Isla & Co. - Midtown Reviews

Caroline Welch 2025.12.05

     

Delicious burger, great drink and burger deal on Thursday, lovely happy hour menu and very kind waitstaff. Nice ambiance too! Overall would come back

Useful Report

Brian Shu 2025.12.05

     

so good

Useful Report

Carlo Catalano 2025.12.05

     

Useful Report

Ian Olexio 2025.12.05

     

Useful Report

cedric washington 2025.12.05

     

Useful Report

Michael Cascione 2025.12.05

     

Jay was great

Useful Report

Leah Cloninger 2025.12.05

     

Jay was fantastic!

Useful Report

Carmina Zamora 2025.12.04

     

Jay is the most fabulous of all servers. Thank u for existing! You should get a raise.

Useful Report

Rosa Coronel 2025.12.04

     

Jay is so amazing has a great attitude and personality ! Love the service

Useful Report

Washington kanlong 2025.12.04

     

Useful Report

Katie Benson 2025.12.04

     

Useful Report

Stephanie Traut 2025.12.04

     

Love Jay ❤️

Useful Report

Reply from Isla & Co. - Midtown 2025.12.04

Thanks for the review, legend! We can't wait to welcome you back real soon!

W Y 2025.12.04

     

Useful Report

Janessa Martinez 2025.12.04

     

Amazing amazing amazing! The food is in great portions and taste so good!

Useful Report

Reply from Isla & Co. - Midtown 2025.12.04

We're stoked you loved the generous portions and flavors, Janessa! It sounds like we hit all the right notes. We can't wait to welcome you back to our Midtown location soon!

John Mortola 2025.12.04

     

So happy to have found this place. Large portions, beautifully prepared and presented. Service was a 6. We'll be back... Often

Useful Report

Reply from Isla & Co. - Midtown 2025.12.02

John, we're stoked you discovered us! So happy to hear you loved the portions and presentation - and that service rating of 6 made our day! We can't wait to welcome you back often. Thanks for the amazing feedback!

Evelyn Jankousky 2025.12.04

     

Rafael was an excellent server and really fun to talk with. He gave great recommendations and was so funny and pleasant. Highly recommend him with 10 stars.

Useful Report

Reply from Isla & Co. - Midtown 2025.12.04

Rafael sounds like a superstar! We're so happy you had such a great time with him, Evelyn. He'll be thrilled to hear how much you enjoyed his recommendations and fun personality. Can't wait to welcome you back soon!

Fragrance Channel 2025.12.03

     

J gave the best service

Useful Report

Reply from Isla & Co. - Midtown 2025.12.04

This review shines as bright as your taste. We appreciate you sharing your thoughts. Stop in again!

Richard Guillermo Vaca Maridueña 2025.12.03

     

Useful Report

Reply from Isla & Co. - Midtown 2025.12.04

We appreciate you stopping by, Richard! Sounds like we had some room for improvement during your visit. We'd love the chance to show you what we're really about next time!

William Barrios 2025.12.03

     

Useful Report

DenizSeyfert 2025.12.03

     

Das Ambiente ist wirklich toll und die Bedienungen freundlich. Am Anfang wurden wir nach „Tap Water“ gefragt und haben dies bejaht, am Ende wurde eine 10$ Wasserflasche berechnet. Hier muss man denke nochmals nachfragen, damit es nicht zu Missverständnissen kommt. Ich bin mir ziemlich sicher, dass es in unserem Fall ein Missverständnis war. Wir hatten ein Steak, die Power Bowl und die Reggatoni mit Prawns + Trüffelpommes, welche allesamt wirklich gut geschmeckt und Preis/Leistungstechnisch, gerade für NYC Verhältnisse, super fair waren. Klare Empfehlung!

Useful Report

Reply from Isla & Co. - Midtown 2025.12.03

Thanks for the awesome feedback, Deniz! We're stoked you loved the atmosphere, service, and especially those dishes - the steak, Power Bowl, and Reggatoni with prawns sound like perfect choices! Sorry about the water mix-up. We'll definitely make sure our team is clearer about that going forward. Can't wait to welcome you back for another great meal!