Blue Haven Pools & Spas Reviews

Matthew Meinema 2026.01.08

     

Blue Haven Pools was great to work with! From the design to material selection, everything was super easy. Would definitely recommend to anyone looking for a pool, especially if you’re looking for a custom concrete pool.

Useful Report

Reply from Blue Haven Pools & Spas 2026.01.09

Matthew,
Thank you for taking the time to share your experience and for including photos of your finished pool. We appreciate you highlighting both the pricing and the ease of the process—from design through material selection—which is exactly how we aim to guide our customers.

Your recommendation, particularly regarding custom concrete pools, is valued and helpful for homeowners evaluating their options. Thank you for sharing your project with us.

Thank you again for choosing Blue Haven Pools.

Evie Winkler 2025.10.31

     

Mike and the Blue Haven were wonderful to work with from start to finish of building our pool. Very responsive and great at communicating throughout the entire process. Even once the project was complete when we had questions, etc they always respond in a timely manner and are helpful. Would definitely recommend talking to Mike and team if you are putting a pool in!

Useful Report

Reply from Blue Haven Pools & Spas 2026.01.09

Evie,
Thank you for taking the time to share your experience and for recommending Blue Haven Pools. We appreciate you noting the pricing, communication, and responsiveness throughout the project, as well as the continued support after completion.

Your comments regarding Mike and the team reflect the level of service and follow-through we expect when working with our customers. If you have any photos of your pool or backyard, we would welcome the opportunity to see them and share your completed project with others considering Blue Haven.

Thank you again for choosing Blue Haven Pools.

Kelli 2025.09.21

     

It was a great experience working with this pool company. They communicated with us when needed, knowledgeable about important information, and assisted us on our project within a convenient timeframe. They’re extremely helpful and we would work with them again. Highly recommended!

Useful Report

Reply from Blue Haven Pools & Spas 2026.01.09

Kelli,
Thank you for taking the time to share your experience and for including photos of your project. We appreciate your feedback regarding pricing, communication, and the team’s knowledge throughout the process, as well as your comments on timing and overall support.

Your recommendation and the range of services you referenced are helpful to homeowners evaluating their options.

Thank you again for choosing Blue Haven Pools.

Brad Persic 2025.08.26

     

Blue Haven installed our pool and the process was smooth from start to finish. The crew was professional, detail-oriented, and kept us updated throughout. The final result looks amazing and has completely transformed our backyard. Highly recommend!

Useful Report

Reply from Blue Haven Pools & Spas 2026.01.09

Brad,
Thank you for taking the time to share your experience and for recommending Blue Haven Pools. We appreciate you noting the smooth process, professionalism, attention to detail, and ongoing communication throughout the project.

It’s great to hear the finished pool has transformed your backyard. If you have any additional photos of the space, we would welcome the opportunity to see how it turned out.

Thank you again for choosing Blue Haven Pools.

Jason Brown 2025.08.01

     

Fantastic experience. Pool was perfect and, most importantly, have experienced terrific support after the initial work. Would highly recommend!

Useful Report

Reply from Blue Haven Pools & Spas 2026.01.09

Jason,
Thank you for sharing your experience and for the recommendation. We appreciate you highlighting not only the finished pool, but the continued support after completion. Long-term service and follow-through are a core part of how we support our customers beyond the initial build.

If you have any photos of your pool or backyard, we would welcome the opportunity to see them and share your project with others considering Blue Haven.

Thank you again for choosing Blue Haven Pools.

Chris Cherry 2025.06.19

     

Blue Haven pools have been great to work with. We have been very pleased with our pool and their service. I would highly recommend this company if you are looking for someone to work with for any pool needs.

Useful Report

Reply from Blue Haven Pools & Spas 2026.01.09

Chris,
Thank you for taking the time to share your experience and for the recommendation. We appreciate your feedback regarding both the finished pool and the level of service provided throughout the process. Supporting our customers before, during, and after completion is an important part of how we operate.

If you have any photos of the finished project, we would love to see how it has transformed your backyard.

Thank you again for choosing Blue Haven Pools.

Christopher OMalley 2025.06.02

     

I purchased our Blue Haven Pool from Mike about 10 years ago and was happy with the install and our choice. Recently I needed a part for our filter and they replaced it for me at no charge to get my pool running again. Thanks Mike and Amy for the quick service! Chris

Useful Report

Reply from Blue Haven Pools & Spas 2026.01.09

Christopher,
Thank you for taking the time to share your experience. We appreciate you highlighting both your original installation and the continued support years later. Standing behind our work and supporting our customers long after completion is an important part of how we operate.

Your comments regarding Mike and Amy reflect the level of service and responsiveness we expect when assisting our customers.

Thank you again for choosing Blue Haven Pools.

S. Givens 2025.05.15

     

Blue Haven Pools did a fantastic job installing our new small pool/spa. We are very happy with the quality of the work they did and with the excellent communication they maintained with us during the entire construction process.

Useful Report

Reply from Blue Haven Pools & Spas 2026.01.09

S. Givens,
Thank you for sharing your experience and for including photos of your pool and spa. We appreciate your feedback regarding the quality of the work and the clear communication maintained throughout the construction process. Delivering consistent updates and a well-executed project is a standard we prioritize.

Thank you again for choosing Blue Haven Pools.

Lauren Mansoori 2025.03.26

     

They built me the pool of my dreams! It was such a great experience picking out all the designs. When I had some chipping in my tiles they helped me get it fixed quickly before pool season.

Useful Report

Reply from Blue Haven Pools & Spas 2026.01.09

Lauren,
Thank you for taking the time to share your experience. We appreciate your feedback regarding both the design process and the support provided after completion. Addressing concerns promptly and standing behind our work are important parts of how we serve our customers.

If you have any photos of the finished project, we would love to see how it has transformed your backyard.

Thank you again for choosing Blue Haven Pools.

Katie Martin 2025.03.10

     

I built a pool in central Indiana with Blue Haven last spring/summer. I just did a small, simple pool: 14x30 feet, no water features, no diving board. Overall, it was a very positive experience. I have recommended this company to my friends and family. Positives: 1) very friendly staff! Nathan worked with me throughout my entire project once I had a signed contract. He was especially helpful with permitting with the City and my HOA. 2) Communication with me about timeline was excellent. Nathan called or texted me regularly with expectations for the week ahead and what the delay would be if unexpected weather should hit. Weather or design changes will delay your project. Do your research and know what you want before you begin, and you'll have no need to amend anything. They had my entire pool constructed in record time. 3) Tom, the on-site project manager is just all-around wonderful. He was so helpful in keeping things running smoothly between the pool company and the general contractor I was using for the pool deck and patio. (I did not use Blue Haven for the pool deck.) 4) The finished product seems high-quality so far! The tile, the gunite, the lights, etc are all beautiful! I'm very happy with my pool! Negatives: I was new to pool ownership and knew nothing. There were a lot of things that I wish had been explained to me before signing a contract: 1) The homeowner is responsible for hiring a plumber to connect the pool heater to the gas line. This goes beyond just running a gas line and providing a stub (which the homeowner is also responsible for). This will be expensive. 2) If you have an auto-cover installed, you will not have travertine on all 4 sides of the pool perimeter. The lid on the cover replaces the travertine. The rendering I was given showed travertine on all 4 sides. I was really disappointed by this. 3) If you upgrade your gunite to include the colored specks, do not expect it to change the appearance of the gunite much. I'm told that it will extend the life of my gunite. Time will tell. 4) Your startup instructions will not include much. I was clueless about pool chemicals, and I was just told that if I didn't balance them correctly, I could ruin my gunite. However, no one would give me any advice about managing the chemicals except to hire a pool maintenance company. The pdf they provide with instructions for initial care of gunite really scared me. I was terrified I was going to ruin the pool if I made the wrong move! However, once I got the chemicals initially balanced, it was a piece of cake for the rest of the summer!

Useful Report

Reply from Blue Haven Pools & Spas 2026.01.09

Katie,

Thank you for taking the time to share such a detailed and thoughtful review, and for including photos of your pool. We appreciate your recommendation and your thorough perspective on both the strengths of the project and the areas where clearer communication would have been helpful.

Your feedback regarding communication, project coordination, and the finished product reflects standards we work hard to maintain. At the same time, your comments on expectations, education for new pool owners, and upfront clarity are valuable and help us continue improving how we guide customers through the process.

Thank you again for choosing Blue Haven Pools.

Brittany Warren 2025.03.01

     

Mike and his team at Blue Haven Pools did an incredible job transforming our backyard into a true outdoor oasis! They built a 44-ft gunite lagoon-style pool with a hot tub and fountains, and we couldn’t love it more. The quality is top-notch, the price was great, and the entire process was smooth and timely—everything was completed with no issues. Communication was excellent throughout, and they truly went above and beyond to make our vision a reality. Highly recommend Mike and Blue Haven Pools for anyone looking to build their dream pool!

Useful (1) Report

Reply from Blue Haven Pools & Spas

Brittany,
Thank you for taking the time to share your experience and for including photos of your project. We appreciate your feedback regarding the quality of the build, the pricing, and the communication throughout the process. Completing a custom gunite pool with added features smoothly and on schedule is always a priority.

Your comments regarding Mike and the team reflect the level of coordination, execution, and customer care we aim to deliver on every project. Thank you for the recommendation and for sharing your finished backyard.

Thank you again for choosing Blue Haven Pools.

D Jackson 2024.12.08

     

Useful Report

Reply from Blue Haven Pools & Spas 2026.01.09

D Jackson,
Thank you for taking the time to leave a review. We appreciate your trust in Blue Haven Pools and the opportunity to work with you on your project.

If you have any photos of the finished project, we would love to see how it has transformed your backyard.

Thank you again for choosing Blue Haven Pools.

Gustavo Garavaglia 2024.11.30

     

Blue Haven did a great job building my pool. They got it done flawlessly in less than 3 months!! Very happy with their team!

Useful Report

Reply from Blue Haven Pools & Spas 2026.01.09

Gustavo,

Thank you for taking the time to share your experience. We appreciate your feedback regarding the quality of the build, the efficiency of the timeline, and the team’s performance throughout the project. Delivering well-executed projects on a clear and reliable schedule is a priority for us.

If you have any photos of the finished project, we would love to see how it has transformed your backyard.

Thank you again for choosing Blue Haven Pools.

martha hernandez 2024.11.25

     

We are excited to share that we have received a luxurious, top-of-the-line pool! Working with Blue Haven Pools was a smooth and enjoyable experience. We are truly in awe of our new pool! Have patience because it’s definitely worth the wait!

Useful Report

J B 2024.07.21

     

Our pool was installed by Blue Haven in 2023. We had to be patient throughout the process as we learned there are many factors that can affect the timeline of the pool construction. We ultimately got the perfect pool for our needs and have been swimming for months. We’ve had to reach out to Tom twice this summer and he was very prompt in coming out and walking us through what needed to be done. Our pool was designed to be a spa at one end and it has turned out to be great for us! We can even swim into early November. We had a waterfall installed in the corner (courtesy of our amazing landscape designer Lowell at ProCare Horticultural Services) and it works wonderfully with our pool. The other factor we love is that the pool maintains its heat well so the heater isn’t always running…saving us money. I would recommend Blue Haven for a pool!

Useful (1) Report

Patti Dean 2024.05.05

     

Blue Haven Pools did an excellent job on our pool and backyard project, coordinating timely completion by all subcontractors involved. Dig date to water in the pool was as quick as we could have hoped for and they followed through on all punch list items. Mike Rutherford assisted us by providing many suggestions that we chose to proceed with. Tile paver decking, waterfalls, outdoor kitchen and other transformed our backyard and we just love it!! Mike and all with Blue Haven were very pleasant and professional to work with and we highly recommend.

Useful Report

TK Conyer 2024.05.02

     

We have had our pool for five years now. We love it! We are still a current customer and having an ozonator installed. Love Blue Haven!

Useful Report

Kevin Hoblik 2024.04.30

     

Very patient and understanding. We had to wait awhile to get our power lines moved and they were willing to wait and pressure us.

Useful Report

Pierre Twer 2024.04.23

     

We recently had our second Bluehaven pool installed by Mike Rutherford and his team. Our first pool was installed 18 years ago and served our growing family wonderfully well. We built a new home two years ago and used Blue Haven’s services again. Both pools have been gunite and we have been very impressed and pleased with the quality of the product. Another reason we have used Blue haven Pools is because Mike and his team have been very responsive to any follow-up issues that we have had. We have friends who have installed Blue haven Pools with the same great results. We can highly recommend Blue haven Pools.

Useful Report

M Green 2024.04.02

     

We chose Blue Haven because they were the only pool company who returned our initial call in a timely manner. Our sales person, Jamey, was very pleasant to work with. The office manager, Amy, communicated well and quickly addressed any concerns that surfaced during construction. The quality and beauty of the completed pool is top-notch.

Useful Report