Macchina Pizza Reviews

Agnieszka Cielecka 2026.05.09

     

Hands down one of the best pizzas I’ve had in long time! Crust on point, delicious perfectly seasoned sauce and nice touch of marinated tomatoes. My new go to spot! I feel like this place is way too underrated and deserve more hype!

Useful Report

Reply from Macchina Pizza 2026.05.11

Thanks for your review Agnieszka! We look forward to seeing you again soon!

Anna Cielecka 2026.03.15

     

Useful Report

Reply from Macchina Pizza 2026.03.23

Thanks for reviewing us, Anna!

Arzan Sam Wadia 2026.03.09

     

Ok Pizza.

Useful Report

Reply from Macchina Pizza 2026.03.23

Thank you for your feedback.

Nick Felker 2025.12.17

     

We grabbed a table outside after spending some time drinking. We were hungry enough to want a pizza before returning home. We got one margarita which came with a few very thin slices with a ton of flavor and a piece of burrata on top. Overall it was a great meal that capped off a great day.

Useful Report

Reply from Macchina Pizza 2025.12.29

Thank you so much for your review, Nick!

J. C. 2025.03.22

     

We just left this place and first off the food was heavily over salted, i got the steak. I asked for medium and they gave me well done. When we looked at our bill it was over $200. When we checked how did it come to this much, the waiter charged us a 20% tip without letting us know. He out “large party” when it was not myself, my wife and another couple and just my 2 toddler children. Next time let us know and do better, the service wasn’t great.

Useful Report

Gabby Beckford 2025.02.01

     

I was craving a burrata pizza and a nice glass of wine and took the train over from Manhattan. I called ahead and made sure that I wouldn't come all the way across the river at 7PM On a Friday and then be filled up but the guy who answered was very nice and told me to come in. (Apparently you can make reservations by calling, but we walked in and had no problem.) The Macchina and The Bedford are the same place! ❗️ Go into The Bedford. Anyway, it absolutely did not disappoint! Our waiter Alberto was very nice. I'm indecisive and asked to try the wine, and he brought out two additional for me to try. I settled on the Cabernet Sauvignon which was delicious. My roommate and I split the buratta pizza which was fantastic - the best pizza I've had in New York thus far, and it came out within 10 minutes of us sitting down. The burrata is fresh and cool, and the sauce is just. The crust is thin yet crunchy like I like and we really had an amazing time. At the end we chatted with Alberto a bit and he gave us a complimentary digestivo spicy drink that was really good. 10/10 honestly and we will be back!

Useful Report

Claire Mcmenamin 2025.01.16

     

Useful Report

shannon lee 2024.09.15

     

Soooo the service was fantastic but the pizza is horrible. The crust taste frozen. The sauce is idk not my cup of tea. That could just be me but really the crust is a problem. It’s nyc- go elsewhere for good pizza The rest of the menu looks like it has potential.

Useful Report

Jose Alvarado 2024.05.28

     

Every visit to Bedford Avenue leads me to this pizza haven. Their burrata pizza is a creamy dream, and the salad options are fresh and flavorful. Perfect spot for a quick bite that doesn’t compromise on quality.

Useful Report

Yanay Perera Reves 2024.04.29

     

Last night's date at Macchina was unforgettable. The cozy, retro ambiance made us feel like we were in a vintage Italian movie. The pizza was delicious, and the wine selection was top-notch. It's the perfect spot for a romantic evening.

Useful Report

Binoy Vasavada 2024.04.11

     

The Burrata pizza is mind blowing. It looks pretty & calls you to demolish it. There’s a giant blob of burrata right in the center that you gently cut & smother the creamy cheese. The sauce is great too, although I would have liked a spicy kick as the creaminess from burrata makes the sauce a little bland. Biggest complaint for this pizza is the crust. It’s way too thin and simply cannot hold the weight if the burrata. So it gets challenging to eat it. We also ordered Old Bay fries which were decent. Burrata lovers head to Macchina now!

Useful Report

Reply from Macchina Pizza 2024.04.26

Thank you for your review Binoy, we appreciate your feedback! Our house made burrata is definitely for burrata lovers!!!

Henry Smith 2024.04.02

     

I love that I can get a hearty salad and a slice of gourmet pizza in one place. It’s perfect for when you want something light but satisfying. The outdoor dining setup is a bonus for beautiful days.

Useful Report

Reply from Macchina Pizza 2024.04.26

Thank you for your review, Henry! We love hearing you enjoy our cuisine and outdoor patio 🥰☀️

Layla Zee 2024.04.01

     

Every time I visit Williamsburg, Macchina Pizza is my first stop. The spot is gorgeous and the pizza is always exceptional. Highly recommend to anyone looking for an authentic pizza experience in Brooklyn.

Useful Report

Reply from Macchina Pizza 2024.04.26

Thank you Layla, we love your feedback ❤️ See you again soon! 🍕

Michelle Torres 2024.03.09

     

Useful Report

Jennifer 2024.02.11

     

One of my favorite places to get Burrata pizza! I tried the meatballs and mac & cheese it was delicious.

Useful Report

Reply from Macchina Pizza 2024.04.26

Thanks for your review Jennifer! Glad you enjoy our housemade burrata 🥰nice pics!! ❤️

datasianjan 2023.10.24

     

Reasons for going: ♀️/♀️Date Night Pros: Great atmosphere Rustic/clean look Attentive/respectful staff Delicious cocktails/food Handicap accessible Clean bathroom Minor complaints: None Overall: Great place for first date, quiet enough to have an intimate conversation, casual Nicely decorated and good food. I had a great time. Thank you for the hospitality 📷@datasianjan

Useful Report

Jason Hahn 2023.10.22

     

Pros: Great location, really nice atmosphere. Cons: Service was slow. The burrata pizza was really bad. The outside crust was good but under the ingredients was a soggy, flimsy mess. It was basically a soup we ate with a fork.

Useful Report

Elphège Nora 2023.09.07

     

Great vibe. Good food. Open late. Fun cocktails

Useful Report

Reply from Macchina Pizza 2023.10.22

Thanks for your review, Elphège!

Abranny Djss 2023.06.22

     

Cute little spot for a intimate dinner. The place is really cute, service was kind of slow but everything we order was amazing *chef kiss*, I can here in a rush so I’m surely coming back to try more dishes and the brunch. Decoration: 10/10 Food: 10/10 Service: 9/10. our server were really nice 10/10; kitchen was slow but food was amazing so not a problem haha

Useful Report

Reply from Macchina Pizza 2023.10.22

Thank you so much for your review Abranny, glad you enjoyed your time at Macchina 😊 thanks for sharing your great pics!

Magnus Mootoo 2023.05.23

     

Incredible! I loved everything I had at this place. I was doing a stroll in the neighborhood and stopped in for dinner. Everything tasted so delicious and rich! I love this place. The food is really good and it has a very cozy atmosphere!

Useful Report

Reply from Macchina Pizza 2023.10.22

Glad you enjoyed your experience with us, Magnus! We look forward to seeing you again, thank you so much for your review.