Katz Jewelry Company New York Reviews

Excellent rating

5.0 | 33 reviews

Verified Company

Katz Jewelry Company New York

www.katzjewelryco.com Visit Katz Jewelry Company New York

Write a review

Reviews

5.0

| 33 total

5 stars

33 pcs

4 stars

0 pc

3 stars

0 pc

2 stars

0 pc

1 star

0 pc

Source filter

33 pcs

Verified

Sarabeth Goldberg 2025.12.04

From start to finish, working with Peter was an absolute dream. He is truly exceptional—so patient, knowledgeable, and incredibly passionate about what he does. He took the time to educate us on every detail, guided us through the entire process with honesty, expertise, and made us feel confident in every decision. You can tell he genuinely cares about creating something meaningful, not just making a transaction. And the ring… I am obsessed. The craftsmanship is flawless, the design is perfection, and every little detail feels intentional and more than i could’ve ever hoped for! You can clearly see the artistry and care that went into it. I cannot stop staring at my hand lol. On top of that, Peter delivered it in such a timely manner, which made the whole experience even more incredible. Truly above and beyond in every way.

From start to finish, working with Peter was an absolute dream. He is truly exceptional—so patient, knowledgeable, and incredibly passionate about what he does. He took the time to educate us on every detail, guided us through the entire process with honesty, expertise, and made us feel confident in every decision. You can tell he genuinely cares about creating something meaningful, not just making a transaction.

And the ring… I am obsessed. The craftsmanship is flawless, the design is perfection, and every little detail feels intentional and more than i could’ve ever hoped for! You can clearly see the artistry and care that went into it. I cannot stop staring at my hand lol.

On top of that, Peter delivered it in such a timely manner, which made the whole experience even more incredible. Truly above and beyond in every way.

From start to finish, working with Peter was an absolute dream. He is truly exceptional—so patient, knowledgeable, and incredibly passionate about what he does. He took the time to educate us on every detail, guided us through the entire process with honesty, expertise, and made us feel confident in every decision. You can tell he genuinely cares about creating something meaningful, not just making a transaction.

And the ring… I am obsessed. The craftsmanship is flawless, the design is perfection, and every little detail feels intentional and more than i could’ve ever hoped for! You can clearly see the artistry and care that went into it. I cannot stop staring at my hand lol.

On top of that, Peter delivered it in such a timely manner, which made the whole experience even more incredible. Truly above and beyond in every way.

From start to finish, working with Peter was an absolute dream. He is truly exceptional—so patient, knowledgeable, and incredibly passionate about what he does. He took the time to educate us on every detail, guided us through the entire process with honesty, expertise, and made us feel confident in every decision. You can tell he genuinely cares about creating something meaningful, not just making a transaction.

And the ring… I am obsessed. The craftsmanship is flawless, the design is perfection, and every little detail feels intentional and more than i could’ve ever hoped for! You can clearly see the artistry and care that went into it. I cannot stop staring at my hand lol.

On top of that, Peter delivered it in such a timely manner, which made the whole experience even more incredible. Truly above and beyond in every way.

From start to finish, working with Peter was an absolute dream. He is truly exceptional—so patient, knowledgeable, and incredibly passionate about what he does. He took the time to educate us on every detail, guided us through the entire process with honesty, expertise, and made us feel confident in every decision. You can tell he genuinely cares about creating something meaningful, not just making a transaction.

And the ring… I am obsessed. The craftsmanship is flawless, the design is perfection, and every little detail feels intentional and more than i could’ve ever hoped for! You can clearly see the artistry and care that went into it. I cannot stop staring at my hand lol.

On top of that, Peter delivered it in such a timely manner, which made the whole experience even more incredible. Truly above and beyond in every way.

Useful (1) Report

Reply from Katz Jewelry Company New York 2025.12.05

You are most welcome!!!
What a wonderful engagement story, and thank you for letting me use it on socials :)

chrisfreeman79 2025.09.25

So I recently worked with Peter to have my wife’s engagement & wedding rings upgraded for our 10th anniversary. The entire process went extremely smoothly, as Peter is a pleasure to work with and is always happy to answer questions and give recommendations. My wife loves the new rings. 10 out of 10 experience, I would definitely recommend.

Reply from Katz Jewelry Company New York 2025.12.05

Thanks so much! Hope all is well :)

Jay Bienstock 2025.09.11

I’ve had the pleasure of knowing Peter at Katz Jewelry Company for almost 30 years, and in all that time he has been nothing short of extraordinary to work with. Buying jewelry from Peter is not just a transaction—it’s an experience rooted in trust, fairness, and genuine care. He is smart, deeply knowledgeable about his craft, and always takes the time to make sure his customers walk away not only satisfied, but truly happy. I believe Peter cares as much about the joy his diamonds bring as he does about the diamonds themselves, and that says everything about the kind of person he is. Beyond being a consummate professional, Peter is a wonderful human being—a lovely guy with a great sense of humor and an even bigger heart. Over the years, I’ve come to appreciate that the only things bigger than his generosity and kindness are the brilliance and quality of the diamonds he provides. I will continue to buy from him again and again, and I sincerely hope more people discover Katz Jewelry Company and Peter’s incredible dedication to his customers.

Reply from Katz Jewelry Company New York 2025.12.05

Thanks Jay, it has been a long road, hasn't it!

Alison Reynolds 2025.07.31

My fiancé’s father bought an engagement ring from Peter decades ago. My fiancé returned with the original stone to get it reset to my style. Peter worked with him to make it perfect for a new life and a new love story while keeping the sentiment of family history. I’m exciting to be working with Peter now on a wedding band to match and he’s been so helpful and honest about the options and what will work for me. Even the dog loves it!

My fiancé’s father bought an engagement ring from Peter decades ago. My fiancé returned with the original stone to get it reset to my style. Peter worked with him to make it perfect for a new life and a new love story while keeping the sentiment of family history. I’m exciting to be working with Peter now on a wedding band to match and he’s been so helpful and honest about the options and what will work for me. Even the dog loves it!

Reply from Katz Jewelry Company New York 2025.12.05

Thanks so much Alison, that is a great picture! Paws up!

Bret Hardin 2025.06.16

Peter is an absolute professional and a pleasure to work with. He was attentive, responsive and worked fast. He helped make buying an engagement ring a wonderful experience, can't wait to use him again!

Reply from Katz Jewelry Company New York 2025.12.05

Bret, I appreciate the review so much. Sorry for my late reply - I do jewels, not computers! haha

Jill Kinison 2025.05.08

I texted Peter about a collection of family heirlooms, unsure of their history or value, and what I got back was not just fast replies, but with answers and a vision for a priceless necklace. Peter helped me understand each piece, what was salvageable and what could be traded for something different. He. reimagined them into a modern, stunning diamond necklace. It’s more than jewelry; it’s a piece of my home and generations of my family I now carry with me every day. I’m forever grateful.

I texted Peter about a collection of family heirlooms, unsure of their history or value, and what I got back was not just fast replies, but with answers and a vision for a priceless necklace. Peter helped me understand each piece, what was salvageable and what could be traded for something different. He. reimagined them into a modern, stunning diamond necklace. It’s more than jewelry; it’s a piece of my home and generations of my family I now carry with me every day. I’m forever grateful.

Useful (1) Report

Reply from Katz Jewelry Company New York 2025.12.05

Sometimes you just know! Thanks for the review Jill, hope all is well!

Mick Potthast 2025.04.14

After my brother worked with Peter to create my sister-in-law’s engagement ring, there was no question I’d be reaching out to him when the time came for myself. His kindness and patience made a process that seemed daunting feel effortless. He took my initial ideas and wishlist all into account, and his expertise and craftsmanship made it easy to trust his recommendations for any adjustments that would keep the ring unique, yet timeless. He always made me feel like my project was his top priority, with clear communication and updates throughout until the ring was physically in my hand. My now fiancé and I couldn’t be more thrilled with the outcome, and look forward to working with Katz again in the future. Thank you, Peter!

After my brother worked with Peter to create my sister-in-law’s engagement ring, there was no question I’d be reaching out to him when the time came for myself. His kindness and patience made a process that seemed daunting feel effortless. He took my initial ideas and wishlist all into account, and his expertise and craftsmanship made it easy to trust his recommendations for any adjustments that would keep the ring unique, yet timeless. He always made me feel like my project was his top priority, with clear communication and updates throughout until the ring was physically in my hand.

My now fiancé and I couldn’t be more thrilled with the outcome, and look forward to working with Katz again in the future. Thank you, Peter!

Reply from Katz Jewelry Company New York 2025.12.05

When it comes to rings like this, it's never just 'another day at the office', it's special, and I mean that - Thanks so much, best of luck to everyone!

Jake Dombrowski 2024.07.29

Go to Katz and talk to Peter if you need an engagement ring! He was so amazing in helping me choose a ring. My new Fiancé is so happy and all her friends can't stop telling her how gorgeous the ring is and asking her where she got the ring!

Reply from Katz Jewelry Company New York 2025.12.05

I hope it still shines bright, Jake - Thanks so much for the review!

Kevin Donovan 2024.05.16

I have been fortunate to work with Peter for 30 years. Nothing but the best from him every time. I trust him completely. I am remarried, and I recently purchased an engagement ring, wedding band and one year anniversary ring. Absolutely stunning craftsmanship & exemplary service as always. I highly recommend Katz Jewelry Company to anyone looking to purchase any kind of jewelry. Peter is a pleasure to work with, and I would give him 10 stars if I could.

Reply from Katz Jewelry Company New York 2025.12.05

I wish I could find those extra stars for you! Thanks so much KD!

Laura Schaefer 2024.04.15

Beautiful custom ring exceeded my expectations!

Useful (1) Report

Reply from Katz Jewelry Company New York 2025.12.05

Laura, you are so welcome!

Huck Metzger 2023.12.18

Reply from Katz Jewelry Company New York 2025.12.05

Thanks very much Huck!

Jim Caskie 2023.11.23

I recently purchased a diamond engagement ring from Katz Jewelry Co, and my expectations were blown away! Before this process started I knew little about jewelry and even less about diamonds. I was really nervous that I was going to get it all wrong! From the moment I talked with Peter, however, I knew I was in great hands. Peter is a great guy who is really dedicated to customer service. He was not only knowledgeable but also incredibly patient and accommodating. He took the time to educate me about diamonds, ensuring I made the decision that aligned with my fiancé’s preferences and our budget. He’s very informed on the latest trends in style within the industry, and offered guidance without any pressure. His suggestions truly made the difference in this ring! As for the ring… it is stunning! My fiancé gets compliments every day from family, friends, and random people she meets. And when I say compliments, I mean they are taken aback by how stunning her ring is. It is truly breathtaking. Peter’s diamonds are of extremely high quality and the color, cut, and clarity of this particular diamond were superb. The craftsmanship of the ring is amazing, and the attention to detail in the setting is perfect. The purchasing process was seamless. I live on the West Coast, and Peter securely shipped my ring. He was in constant communication with me, and I was never worried about the process. I highly recommend Peter to anyone in search of the perfect engagement ring or jewelry for any occasion. The combination of top-notch craftsmanship, a diverse and high-quality diamond selection, and exceptional customer service makes Peter a standout choice. He will no doubt be my first and only stop for any jewelry needs from now on. Thank you Peter and Katz Jewelry for making my engagement so special!!!

Reply from Katz Jewelry Company New York 2025.12.05

What a wonderful review - I am so late to replying (me and tech...), but thank you so much for taking the time to be so deliberate and detailed in your review to help other people really see what its all about. THANK YOU

Brian Klapper 2023.06.07

Peter is a fantastic jewelry “partner.” We have been coming to Katz Jewelry for over 40 years and he is thoughtful, honest and very easy to work with. I highly recommend both Peter and the company!

Reply from Katz Jewelry Company New York 2025.12.05

Thanks Brian (only 2 years late to reply!)

jennifer mannarino 2023.05.23

Peter uses the finest quality of gold and diamonds. Peter knows what the newest trends are, as well as the classiest looks around in jewelry. He helped me to create a necklace that exceeded my expectations. I was beyond ecstatic with the final product. He also created my engagement ring which I receive compliments with on a daily basis. Peter is very pleasant to work with and very very knowledgable with in the field. He knows what works!

Reply from Katz Jewelry Company New York 2025.12.05

Only the best for you, Jennifer, thanks so much!

Danny Potthast 2023.04.30

Peter is one of the most easily likable people you'll ever meet within the first 5 minutes of working with him. The level of hospitality he brings while working with him makes it easy to do business with Katz. He is truly a very good person with kindness in his heart. The craftsmanship and gorgeous precision of their jewelry are unmatched. They never cease to impress. Thank you for the beautiful work you all have done to make our engagement and wedding everything we could hope for.

Reply from Katz Jewelry Company New York 2025.12.05

I may work with the fancy stuff, but I don't need to be fancy myself. Thanks so much :)

JP Rotchford 2022.12.29

If six stars we're an option, Peter would deserve it. He handled my wife's engagement ring and both our wedding bands. He provided great advice, found the right gems for all the pieces, and crafted perfect pieces to celebrate our marriage. He is also an absolute delight to work with; a true professional and a kind man. Peter was such an essential part of our journey from engagement to marriage, and we can only hope that Katz Jewelry continues to be part of our lives in the future.

If six stars we're an option, Peter would deserve it. He handled my wife's engagement ring and both our wedding bands. He provided great advice, found the right gems for all the pieces, and crafted perfect pieces to celebrate our marriage. He is also an absolute delight to work with; a true professional and a kind man. Peter was such an essential part of our journey from engagement to marriage, and we can only hope that Katz Jewelry continues to be part of our lives in the future.

If six stars we're an option, Peter would deserve it. He handled my wife's engagement ring and both our wedding bands. He provided great advice, found the right gems for all the pieces, and crafted perfect pieces to celebrate our marriage. He is also an absolute delight to work with; a true professional and a kind man. Peter was such an essential part of our journey from engagement to marriage, and we can only hope that Katz Jewelry continues to be part of our lives in the future.

Useful (1) Report

Reply from Katz Jewelry Company New York 2025.12.05

These photos are beautiful, thank you for adding them, thanks for the review, and I know where the extra star is - The sparkle is on her finger!!!

Thanks so much!

Nicholas DiSomma 2022.08.15

Couldn't be happier with the whole process with Peter from start to finish. He was always very responsive, timely and educational. Peter was able to teach me so much about diamonds and make sure I felt comfortable with the purchase. He gave me the fairest price and guided me through an appraisal and insurance process. His process is very professional and clear. Couldn't recommend more!

Reply from Katz Jewelry Company New York 2022.10.09

Thanks so much Nicholas, it was my pleasure to help you on your diamond journey.

Jairo 2022.07.02

Peter was excellent and was patient through out my custom made chain. I don't have any complaints. Everything was made on schedule and on time. Peter thank-you very much for your service. I appreciate your customer care.

Reply from Katz Jewelry Company New York 2022.10.09

Jairo, you are most welcome, enjoy the chain!

Sasanka K 2021.11.26

Peter is a true professional. I was referred to him by a family friend, and went into the whole process of buying an engagement ring clueless. He helped me understand all the things I needed to know in order to make the right choice, found the perfect diamond for my fiance, and made the ring for us. She loves it. I would highly recommend him for anyone needing help with buying jewelry.

Reply from Katz Jewelry Company New York 2022.10.09

Thank you very much Sasanka, so happy for you two!

charles caruso 2021.04.27

Peter Kahan of Katz Jewelry made long distance business with him easy. His knowledge in the business helped me reach my jewelry goals. My sweetheart is so pleased with her gift,a ring matched with one given to me many years ago by a cherished family member. An honorable man,his word is his bond. Thanks Peter...

Reply from Katz Jewelry Company New York 2021.05.09

Thank you sir! Glad to help you ANY DAY!

Company activity

Claimed Profile
Displaying Reviews
Replies To Reviews In Months
Replied to 100% of reviews
Top Rated Certificate

About Katz Jewelry Company New York

Katz Jewelry Company New York is trusted by over 29 happy customers, earning a 5-star rating! Explore real reviews and share your own experience.

TOP 5 Trustindex Features

100+ Review Platforms

40 Breathtaking review widgets

Easy review collection

Review image generator

Review e-mail signatures

Create a Free account