Watermark of Wading River

Watermark of Wading River Reviews

Excellent rating
     
4.8 | 253 reviews
Trustindex Verified Company
Watermark of Wading River
Write a review

Reviews

Trustindex

4.8

| 253 total

221 pcs
22 pcs
4 pcs
2 pcs
4 pcs
Source filter
Esmeralda Herrera
Esmeralda Herrera 2025.11.23
     
Oh my God! This place is wonderful! Besides the delicious food, the service is amazing. The waiters and bussers were super attentive and friendly. It's a great place for a delicious dinner. I'm a little embarrassed because my husband didn't know what to order and bothered our waiter, Conner, quite a bit, but he's so, so good. I loved how he served us and how patient he was with us. Thank you so much for your attention! I will definitely be back for the third time. It's my favorite place now.
joseph bair
joseph bair 2025.11.20
     
5 Stars across the board. Food, Service, atmosphere!!!
yvonne bendzlowicz
yvonne bendzlowicz 2025.11.16
     
Perfect in every way. My favorite place
Kathie Ferrandino
Kathie Ferrandino 2025.11.10
     
Always a good meal and great cocktails. Servers are very friendly.
Jesse Citro
Jesse Citro 2025.10.19
     
First time at Watermark the food was phenomenal! We ordered a bunch of Apps for 5 people (rice balls, meatballs short rib quesadilla, stuffed mushrooms) all 10/10. I got the orecchiette pasta special wish sausage and the meal was perfect. The cocktails were so good and atmosphere was great. The dessert (german chocolate cake) was not traditional but 10/10. You could just tell there was so much love and care put behind every dish and would definitely go back. Give this place a try if you havent!
Thomas LoSquadro
Thomas LoSquadro 2025.10.15
     
This place has it all. Family run and well run.
Alexander Steinkoenig
Alexander Steinkoenig 2025.10.05
     
The crab cake eggs benedict was unbelievable. (Lobster hollandaise? Like what??) Also, our server Jenny was 10/10. If we open a restaurant, we’re totally poaching her. (Egg pun intended) We live an hour away, but we’ll be back next weekend!
Lauren Stawski
Lauren Stawski 2025.09.21
     
Visited while on a quick weekend trip and found this restaurant based on their already stellar google review score. Food was absolutely delicious… true perfection! So many great menu options! Even offer plenty of unique brunch and lunch specials, that seem to be rotating. I enjoyed everything and even cleaned my plate, my meal was that good!! I got the crab cake sandwich with home fries and my best friend got the turkey melt with french fries. They roast and carve their own turkey, which is such a treat. Everything is made to order with real and fresh ingredients. Food comes out of the kitchen perfect, with minimal wait time. True compliments to the chefs! If you have to wait for seating, the wait is well worth it for the quality of the food, trust me! They do also have a full bar, margaritas were super tasty! Staff is wonderful, super friendly and very hard working. Staff are vigilant and ready to deliver drinks and pick up your garbage promptly! It also was very hard for me and my friend to decide on our meal choices because of so many good and enticing options. Really feel like there is something on the menu for EVERYONE! If ever I’m in this area again, I will for sure be coming back to this restaurant!
Gerri Surdi
Gerri Surdi 2025.09.21
     
Real nice local surprise. Serves gluten free. Our server Connor was great. Food was good. Definitely will return.
Kai Troescher
Kai Troescher 2025.09.20
     
We were there for a rehearsal dinner on 9/18. My daughter is deathly allergic to dairy and eggs. Connor, our waiter, made sure that my oldest still was able to have food, and was comfortable. He went ABOVE and beyond for my daughter, making her comfortable and seen. The food was absolutely immaculate.
J T
J T 2025.09.09
     
$16 lunch set INCLUDING a drink?! Yes, just try it yourself, silly :)
michael wern
michael wern 2025.08.31
     
Great food. Great service. Will definitely be back

Skyrocket Your Sales with Customer Reviews. No coding required.

Create a Free Account