CAKESBYNICKG Reviews

Alyssa Perez 2026.07.16

     

Absolutely loved my experience with Nicholas. He was super sweet and professional. We loved the caked for my daughter! A couple of figurines fell off during the car ride but no big deal at all, everyone loved it, especially my daughter. Tasted great too! Will definitely work with Nicholas again for future celebrations!

Useful Report

Yang 2026.07.14

     

Nick made my vision come to life. He is so easy to work with, and extremely responsive. Highly recommend him for all custom cakes. I will definitely be ordering from him again!

Useful Report

Stephen Sultan 2026.06.08

     

Chef Nicholas was given the assignment of creating a replica of the Intrepid aircraft carrier for my birthday. Not only was it perfect in detail but became the centerpiece of my party with guests requesting to have their pictures taken behind it. Chef Nick, you have made the party greater than expected. Needless to say recommendations for my friends are forth coming. Thanks again, Steve

Useful Report

Janet Gomez 2026.05.25

     

Nick is so nice ! Cake was so cute !

Useful Report

S 2026.05.13

     

Nick was absolutely incredible to work with from start to finish. He was so personable, easygoing, and truly made the entire process feel seamless. From the very beginning, he reassured me and took the time to understand exactly what I was envisioning—and then somehow exceeded every expectation. Our wedding cake was not only stunningly beautiful, but it was also delicious. We received so many compliments from our guests about both the design and the taste. It was honestly one of the highlights of the night! My fiancé and I loved it so much that we’ve joked about reaching back out just to have him make us more cakes like we had during the tasting. That’s how good it was. We will absolutely be working with Nick again in the future and can’t recommend him highly enough!

Useful Report

Edwin Quinones 2026.04.04

     

If you’re debating ordering a cake from Nick, let me save you the time—just do it. I thought I was getting a nice cake but what I got was a literal masterpiece. It looked unreal and somehow tasted even better which I feel is hard to do in this day and age. My girlfriend was obsessed with her Spirited Away themed cake and I’m pretty sure Nick just raised the bar way too high for every birthday moving forward 😭 Thank you so much for everything!

Useful Report

Ruxana Jina 2026.03.21

     

Very responsive service. Had the most beautiful and delicious cupcakes that lifted our Eid celebrations.

Useful Report

Mayra Quishpe 2026.03.20

     

Our wedding was in March 14, 2026! Nicholas did an absolutely amazing job with our wedding cake! It was not only delicious, but the presentation was exactly how I envisioned it!! beautiful and elegant. Communication throughout the process was easy and smooth and he was always professional and attentive to every detail. We couldn’t have asked for a better experience. Highly recommend!

Useful Report

Robert Hupf 2026.03.16

     

Loved working with Nicholas on this project. We were celebrating the birthday for our friend and wanted something special. The video game REPO is one of her favorite games, and something we all play/share together, so we really wanted to make this 3d cake a possibility. Nicholas was very invested in the project (even playing the game a bit to understand the character). Multiple reference photos, questions, and emails to cover every detail. Special requests (someone had a nut allergy for example) addressed with care and confidence. We loved working with him! Thank you Nicholas!

Useful Report

Nabila Brache 2026.03.09

     

Very happy with my experience with Nicholas, 100% recommend! The cake turned out exactly as the reference picture I had sent, and it was delicious too. All our guests enjoyed the cookies and cream flavor.

Useful Report

anthony merlino 2026.03.02

     

The best cake I had, Nicholas is a true pastry chef.

Useful Report

Voula Georgiou 2026.02.24

     

Had a wonderful experience working with Chef Nicholas to create the perfect cake for my daughter’s mermaid themed birthday party. He was extremely responsive and accommodating. The end result was a beautiful and delicious creation that both the adults and children enjoyed. Look forward to working with him again in the future.

Useful Report

Vered Shamel 2026.02.21

     

The cake itself was gorgeous and very well made. The flavor however, wasn’t so great. Wasn’t really sweet at all. I would use him for more aesthetically pleasing cakes but if you want flavor I’d go elsewhere. Very durable cake, however. Great attention to detail. Unfortunately, not one family member enjoyed the taste and most of it was discarded. Makes for a pretty cake, though.

Useful Report

Reply from CAKESBYNICKG 2026.02.21

Thank you for your thoughtful feedback and for the kind words about the design. It was a pleasure creating this cake, I’m so glad the craftsmanship and details stood out to you.

The flavor combination was customized during the consultation process to reflect the specific preferences requested. When working with custom flavor pairings, I always aim to create a balanced and enjoyable result based on those selections.

I understand that taste can vary from person to person and I genuinely appreciate you sharing your feedback. I’m always open to further conversation if you’d like to connect directly.

Nicole Lonoa 2026.02.20

     

Every layer was moist and flavorful but not overly sweet. We felt completely taken care of working with Chef Nicholas and on the wedding day everything looked flawless. We are so grateful we chose him.

Useful Report

Tyana Soto 2026.01.19

     

Nick made my wedding cake and I couldn't recommend ordering from him more. He was extremely professional and kind and was great to work with from start to finish. We did a cake tasting before and were so blown away with his coquito flavor (and so happy to include some of our latin culture in our cake). With just a little bit of reference on what we were looking for he completely blew the design out of the park and we were so happy the day of our wedding. Not only did it look perfect but absolutely tasted amazing and was a great addition to our special day. Thank you Nick!!

Useful Report

Stephen Lazarus 2025.12.15

     

Beautiful wedding cake. Nick was so nice to work with, from getting our tasting samples to working out logistics on the day of our wedding -- the whole process was very easy. The cake itself was beautifully made and very delicious. It fit the vision we had for our wedding perfectly. I would recommend him to anyone needing a cake for their event!

Useful Report

Olivia M 2025.12.14

     

Our wedding cake was one of the most beautiful things that I had a pleasure of seeing and eating, and the booking process was extremely detailed and swift. I can’t wait to use chef again for any other events, and will definitely be referring him to other friends and family. Thank you for making the wedding cake of our dreams!

Useful Report

Sharon Xue Yao LI (SoYouSnow) 2025.11.23

     

If youre looking for a special occasion custom cake creator LOOK NO FURTHER. I had the honor of creating a cake for my baby’s 100 day and he absolutely outdid himself. The cake blew every single guest away. I swear it was PERFECT. And i do not say this lightly. I spent over 600$ for my baby shower cake last time with another baker which quality/flavor/design was nowhere EVEN close to Nicholas’s creation. Made me feel like I got scammed from my baby shower cake 😭. The flavor was exactly what we were looking for as well and you absolutely replicated my visions exactly. It was so so so so good. The delivery was also on point. Super accomodating. Love love love. Will be returning customer over the next years with all special occasions!

Useful Report

Will Wallop (Yeti Wyckoff) 2025.11.03

     

Man Chef Nicholas is a MASTER of what he does. Visually - He created an absolute show stopper that felt like he pulled it straight out of our imagination Taste - This was such a good cake it’s going to haunt my dreams. It may have ruined other cakes for me because this cake was DELICIOUS Service - Simple no fuss, communicated every step of the way he was incredibly helpful and collaborative and put in a level of effort that reshaped my understanding of cake making as a whole. Price - not only reasonable but I would’ve payed extra just for a video of the creation of this cake. But I completely understand a magician never reveals his tricks! 10 outta 10 would work with again!

Useful Report

Brooklynn Gomez 2025.10.31

     

My husband and I decided to go through Cakes By Nick for our baby shower cake. We had a safari themed party and wanted a chocolate cake with raspberry filling with a more simple design. Nick exceeded all of our expectations from the design of the cake to the flavor. He was very easy to communicate with and listened to all my ideas and brought them to life better then I could have expected. I would 100% recommend Nick to anyone looking for costume cake in the area.

Useful Report