Bar San Miguel Reviews

Excellent rating

4.6 | 465 reviews

Verified Company

www.barsanmiguelbk.com Visit this website

Reviews

4.6

| 465 total

5 stars

371 pcs

4 stars

57 pcs

3 stars

7 pcs

2 stars

6 pcs

1 star

24 pcs

Source filter

465 pcs

Verified

Jerry Christian 2025.12.12

Reply from Bar San Miguel 2025.12.13

Hi Jerry,
Thank you for visiting us. We appreciate you taking the time to share your experience at our neighborhood restaurant. We will take in consideration your feedback and do our best to do even better.
We hope to see you back soon.

Owner and the BarSanMiguel team

Anders Fade 2025.12.04

Food was rough. Ordered Al pastor tacos that had some tough pork - figured I’d eat the cost and get a good meal so I ordered fish tacos that came burnt. So basically they gave me 2 meals in one night tha were both sub-par. You can do better than that.

Reply from Bar San Miguel 2025.12.13

Hi Anders,
Thank you for visiting us and for taking the time to share your valuable feedback. We take every comment seriously and we will do our best to improve on your mentioned points.
At the same time, we know our standards are much higher and would like to see you back and make this right.
Please let us know whenever you can return and let us take care of you.

Owner - Bar San Miguel

Monserrat Gonzalez silva 2025.11.24

Una experiencia de comida mexicana inolvidable!!! El ambiente muy agradable , el servicio atento y amable, la comida estuvo deliciosa muy fresco todo. Definitivamente se a convertido en de mis lugares favoritos para visitar en brooklyn..

Una experiencia de comida mexicana inolvidable!!!
El ambiente muy agradable , el servicio atento y amable, la comida estuvo deliciosa muy fresco todo. Definitivamente se a convertido en de mis lugares favoritos para visitar en brooklyn..

Una experiencia de comida mexicana inolvidable!!!
El ambiente muy agradable , el servicio atento y amable, la comida estuvo deliciosa muy fresco todo. Definitivamente se a convertido en de mis lugares favoritos para visitar en brooklyn..

Una experiencia de comida mexicana inolvidable!!!
El ambiente muy agradable , el servicio atento y amable, la comida estuvo deliciosa muy fresco todo. Definitivamente se a convertido en de mis lugares favoritos para visitar en brooklyn..

anne joyce 2025.11.24

I LOVE this restaurant! I just found it with friends and have already been back three times. The enchiladas are a perfect size and full of flavor. The queso is so tangy and delicious. The chip and guac are perfect. And the margaritas! Yum!!! This will become our neighborhood favorite.

Md Jabed 2025.11.23

Ozgun Saran 2025.11.23

Bar San Miguel — legend has it that it’s owned by Jim Cramer from Mad Money. I’ve been there countless times but have never actually run into him :) What keeps me coming back are the great margaritas and tacos. The food is solid, the atmosphere is relaxed, and it’s a perfect spot whether you’re out with friends or on a date. It’s definitely not a flashy place — blink and you might miss it — but that’s part of its charm. The garden is also lovely, and the whole place really comes alive in the spring and summer. A low-key neighborhood favorite with reliably good vibes.

Reply from Bar San Miguel 2025.11.23

Hi Ozgun,
Thank you for visiting us many times and for taking the time to share your experience. Bar San Miguel used to be owned by Jim Cramer, however he is not the owner anymore for quite some time. It is a family owned and operated neighborhood restaurant, that has one of the largest tequila and mezcal selections, along with great Mexican dishes. We hope to see you again soon!
Owner and The Bar San Miguel team

Jack Wells 2025.11.10

Reply from Bar San Miguel 2025.11.11

Hi Jack,
We’re truly sorry to hear that your visit to Bar San Miguel in Carroll Gardens didn’t meet your expectations. We take your feedback very seriously — both the food and service should always reflect the warm, authentic experience we’re known for after more than 13 years in the neighborhood.

We’d love the opportunity to learn more about what went wrong and to make it right for you. If you’re open to sharing details or giving us another chance, please reach out directly at lasirenagorda307@gmail.com or stop by so we can personally ensure you have a better experience next time.

Thank you for your honesty — it helps us grow and continue improving for our guests.

Warm regards,
Owner, Bar San Miguel Carroll Gardens

Richard Vargas 2025.11.09

The service was amazing.

Reply from Bar San Miguel 2025.11.10

Hi Richard,
Thank you for your visit. We appreciate you taking the time to share your experience and look forward to seeing you back soon.

Owner and the Bar San Miguel team

Steven Arangio 2025.11.08

Pros: food was good and staff was friendly Cons: it's overpriced and the food portions are way too small. I left still hungry and got pizza down the street. I will NOT be returning

Reply from Bar San Miguel 2025.11.11

Hi Steven,
Thank you for taking the time to share your feedback. We’re truly sorry to hear that your experience didn’t meet expectations, especially regarding portion size and value. Our goal at Bar San Miguel in Carroll Gardens is to serve authentic, high-quality Mexican food that feels satisfying and welcoming — and it’s clear we missed that for you.

We’d really appreciate the chance to make this right. If you’d be open to it, please reach out to us directly at lasirenagorda307@gmail.com or stop by again so we can personally ensure you leave happy and full. We take every comment seriously and will use your feedback to keep improving.

We hope you’ll give us another opportunity to show you the warm hospitality and flavors our guests have loved for over 13 years.

Warm regards,
Owner, Bar San Miguel Carroll Gardens

Lisette Tucker 2025.11.07

Happy hour prices are great. Yucca fries? Worst I ever had. Their dipping sauce? Best ever. But really. Don’t get the fries. Hard as hell and undercooked. No bueno.

Reply from Bar San Miguel 2025.11.10

Hi Lisette,
Thank you so much for taking the time to share your feedback and for joining us during happy hour — we really appreciate it. We’re so sorry to hear the yucca fries didn’t come out right; that’s definitely not the standard we hold ourselves to at Bar San Miguel. Your honesty helps us improve, and we’d truly love the chance to make it up to you.

Please come back soon and ask for one of our managers — we’d be happy to take care of you and ensure everything comes out just the way it should. We’re grateful for your support and hope to welcome you back to Bar San Miguel in Carroll Gardens for a much better experience next time.

Warm regards,
Owner and The Bar San Miguel Team

Lindsay 2025.11.07

First of all, the service is incredible. The bartenders are professional and make the most incredible cocktails, even if you ask for off menu. The food is excellent and solid core Menu with excellent rotational seasonal.

First of all, the service is incredible. The bartenders are professional and make the most incredible cocktails, even if you ask for off menu. The food is excellent and solid core
Menu with excellent rotational seasonal.

First of all, the service is incredible. The bartenders are professional and make the most incredible cocktails, even if you ask for off menu. The food is excellent and solid core
Menu with excellent rotational seasonal.

Reply from Bar San Miguel 2025.11.08

Hi Lindsay,
Thank you so much for taking the time to share your kind words! We’re thrilled you enjoyed both the service and the cocktails — our bartenders truly take pride in crafting creative, high-quality drinks, whether they’re classics or off-menu favorites. It also means a lot that you noticed our seasonal dishes; we love bringing fresh flavors to our Mexican menu throughout the year. We look forward to welcoming you back soon for more handcrafted cocktails and authentic Mexican food here at Bar San Miguel in Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn.
Owner and The Bar San Miguel Team

Nadean Novogratz 2025.11.02

Reply from Bar San Miguel 2025.11.03

Hi Nadean,
Thank you for your continuous support and for being a top customer at our neighborhood restaurant, Bar San Miguel. We are always happy to see the whole family and glad to know you keep us as one of your favorite neighborhood spots.

Owner and Bar San Miguel team

Francois Balmelle 2025.10.26

Very nice little peaceful heaven

Reply from Bar San Miguel 2025.10.27

Hi Francois,
Thank kindly for visiting us. We appreciate you taking the time to share your experience and look forward to seeing you back soon.

Owner and the Bar San Miguel team

Kerri Gaudelli 2025.10.24

Reply from Bar San Miguel 2025.10.24

Hi Kerri,
Thank you for your visit and for taking the time to review us. We truly appreciate it and look forward to seeing you back soon.

Owner and The Bar San Miguel Team

Leyla Housein 2025.10.05

Came here for my boyfriends birthday dinner and everything was perfect! The ambiance, the food, and the drinks! Highly recommend the tuna taquitos, Baja style fish tacos, churros with ice cream and pomegranate mezcalita. The warm churros with the vanilla ice cream were truly the show stopper. All of it to die for and will be coming back!

Reply from Bar San Miguel 2025.10.06

Hi Leyla,
Thank you so much for celebrating such a special occasion with us! We’re thrilled to hear that your boyfriend’s birthday dinner at our neighborhood restaurant was perfect from start to finish. It means a lot that you loved the ambiance, food, and drinks — and we couldn’t agree more, the churros with vanilla ice cream are definitely a guest favorite!

We’re so happy you enjoyed the tuna taquitos, Baja-style fish tacos, and pomegranate mezcalita — each one was crafted to showcase the fresh, bold flavors that define our Latin American menu.

We truly appreciate your kind words and recommendation, and we can’t wait to welcome you back for more ceviche, tacos, and mezcal cocktails soon.

Bar San Miguel– a top Brooklyn destination for tacos, tequila mezcal, and unforgettable Latin flavors.

JONATHAN STARR 2025.09.18

Reply from Bar San Miguel 2025.09.19

Hi Jonathan,
Thank you for your feedback. We appreciate it.

Owner and BSM team,
Bar San Miguel

Nicholas La Forge 2025.09.15

We recently had a surprise 80th birthday party for my father at Bar San Miguel. Petru and his team were top-notch! He made planning easy and was very accommodating. The food and drinks were excellent! The service for our group of 21 was handled seamlessly. We will definitely be back!

Reply from Bar San Miguel 2025.09.19

Hi Nicholas,
We appreciate you sharing your experience at our neighborhood restaurant. It is always a pleasure to host private parties and we are thrilled to hear that everyone enjoyed what we have to offer. We look forward to seeing you again soon.

Owner and BSM team
Bar San Miguel

Vivianne Barretto 2025.09.12

I absolutely loved the aesthetics of this bar. Loved the backyard. It's all beautifully decorated. They have a great happy hour. I had a Pomegranate Mezcalita and it was delicious. I didn't try the food, so I can't comment on it. The service is good. Jaime, the bartender and Claudia, the server, were both very hospitable. I would definitely come back. I have to try some food next time.

I absolutely loved the aesthetics of this bar. Loved the backyard. It's all beautifully decorated. They have a great happy hour. I had a Pomegranate Mezcalita and it was delicious. I didn't try the food, so I can't comment on it. The service is good. Jaime, the bartender and Claudia, the server, were both very hospitable. I would definitely come back. I have to try some food next time.

I absolutely loved the aesthetics of this bar. Loved the backyard. It's all beautifully decorated. They have a great happy hour. I had a Pomegranate Mezcalita and it was delicious. I didn't try the food, so I can't comment on it. The service is good. Jaime, the bartender and Claudia, the server, were both very hospitable. I would definitely come back. I have to try some food next time.

I absolutely loved the aesthetics of this bar. Loved the backyard. It's all beautifully decorated. They have a great happy hour. I had a Pomegranate Mezcalita and it was delicious. I didn't try the food, so I can't comment on it. The service is good. Jaime, the bartender and Claudia, the server, were both very hospitable. I would definitely come back. I have to try some food next time.

I absolutely loved the aesthetics of this bar. Loved the backyard. It's all beautifully decorated. They have a great happy hour. I had a Pomegranate Mezcalita and it was delicious. I didn't try the food, so I can't comment on it. The service is good. Jaime, the bartender and Claudia, the server, were both very hospitable. I would definitely come back. I have to try some food next time.

I absolutely loved the aesthetics of this bar. Loved the backyard. It's all beautifully decorated. They have a great happy hour. I had a Pomegranate Mezcalita and it was delicious. I didn't try the food, so I can't comment on it. The service is good. Jaime, the bartender and Claudia, the server, were both very hospitable. I would definitely come back. I have to try some food next time.

I absolutely loved the aesthetics of this bar. Loved the backyard. It's all beautifully decorated. They have a great happy hour. I had a Pomegranate Mezcalita and it was delicious. I didn't try the food, so I can't comment on it. The service is good. Jaime, the bartender and Claudia, the server, were both very hospitable. I would definitely come back. I have to try some food next time.

I absolutely loved the aesthetics of this bar. Loved the backyard. It's all beautifully decorated. They have a great happy hour. I had a Pomegranate Mezcalita and it was delicious. I didn't try the food, so I can't comment on it. The service is good. Jaime, the bartender and Claudia, the server, were both very hospitable. I would definitely come back. I have to try some food next time.

I absolutely loved the aesthetics of this bar. Loved the backyard. It's all beautifully decorated. They have a great happy hour. I had a Pomegranate Mezcalita and it was delicious. I didn't try the food, so I can't comment on it. The service is good. Jaime, the bartender and Claudia, the server, were both very hospitable. I would definitely come back. I have to try some food next time.

I absolutely loved the aesthetics of this bar. Loved the backyard. It's all beautifully decorated. They have a great happy hour. I had a Pomegranate Mezcalita and it was delicious. I didn't try the food, so I can't comment on it. The service is good. Jaime, the bartender and Claudia, the server, were both very hospitable. I would definitely come back. I have to try some food next time.

I absolutely loved the aesthetics of this bar. Loved the backyard. It's all beautifully decorated. They have a great happy hour. I had a Pomegranate Mezcalita and it was delicious. I didn't try the food, so I can't comment on it. The service is good. Jaime, the bartender and Claudia, the server, were both very hospitable. I would definitely come back. I have to try some food next time.

I absolutely loved the aesthetics of this bar. Loved the backyard. It's all beautifully decorated. They have a great happy hour. I had a Pomegranate Mezcalita and it was delicious. I didn't try the food, so I can't comment on it. The service is good. Jaime, the bartender and Claudia, the server, were both very hospitable. I would definitely come back. I have to try some food next time.

I absolutely loved the aesthetics of this bar. Loved the backyard. It's all beautifully decorated. They have a great happy hour. I had a Pomegranate Mezcalita and it was delicious. I didn't try the food, so I can't comment on it. The service is good. Jaime, the bartender and Claudia, the server, were both very hospitable. I would definitely come back. I have to try some food next time.

I absolutely loved the aesthetics of this bar. Loved the backyard. It's all beautifully decorated. They have a great happy hour. I had a Pomegranate Mezcalita and it was delicious. I didn't try the food, so I can't comment on it. The service is good. Jaime, the bartender and Claudia, the server, were both very hospitable. I would definitely come back. I have to try some food next time.

I absolutely loved the aesthetics of this bar. Loved the backyard. It's all beautifully decorated. They have a great happy hour. I had a Pomegranate Mezcalita and it was delicious. I didn't try the food, so I can't comment on it. The service is good. Jaime, the bartender and Claudia, the server, were both very hospitable. I would definitely come back. I have to try some food next time.

I absolutely loved the aesthetics of this bar. Loved the backyard. It's all beautifully decorated. They have a great happy hour. I had a Pomegranate Mezcalita and it was delicious. I didn't try the food, so I can't comment on it. The service is good. Jaime, the bartender and Claudia, the server, were both very hospitable. I would definitely come back. I have to try some food next time.

I absolutely loved the aesthetics of this bar. Loved the backyard. It's all beautifully decorated. They have a great happy hour. I had a Pomegranate Mezcalita and it was delicious. I didn't try the food, so I can't comment on it. The service is good. Jaime, the bartender and Claudia, the server, were both very hospitable. I would definitely come back. I have to try some food next time.

Reply from Bar San Miguel 2025.09.12

Hi Vivianne,
Thank you so much for taking the time to share your experience at our neighborhood place. We truly appreciate your visit and hope to see you again soon, so you can try more of the food and drink items.

Owner
Bar San Miguel

Tati Ha 2025.09.06

Das Essen war lecker, tolle Drinks, alles frisch zubereitet, die Bedienungen super aufmerksam und sehr freundlich! Große Empfehlung.

Reply from Bar San Miguel 2025.09.12

Hello,
Thanks so much for sharing your experience. We hope to see you again soon.
Owner
Bar San Miguel

Carla Lother 2025.09.01

Such a fun night we had. Uriel behind the bar managed to make us feel important while busting his butt pouring drinks, serving people, seating folk, smiling, explaining the menu and cocktails, all the while never letting us see him sweat. We enjoyed small plates of tuna tartar, fish tacos and a wonderful special beef taco with an amazing consommé dipping sauce. We wish this very fairly priced Carroll Gardens spot all the very best.

Reply from Bar San Miguel 2025.09.12

Hi Carla,
This means so much for us. We appreciate you taking the time to share your experience. Yes, Uriel is keeping the bar high at our neighborhood restaurant and we are truly glad that our guest see this.
We look forward to seeing you again soon.

Owner
Bar San Miguel

Company activity

Claimed Profile
Displaying Reviews
Replies To Reviews In 1 Week
Replied to 93% of reviews
Top Rated Certificate

About Bar San Miguel

Bar San Miguel is trusted by over 434 happy customers, earning a 4.6-star rating! Explore real reviews and share your own experience.

TOP 5 Trustindex Features

100+ Review Platforms

40 Breathtaking review widgets

Easy review collection

Review image generator

Review e-mail signatures

Create a Free account