholesale Diamonds 2025.08.19

Wishing you both every happiness life has to offer Mike!

Nariyoshi Miyagi 2025.08.16

Reply from NYC Wholesale Diamonds 2025.08.25

You must have the wrong business as you have never been at my office, called, or email us ever

PISHOI MISDARY 2025.08.11

Absolutely magnificent to work with! Honest man and true to his word! My fiancé said the ring Keith made was absolutely perfect. A pleasure working with Keith. Would absolutely recommend!

Reply from NYC Wholesale Diamonds 2025.08.19

These complements from such a special man is the highlight of my year! Thank you Pichoi

Andrew Lipman 2025.08.11

Keith was the best to work with! The diamond and ring came out incredible and at an extremely fair price! I would definitely recommend him and buy from him again in the future!

Reply from NYC Wholesale Diamonds 2025.08.19

An honor an dpleasure Andrew, you were a true joy to work with throughout the exciting process!

Ian Folan 2025.08.10

Kieth is hands down the best jeweler I could have asked for. All my worries and questions were immediately quelled once we sat down and made my engagement ring purchase a dream. Cannot say enough great things!!!

Reply from NYC Wholesale Diamonds 2025.08.10

An honor and pleasure to play my small part in your happiness Ian!

Jack Patterson 2025.07.28

I wanted to take a moment to share my wonderful experience with Keith. As someone who has very little knowledge about diamonds, I was quite apprehensive about what to look for or even where get started. Keith's expertise and insightful guidance made the process incredibly smooth and enjoyable. He took the time to educate me about the various aspects of diamond selection, helping me make an informed decision and creating a beautiful ring for my fiancée. Keith's patience and professionalism are truly remarkable. He went above and beyond to address all my questions and concerns, making me feel confident in my choice. No topic was off limits, and his insights were truly helpful in making my decision. I highly recommend Keith for all your diamond/jewelry needs. Thank you Keith for all of your help, and I look forward to working with you soon!

I wanted to take a moment to share my wonderful experience with Keith. As someone who has very little knowledge about diamonds, I was quite apprehensive about what to look for or even where get started. Keith's expertise and insightful guidance made the process incredibly smooth and enjoyable. He took the time to educate me about the various aspects of diamond selection, helping me make an informed decision and creating a beautiful ring for my fiancée.

Keith's patience and professionalism are truly remarkable. He went above and beyond to address all my questions and concerns, making me feel confident in my choice. No topic was off limits, and his insights were truly helpful in making my decision. I highly recommend Keith for all your diamond/jewelry needs.

Thank you Keith for all of your help, and I look forward to working with you soon!

Reply from NYC Wholesale Diamonds 2025.07.28

Jack, a true honor to assist such a loving gentleman Wishing you every happiness together always!

Matt Sica 2025.06.10

Keith and his team are the absolute best. Reached out to over 10 jewelers before purchasing a ring and NYC Wholesale Diamonds was the best not only in price, but in teaching me about diamonds as well. Would highly highly recommend, nobody better out there! Thanks again Keith!

Reply from NYC Wholesale Diamonds 2025.06.10

A true honor and pleasure to assist such a caring gentlemen as you Matt

Mary Gorry Photography 2025.05.05

Simply the best jeweler out there. My husband found Keith on TikTok and got my STUNNING engagement ring from him. He raved about the process and Keith himself. Over the past few years, we’ve gotten our wedding bands, earrings and pendent necklace all to match. We live in NC and I’m amazed every time we receive a package from him in the mail because it never fails to amaze us and go beyond our expectations. We will continue to use Keith for all our future jewelry needs. Thank you!!

Simply the best jeweler out there. My husband found Keith on TikTok and got my STUNNING engagement ring from him. He raved about the process and Keith himself. Over the past few years, we’ve gotten our wedding bands, earrings and pendent necklace all to match. We live in NC and I’m amazed every time we receive a package from him in the mail because it never fails to amaze us and go beyond our expectations. We will continue to use Keith for all our future jewelry needs. Thank you!!

Simply the best jeweler out there. My husband found Keith on TikTok and got my STUNNING engagement ring from him. He raved about the process and Keith himself. Over the past few years, we’ve gotten our wedding bands, earrings and pendent necklace all to match. We live in NC and I’m amazed every time we receive a package from him in the mail because it never fails to amaze us and go beyond our expectations. We will continue to use Keith for all our future jewelry needs. Thank you!!

Simply the best jeweler out there. My husband found Keith on TikTok and got my STUNNING engagement ring from him. He raved about the process and Keith himself. Over the past few years, we’ve gotten our wedding bands, earrings and pendent necklace all to match. We live in NC and I’m amazed every time we receive a package from him in the mail because it never fails to amaze us and go beyond our expectations. We will continue to use Keith for all our future jewelry needs. Thank you!!

Reply from NYC Wholesale Diamonds 2025.05.06

Mary, it is my honor and pleasure to play my small part in your happiness. So appreciate your kind words

Kyle Dedrick 2025.04.19

Keith did a tremendous job with my engagement ring. He did a great job of teaching me about the important aspects of the process, then presenting me with many ring options, doing a detailed review of each ring including the certifications, and then crafting the perfect ring for my fiancé. He also had the ring made in record time. Overall, I highly recommend Keith

Reply from NYC Wholesale Diamonds 2025.04.20

An honor and pleasure Kyle. Wishing you and Kerry every happiness life has to offer always!

Hunter Clutz 2025.04.16

Keith could not have made my engagement ring shopping any easier or more smooth. He is truly a wealth of knowledge when it comes to the space, but most importantly, he is an honest man. Keith took the time to educate me regarding diamonds, how they are priced, insurance, and even tips on how to pull off the perfect proposal. I could not be more grateful for his guidance as he made what is often a stressful experience, fun and comfortable. 1000/10 recommend.

Reply from NYC Wholesale Diamonds 2025.08.10

Hunter, it was my true pleasure and honor to asist such a wonderful Couple!

logan shoap 2025.03.21

Keith was absolutely phenomenal throughout the entire ring buying process. He was very responsive to emails and calls, qnd was very reassuring. He is also very reasonable with the wholesale price of the high quality ring. I would definitely recommend NYC Wholesale Diamonds to any lucky couple shopping for rings.

Keith was absolutely phenomenal throughout the entire ring buying process. He was very responsive to emails and calls, qnd was very reassuring. He is also very reasonable with the wholesale price of the high quality ring. I would definitely recommend NYC Wholesale Diamonds to any lucky couple shopping for rings.

Reply from NYC Wholesale Diamonds 2025.03.23

Thank you Logan, your love and infinite effort during this wonderful process was so admirable and touching!

Daniel 2025.03.19

Keith was the best! He answered every question my fiancé and I had, showed us tons of options, and was so patient and honest throughout the whole process. He made everything fun and really helped us make the most of our budget. The 4-carat natural diamond ring he created is absolutely stunning.

Keith was the best! He answered every question my fiancé and I had, showed us tons of options, and was so patient and honest throughout the whole process. He made everything fun and really helped us make the most of our budget. The 4-carat natural diamond ring he created is absolutely stunning.

Reply from NYC Wholesale Diamonds 2025.03.19

My true honor and pleasure to assist such a loving gentleman like you Daniel. Wishing you happiness and success togther always!

Juan Santos 2025.02.08

Graham Voss 2025.01.17

Keith was a pleasure to work with! Excellent communication throughout the process coupled with top-tier quality and craftsmanship. We could not be happier with our engagement ring.

Reply from NYC Wholesale Diamonds 2025.01.30

Congrats Graham on your incredibly romantic proposal to Elivia in Switzerland! Thank you so much for this kind review

Jackson Aaron 2025.01.04

I met Keith after being referred by a co-worker who had purchased an engagement ring from him. From the first time I met Keith I knew he was a true professional. Keith helps during the whole process from start to finish. Once you’re ready to make a purchase he’ll help you understand what goes into the pricing of a diamond and industry terminology He will work with you to find the best diamond and ring for your budget. Any of my friends who are getting engaged there’s only 1 person I’ll be telling them to work with. He made the experience easy, I learned about diamonds and felt confident I made a great purchase. My fiancée loved the ring and so did everyone else! I wouldn’t recommend anyone other than Keith Saxe of NYC Wholesale Diamonds. 10/10.

I met Keith after being referred by a co-worker who had purchased an engagement ring from him. From the first time I met Keith I knew he was a true professional. Keith helps during the whole process from start to finish. Once you’re ready to make a purchase he’ll help you understand what goes into the pricing of a diamond and industry terminology He will work with you to find the best diamond and ring for your budget. Any of my friends who are getting engaged there’s only 1 person I’ll be telling them to work with. He made the experience easy, I learned about diamonds and felt confident I made a great purchase. My fiancée loved the ring and so did everyone else! I wouldn’t recommend anyone other than Keith Saxe of NYC Wholesale Diamonds. 10/10.

I met Keith after being referred by a co-worker who had purchased an engagement ring from him. From the first time I met Keith I knew he was a true professional. Keith helps during the whole process from start to finish. Once you’re ready to make a purchase he’ll help you understand what goes into the pricing of a diamond and industry terminology He will work with you to find the best diamond and ring for your budget. Any of my friends who are getting engaged there’s only 1 person I’ll be telling them to work with. He made the experience easy, I learned about diamonds and felt confident I made a great purchase. My fiancée loved the ring and so did everyone else! I wouldn’t recommend anyone other than Keith Saxe of NYC Wholesale Diamonds. 10/10.

Reply from NYC Wholesale Diamonds 2025.01.05

Thank you for the kind words Jackson. the love and effort you put into thsi process, always with a smile was wonderfuil to behold. Wishing you and Jacky every happiness togther always!

Company activity

Claimed Profile
Displaying Reviews
Replies To Reviews In 1 Day
Replied to 95% of reviews
Top Rated Certificate

About NYC Wholesale Diamonds

NYC Wholesale Diamonds is trusted by over 258 happy customers, earning a 5-star rating! Explore real reviews and share your own experience.

TOP 5 Trustindex Features

100+ Review Platforms

40 Breathtaking review widgets

Easy review collection

Review image generator

Review e-mail signatures

Create a Free account