Aldo's Coffee Company Reviews

Marc Hernandez 2026.05.12

     

Just had an amazing experience and picked these for Mother’s Day at Aldos Coffee in Greenport. The handcrafted organic coffee, fresh roasted beans, and chocolate-dipped hazelnut biscotti made for such a thoughtful and delicious gift. You can really taste the quality and tradition that’s made this place a North Fork favorite for decades. The atmosphere is warm, cozy, and authentic — exactly what you hope for in a local coffee shop. Friendly service, incredible aroma the moment you walk in, and products that feel made with care. If you’re visiting Greenport, this spot is absolutely worth the stop. Highly recommend the Costa Rica roast and the biscotti! ☕❤️

Useful Report

Reply from Aldo's Coffee Company 2026.05.12

Thank you for sharing this — it means a lot to hear we could be a part of your Mother’s Day plans. We care deeply about everything we make and are glad it came through in the coffee and biscotti. Hope to see you again next time you’re in Greenport.

Ponta Car repair service 2026.05.10

     

The espresso is truly good—Italian style.

Useful Report

Reply from Aldo's Coffee Company 2026.05.10

Thanks for saying that. We care a lot about making coffee that respects tradition, so it means a lot to hear you enjoyed the espresso. Hope to see you again soon. – Josh

Nicholas Papanikolaou 2026.05.04

     

An awesome place, very cozy and great quality. Everyone so friendly and welcoming definitely the place to go

Useful Report

Reply from Aldo's Coffee Company 2026.05.04

Thank you for spending some time with us and for the kind words. It's good to know the space and the coffee felt right to you—that’s what we’re here for. Hope to see you again soon.

Monica Cabral S. 2026.05.02

     

Useful Report

Reply from Aldo's Coffee Company 2026.05.02

Thanks for the kind words and the five stars. It means a lot to us. We care deeply about making good coffee for good people, and it’s always encouraging to know that comes through. Hope to see you again soon. – Josh

Steven G 2026.04.24

     

I’ve frequented aldo’s back in the early 2000’s when i lived in southold. I called Aldo the the Willy Wonker of coffee. Everything was delicious. My go to was a coffee and a scone. Aldo used to hand pour over coffee grinds each cup. Touch of personal care, and it was delicious. I visited Aldo’s this morning for the first time since he sold. Today, my coffee was poured out of a urn and was a very ordinary cup of coffee that can be had at any convenience store. Staff was great, atmosphere also still good…but the coffee. I will say the scone was just as good. Aldo’s management, you should go back to Also’s touch. Good luck

Useful Report

Reply from Aldo's Coffee Company 2026.04.25

Steven — really appreciate you coming back in and taking the time to share this.

You’re right about the old days — everything used to be hand-poured, and that level of care is something we think about constantly.

Over time, we had to make a call: either raise prices significantly or find a way to keep coffee accessible for everyone. We chose to keep a 12oz cup at $3.25, which meant moving to a batch brew — but we’re still using the same fresh-roasted beans behind it.

That said, your point lands. The experience matters just as much as the product, and we don’t take that lightly.

If you’re around again, I’d genuinely love to make you an Americano the way you remember — on us. Feel free to reach out at info@aldoscoffee.com or just stop in and ask for me.

Thanks again for the honest feedback — it helps keep us sharp.

– Josh

Sonjay Joseph Fonn, DO 2026.04.24

     

Incredibly delicious gelato.

Useful Report

Reply from Aldo's Coffee Company 2026.04.24

Thank you for your kind words—glad you enjoyed the gelato. Small details like that mean a lot to us. Hope to see you again soon.

Tom C. 2026.04.16

     

Verified

Great espresso, the best! Met Josh, great person, great experience all around! Hometown feel with great biscotti!!

Useful Report

Reply from Aldo's Coffee Company 2026.04.16

Great meeting you and thank you so much for writing this! We appreciate you.

Lorena M. 2026.04.14

     

Verified

Excellent service, the coffee is delicious! Ambiance: nice smooth music, very clean and cozy

Useful Report

Reply from Aldo's Coffee Company 2026.04.14

Appreciate you, Lorena — means a lot you took the time to leave this. Looking forward to having you back in soon!

Joan Horbert 2026.04.11

     

Useful Report

Reply from Aldo's Coffee Company 2026.04.11

Thank you for the kind words and the five stars. Knowing you had a good experience means a lot to us. We care deeply about making bold coffee and creating a space that feels welcoming, so it’s always good to hear when it connects with someone. Hope to see you again when you’re in town.

Dani 2026.04.11

     

Useful Report

Reply from Aldo's Coffee Company 2026.04.11

Hi there, thanks for the five stars. Means a lot to us. We take pride in what we do, and it’s always good to know it’s landing well. Hope we’ll see you back in Greenport soon. –Josh

Zef Noci 2026.04.10

     

Amazing coffee. I always load up when I’m in Greenport. Great staff and the owner is great! What a gem. I bring all my family and friends here and they love it!

Useful Report

Reply from Aldo's Coffee Company 2026.04.10

Thanks for making us a part of your routine when you're in town. It means a lot that you share Aldo's with the people you care about. That's what it's all about for us—good coffee and good company. Hope to see you again soon.

drgoodman27 Goodman 2026.04.02

     

The new owners have taken an iconic brand to the next level. I have been going to Aldo’s for 20 years and always left happy and satisfied. I worried as Aldo was contemplating retirement, what would happen to this absolute gem of a place. I was simply blown away by the new family that took over, they are passionate , and dedicated to expanding the legacy of what Aldo built with his Blood sweat and tears, Bravo All my love to them , Dr Howard Goodman

Useful Report

Reply from Aldo's Coffee Company 2026.04.02

Thank you, Dr. Goodman. It means a lot to hear this from someone who knows Aldo’s so well. We have so much respect for what Aldo built here, and every day we just aim to honor that—with great coffee and the kind of place people want to keep coming back to. Your support means the world. Hope to see you again soon. – Josh

Ari Paparo 2026.04.01

     

Josh the owner is a force of nature. Great to see him continuing where Aldo left off.

Useful Report

Reply from Aldo's Coffee Company 2026.04.01

Thank you for the kind words. Taking care of what Aldo built means a lot to me, and I’m lucky to be surrounded by a community that gets it. Hope to see you again soon. – Josh

Randi Parker 2026.03.28

     

Useful Report

Reply from Aldo's Coffee Company 2026.03.28

Thanks so much for the kind words and the five stars. It means a lot to us that you enjoyed your time here. We care about keeping things simple—good coffee, good company—and it’s nice to know that connected with you. Hope to see you again soon. – Josh

Mike Reviewed It! 2026.03.22

     

Got here just 10 minutes before they closed. Went with an Americano and Bae got an espresso and Saratoga spring water. Coffee is very strong. I like it. I like the seating area, coffee bags covered cushions and original local themed art work on the wall. They have seating out back too but since they were about to close we had to take it to go.

Useful Report

Reply from Aldo's Coffee Company 2026.03.21

Thank you for stopping by, even close to closing time. Glad to hear you enjoyed the coffee and the space—we care a lot about creating an environment that feels welcoming and true to who we are. If you’re ever back in Greenport, we’d love to have you stay a little longer and enjoy the back garden. Safe travels. – Josh

Linda Meise 2026.03.14

     

We were enjoying coffee and scones at Aldo's long before he sold the business to the new owners. And I am happy to report that the coffee experience is just as good. Not only have the new owners carried on Aldo's long-standing coffee bean roasting tradition, but they have also expanded the menu offerings in very tasty ways. And if you are a local, take advantage of their "Points" program which results in freebees--always a welcome treat!

Useful Report

Reply from Aldo's Coffee Company 2026.03.14

Thanks for the kind words. It means a lot to hear that the coffee and experience still feel right to you—we try every day to honor what Aldo built while adding a few touches of our own. And yes, locals like you are a big part of what makes this place special, so we’re glad the points program has been a nice little extra. Looking forward to seeing you again soon.

Gordy Rogers 2026.03.14

     

Fabulous coffee spot - the best on the North Fork in my opinion. Grab a coffee and chill on their back patio and watch the Shelter Island ferry come and go...also probably the best biscotti I've ever had...

Useful Report

Reply from Aldo's Coffee Company 2026.03.14

Thanks so much for the kind words. It means a lot to hear that you enjoy the coffee and the biscotti—and that the patio feels like a good spot to spend some time. That’s what we hope for. Appreciate you stopping by and sharing this.

Linda L. 2026.03.12

     

Useful Report

Reply from Aldo's Coffee Company 2026.03.12

Thanks so much for the kind review. It means a lot to us that you enjoyed your time here. We care deeply about good coffee and creating a space that feels welcoming, so hearing this is grounding. Hope to see you again soon. – Josh

sherman childress 2026.03.11

     

Great coffee!

Useful Report

Reply from Aldo's Coffee Company 2026.03.11

Thanks for stopping in and for the kind words. We care deeply about making a great cup of coffee, and it's always good to hear when it resonates. Hope to see you again soon.

Doug B. 2026.03.01

     

Verified

The smell and taste is so delightful of the coffee. The employees are really, really nice. and I love Greenport

Useful Report

Reply from Aldo's Coffee Company 2026.03.01

Doug — this made our day. Thanks for taking the time to write it.

If you’re back in Greenport soon, swing in and say hi. First biscotti’s on us.

Cheers.