Black Forest Brooklyn Reviews

tony brueske 2025.12.08

     

My wife and I have been going here for a long time. Lots of good German beers and it’s a hall experience. Get a sausage they’re great they have there take on kraut, it’s good but some people seem taken aback but the flavors are nice avoid the fries in off hours potentially. You can’t get this anywhere in the area have a good time, Prost!

Useful Report

Zachary Taylor 2025.12.05

     

I’ll admit it’s been a while, but I’ve been to Black Forest a bunch of times. Anyway, good beer. Food not great but not as awful as DSK’s grub. Ok atmosphere. Once upon a time, I preferred DSK overall, but wouldn’t set foot in there now.

Useful Report

David Weitzenhoffer 2025.11.29

     

Useful Report

Paul Slater 2025.11.28

     

Useful Report

Joshua Lane 2025.11.22

     

The Chicken Schnitzel & Waffles are fantastic!

Useful Report

Matt Goldstein 2025.11.14

     

Great food. I hadn't been to a German restaurant in decades. The negative is the noise level. It was LOUD!

Useful Report

Roberto Linares 2025.11.11

     

Great service and great vibes! The Black Forest Cake was a bit too sour for my liking, but the overall experience, and service were great.

Useful Report

Stephanie Donis 2025.11.03

     

Had a surprise birthday party here with around 20 people and it was perfect! The food, the vibe, the staff all made our day amazing. Thank you!

Useful Report

Reply from Black Forest Brooklyn 2025.11.03

Stephanie - yay, thank you so much for this great review, it was nice to host your group!

Martin Vögele 2025.10.28

     

Useful Report

Reply from Black Forest Brooklyn 2023.08.28

Dankeschön!

C Conroy 2025.10.26

     

Useful Report

John Lusk 2025.10.26

     

Loud, packed ==> local favorite. Food is German but what I got (goulash and spätzle) wasn't as heavy as I expected (and tasty). Wife got kale and apple salad, which she loved. I rarely encountered salad like that when I visited Germany, so that was a (pleasant) surprise. Tannenzapfle beer was great, a bit like a saison, but more crisp and fresh.

Useful Report

Jim Tews 2025.10.21

     

Food was awesome, service was great, and it wasn't expensive. I also had an issue with an accidental charge that the staff went out of their way to take care of.

Useful Report

Brooklyn USA 2025.10.12

     

Tasty Germany style food ,beer right in Brooklyn

Useful Report

Austin 2025.10.12

     

Useful Report

Lorna Vi 2025.09.28

     

Useful Report

Dario Cazzani 2025.09.28

     

Fun place

Useful Report

Steve Esposito 2025.09.27

     

Great place, great food, great beer. I went 2 days in a row, loved it so much.

Useful Report

Jim Sears 2025.09.25

     

No longer open for lunch during the week. Our favorites include: Nurnberger platter, Goulash, and sausage platters. Don't forget the pretzels! Friendly and attentive service.

Useful Report

Reply from Black Forest Brooklyn 2024.06.23

Thank you Jim for the nice review!

Ryan 2025.09.24

     

Pretty typical biergarten menu, thought theyd offer more but cant complain. Spätzle was unreal.

Useful Report

Neil Theiss 2025.09.22

     

Oktoberfest! Love the German band! So much fun! The food is authentic tastes from the Black Forest region. I had the Kasebratwurst (cheese sausage) which was excellent! Many beers on tap to choose from here as well. I highly recommend you check out Oktoberfest at the Black Forest!

Useful Report