Bella's Bagels Reviews

Write a review

Bella's Bagels rating: 4.7 out of 5 from 901 reviews

4.7 | 901 total

Rating breakdown

5 stars

767 pcs

4 stars

57 pcs

3 stars

31 pcs

2 stars

19 pcs

1 star

27 pcs

Source filter

701 pcs

0 pc

200 pcs

Verified

What customers say about Bella's Bagels

Recent reviews

Natelie Rivera 2026.10.18

Delicious bagels! Come early for more options. They were sold out of many bagels by 12pm. I had a Bella on Cinnamon Raisin 😋

Report

Reply from Bella's Bagels 2026.10.18

Good advice Natelie! Thank for the review!

Thatcher G. 2026.10.02

World class bagels. I got the everything and the green chili cream cheese. Honestly best bagel/cream cheese experience I've ever had. Owner was there and super cool.

Report

Reply from Bella's Bagels 2026.10.02

Thanks so much Thatcher - our pleasure!

Jenifer Langdon 2026.09.25

Report

Reply from Bella's Bagels 2026.09.27

Thanks for the HIGH-FIVE Jenifer!

Mark Ulanowicz 2026.09.18

I like Bella’s. Great bagels friendly service. My only issue is the price of the Nove Lox bagel. Bella’s cost $16 and Einsteins is $10. So even though I’m live a block away from Bella’s I’ll drive 20 minutes round trip to go to Einsteins being Bella’s is 60% more expensive.

Report

Reply from Bella's Bagels 2026.09.18

Hi Mark. Thanks for your input. We fly our lox in from Brooklyn weekly. Unless you’d like to share your airplane miles with our salmon ;) , our price is going to reflect the top quality.)

Lyle Larson 2026.09.17

The green chili schmear lives up to the hype! The Bella with taylor pork roll was also amazing. Some of the best fresh bagels I’ve had. Pro tip- avoid the restaurant around lunch time as copious amounts of kids from the high school across the street descend on the shop, packing it, reducing seating options and change the atmosphere from quiet breakfast spot to a loud and chaotic cafeteria vibe.

Report

Reply from Bella's Bagels 2026.09.17

Thanks Lyle for the kind words. We do love our Pine Creek Students at lunchtime. Weekdays from 11:05 - 11:25 :)

Rosy E. 2026.09.15

Absolutely delicious! Everything is freshly made with quality ingredients, and the online ordering process is easy and convenient with rapid pickup service. The bagels are fresh, flavorful, and generously portioned. You can truly taste the quality in every bite! Absolutely recommend!

Report

Reply from Bella's Bagels 2026.09.15

Wow, Rosy! Thank you for such a thoughtful review.

Bobby Rasmussen 2026.09.13

Report

Reply from Bella's Bagels 2026.09.14

Thanks for the HIGH-FIVE Bobby!

Jeanne P 2026.09.11

Report

Reply from Bella's Bagels 2026.09.11

Thank you Jeanne!

Nathan D. 2026.09.10

Absolutely phenomenal bagels. Takes me back to my visits in NYC. The sesame with butter is to die for.

Report

Reply from Bella's Bagels 2026.09.10

Greatly appreciated Nathan. Thank you.

Jen T. 2026.09.09

These are real NY/NJ-style bagels -- boiled then baked, with a crisp outer crust and a chewy, soft interior. Every flavor I've tried has been excellent. The everything, jalapeño cheddar, and rosemary olive oil bagels are standouts.The sandwiches are just as good. The Bella (egg, bacon, and cheese) is generous and perfectly balanced. The Cooper caprese-style sandwich is fresh and flavorful. Their Pueblo green chile cream cheese is outstanding and worth getting on its own.The staff is friendly and efficient even when the line is long, the shop is clean and bright, and they even make doggie bagels if you bring your pup.

Report

Reply from Bella's Bagels 2026.09.09

Love the input. Thank you, Jen!

Colin 2026.09.05

Thanks for having vegan cream cheese! Bagel was delicious.

Report

Reply from Bella's Bagels 2026.09.05

Awesome!

Reagan Davis 2026.09.05

So delicious the Bella(bacon egg and cheese) on any bagel is so good highly recommend! The best bagel I’ve ever had fr fr also I’d recommend getting another bathroom to the owner if he’s able cause there is only one but I’d say 10/10 in total for this place you should def go!

Report

Reply from Bella's Bagels 2026.09.05

Thanks for the kind words Reagan!
Regarding another restroom, you’ll have to wait for our much bigger Bellas Bagels & Bistro that we’re building down by The Broadmoor!

Jon B 2026.09.05

My wife would leave me if I left anything other than 5 stars - she loves this place. While not a huge bagel fan, it’s pretty good. The Bella breakfast sandwich on the jalapeno was incredible! I have a go to when coming with my wife now

Report

Reply from Bella's Bagels 2026.09.05

Glad you enjoyed and you clearly have a wise wife, Jon!

Micayla Bahr 2026.09.05

PERFECTION every time! Summers and weekends there will be a wait, but you can order ahead online. Lemon curd, bacon scallion, olive rosemary bagel, all amazing!

Report

Reply from Bella's Bagels 2026.09.05

Thank you Micayla!!!

Ioannis Labrakis 2026.09.05

Report

Reply from Bella's Bagels 2026.09.05

Thanks Loannis!

Noelle King 2026.09.03

Report

Reply from Bella's Bagels 2026.09.03

Thanks for the HIGH-FIVE Noelle!

Bob B. 2026.09.03

Best bagels in town. Such a great selection and always fresh. The staff is amazing- courteous and helpful and they always seem to be cheerful. The place is clean and tidy. The service is so fast too considering their output. They always have the order ready by the time listed on an online order. Can't wait to check out the new location coming to the Broadmoor area next year. My favs are the Bella and the Shelby.

Report

Reply from Bella's Bagels 2026.09.03

Love to hear it, Bob! Thank you for taking the time to provide your input.

Suzie Bauer 2026.08.30

The bagels are so good. It's amazing the weekend specials.

Report

Reply from Bella's Bagels 2025.09.09

Thank you, Suzie!

Jessica G. 2026.08.30

One of the best bagels I have ever had! The green chile cream cheese is incredible! Definitely our new weekend spot.

Report

Reply from Bella's Bagels 2026.08.30

Wonderful Jessica!

Jordan Shovar 2026.08.29

We absolutely love Bella’s. The owner and staff are always very friendly, and the food is top notch. Highly recommend.

Report

Reply from Bella's Bagels 2026.08.29

Thanks much Jordan!!

Frequently asked questions about Bella's Bagels

How many reviews does Bella's Bagels have?

Bella's Bagels has 901 reviews on Trustindex, collected from Google, Yelp and Trustindex.

What is Bella's Bagels's average rating?

Bella's Bagels is rated 4.7 out of 5 based on 901 reviews. 85% of reviewers gave five stars.

Are Bella's Bagels reviews verified?

Trustindex moderates every review and verifies that it was collected from a real, active review platform before it is published.

How do I write a review for Bella's Bagels?

Use the "Write a review" button on this page to share your own experience with Bella's Bagels.

Write a review for Bella's Bagels

Write a review

Company activity

Profile claimed and verified by the business This company can manage and engage with its customer reviews. This includes updating company information, collecting new customer reviews, replying to reviews, and more.
Reviews shown unedited The reviews on the company profile are up-to-date and authentic. They are displayed without any modifications on their website.
Top Rated Certificate Trustindex verifies that the company has a review score above 4.5, based on reviews collected over the past 12 months, qualifying it to receive the Top Rated Certificate.
Replies to 98% of reviews within 1 day

About Bella's Bagels

Bella's Bagels is based in Colorado Springs, United States and is listed under Coffee Shop on Trustindex. On Trustindex, Bella's Bagels has collected 901 reviews from Google, Yelp and Trustindex, with an average rating of 4.7 out of 5 — 85% of customers gave five stars. The company has claimed its profile and replies to 98% of reviews, usually within 1 day. Read the latest Bella's Bagels reviews below or share your own experience.

Authentic scratch-made NY/NJ bagels baked fresh daily in Colorado Springs, offering award-winning breakfast, lunch, coffee, and catering services.