Donato's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria Reviews

Jacob Herrera 2025.12.10

     

Tucked away in the woodside neighborhood of Queens. Carlos took great care of us. Amazing food and service. We came an hour before close and left full and had plenty to go.

Useful Report

Reply from Donato's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria 2025.12.11

Thank you, Jacob! Next time you’re here, we’d love to cook for you again. We always want to fulfill a persons appetite here, no matter what time it is!

Thien Vo 2025.12.09

     

Some of the best Italian food and service I’ve had in the city. Good prices and huge portions. Our waiter Carlos was an absolute delight. He was charming and attentive.

Useful Report

Reply from Donato's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria 2025.12.11

Thank you, Thien! We’ll have more big portions and warm service waiting whenever you’re craving Italian again.

Victory Lee 2025.12.08

     

Such a cozy italian restaurant and a local gem in sunnyside:) I’d choose this over any fancy italian place in manhattan. Carlos our waiter was so friendly and the staff here us very welcoming. Every dish we got was so flavorful and perfect texture⭐️

Useful Report

Reply from Donato's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria 2025.12.11

Thank you, Victory. We’re glad you enjoyed everything and we’d be happy to have you back anytime.

Alexander Resnick 2025.12.03

     

Huge portions and a great chicken parm. Carlos was wonderful too! And our group had a few little kids and everyone was so accommodating

Useful Report

Reply from Donato's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria 2025.12.11

Thank you, Alexander. We’re happy your group had a great time and we’d love to welcome you all again.

Rosalina Villanueva 2025.11.17

     

Their lentil soup lives rent free in my head forever. Carlos our waiter was super attentive.

Useful Report

Paola Melo 2025.11.17

     

Good Food they acomódate to my allergies to sheldfish with no issued

Useful Report

G M 2025.11.17

     

Great service good food. Very friendly staff Walter was awesome

Useful Report

Nico Angerosa 2025.11.15

     

Excellent food and service - the restaurant is a little quiet with some typical Italian music. Great place for a cozy night out. Definitely want to try here again.

Useful Report

Grace Suarez 2025.11.15

     

Useful Report

Alexander Rodriguez 2025.11.13

     

They make the best garlic bread

Useful Report

Anna Campbell 2025.11.12

     

You want old school NY? Here it is, in all its glory!

Useful Report

Sara Edwards 2025.11.12

     

Carlos was the best! Great food and chill atmosphere

Useful Report

Alfie Palao 2025.11.12

     

Great sauce here and good vibes. Thanks Carlos!

Useful Report

Elona 2025.11.11

     

Excellent service and a warm, welcoming atmosphere. The staff at Donatos go above and beyond, friendly, attentive, and fast. Great neighborhood spot to relax and enjoy good food in a cozy setting.

Useful Report

Anisa Mint Sennan 2025.11.11

     

We’ve been frequent customers here because the food is always consistently delicious. The atmosphere is cozy and welcoming, and the service is friendly. Carlos always greets us with such warmth that it feels like coming home every time we visit. Highly recommend this place if you’re looking for a quality local spot in Sunnyside!

Useful Report

Luz Marina Ariza Hernandez 2025.11.10

     

Excelente, comida deliciosa

Useful Report

anna mcgrade 2025.11.10

     

Love carlos so much

Useful Report

Franklin Lopez 2025.11.10

     

Useful Report

Sebastian Prado Aguilar 2025.11.09

     

Great food very fresh and lovely atmosphere, the server Carlos really made our dinner a lot better!

Useful Report

Giselle Gonzalez 2025.11.09

     

Carlos was great with us today. Great service

Useful Report