Crumbly Cafe & Bakery Reviews 2026 | Trustindex.io

Write a review

Reviews

4.9 | 340 total

5 stars

328 pcs

4 stars

6 pcs

3 stars

4 pcs

2 stars

1 pc

1 star

1 pc

Source filter

340 pcs

Verified

Kajal 2026.03.29

5 stars for Crumbly Cafe ☕️ This place will always be near and dear to me—a local favorite from when I lived in the area. Their coffee is phenomenal, and I’m also a big fan of their chai. The real showstopper, though, is the food. They’re known for their crumb cake (and for good reason), but the true standout is their Parmesan leek pastries. You have to get them—I say that fully knowing they might be sold out by the time I get there haha. The potato mushroom boreka is also incredible. 10/10 every time.

Useful (1) Report

Elliott Hoopes 2026.03.23

Crumbly Cafe & Bakery just did an 80th birthday cake for a family member. They were great to work with, were open to my ideas and the end result was amazing! People at the party couldn't stop talking about the cake. It was almost too pretty to eat, but I am glad we did, because it was delicious!! I would highly recommend!

Useful Report

Henry Slomowitz 2026.03.20

The best tasting desserts you’ve ever had

Useful (1) Report

Christina Treyz 2026.03.16

Crumbly made a fantastic cake for my son’s 1st birthday party! Would highly recommend & will be ordering again for sure!

Useful Report

Riley Kiefer 2026.03.09

Useful Report

levan bakuradze 2026.03.09

Useful (1) Report

Zviad Tabatadze 2026.03.09

Useful Report

Brooke Wellington 2026.03.09

Fabulous cake!! Couldn’t be happier.

Useful Report

Lym Arias 2026.03.08

Our custom cake for my daughter’s first bday was exactly what we wanted. We chose funfetti cake with vanilla icing and it was absolutely delicious. This will be our go to celebration cakes going forward!

Useful Report

Julia Jeon 2026.03.08

Useful Report

Ana Panagrossi 2026.03.08

Such a cute bakery. We love this place! Their coffee is amazing and their pastries and goods are excellent! Such kind people. Def check them out

Useful Report

Christiana Sciaudone 2026.03.07

Pricey but tasty

Useful (1) Report

Michael Simon 2026.03.06

Crumbly created a beautiful Frozen/Elsa birthcake for my daughter. It tasted as amazing as it looked!

Useful (1) Report

Christina Franzese 2026.02.21

Beautiful and delicious cake! Great service and delicious cake.

Useful Report

Howard 2026.02.21

Flew on from Texas for my Granddaughter's 3rd birthday today. My son ordered a birthday cake for the occasion and I went with him to pick it up. An amazing, spectacular pink and white bunny themed cake appeared in the shape of a 3 and “happy birthday Gemma” in icing. Really a fantastic bakery. Great people and reasonably priced for this culinary creation.

Useful Report

Barbara Wood 2026.02.20

Incredible cake for our baby shower! Crumbly made a delicious GLUTEN FREE chocolate cake with a raspberry filling and a buttercream frosting. The cake was impressively moist and chocolatey! Going forward Crumbly will make all our gluten free cakes!

Useful Report

Katherine Wood 2026.02.20

I reached out to the Crumbly team for a custom baby shower cake for my sister and to say they did not disappoint is an understatement! The team was super friendly and helpful in helping us sort through the design quantity and pricing. Then, the gluten free cake they produced was right on the money in terms of aesthetic but also quality and many said it was one of the best cakes (not just gluten free!) they’d had in the city. Thank you so much again to the Crumbly team — you’re now our go-to cake supplier for any occasion.

Useful (1) Report

Tyra Jones 2026.02.12

We partnered with Crumbly Cafe & Bakery for our office “Sweet Social,” and they were phenomenal from start to finish! I manage this office remotely, so trust and communication were huge for me and they absolutely delivered. Ordering was seamless, responses were timely, and they made the entire process feel easy and stress-free. Knowing I could rely on them without being onsite meant everything. Delivery was smooth and right on time (major plus!), and the presentation was beautiful. Most importantly… the team LOVED the treats. When I say there were no crumbs left, I mean it; completely wiped out! If you’re coordinating an office event (especially remotely), I highly recommend Crumbly Cafe & Bakery. Reliable, professional, and delicious.

Useful (1) Report