Under the Sea Diving | Playa Potrero Dive Center Reviews

Demi 2025.11.29

     

We had the best dive with Aaron and his team. Jose was our guide and he made us feel extremely comfortable and pointed out lots of marine life. We saw white-tip sharks, rays, eels, shrimp, octopus, and more! They kept the group small and were all so friendly. Cannot recommend Aaron and the team more!

Useful Report

Reply from Under the Sea Diving | Playa Potrero Dive Center 2025.11.29

Thank you so much for your wonderful review! We’re thrilled to hear you had such an amazing dive with us. José will be delighted to know he helped make your experience comfortable and memorable—and it sounds like the ocean really delivered with all that incredible marine life!

We take pride in keeping our groups small and creating a relaxed, friendly atmosphere, so it means a lot to know that stood out to you. On behalf of Aaron and the entire team, thank you for diving with us and for the recommendation. We hope to welcome you back for more underwater adventures soon! 🌊🤿

Garret Albers 2025.11.27

     

Best time ever. Jose is an amazing instructor. I learned a ton and had the best time!

Useful Report

Reply from Under the Sea Diving | Playa Potrero Dive Center 2025.11.27

Thank you so much for your review!
We’re thrilled to hear you had such a great time diving with us. Jose will be delighted to know you enjoyed the experience and learned a lot along the way. It’s always our goal to make every dive both fun and educational, and we’re so glad that came through for you.

We hope to see you back underwater with us again soon! 🌊🤿

MARIA CATALINA BOETSCH HEVIA 2025.11.27

     

¡Excelente experiencia! Buceamos en Islas Catalina y disfrutamos mucho! El equipo de guías muy profesional y con mucho conocimiento de la zona. Nuestro guía fue Jose Algaba y lo hizo increíble! Era mi primera inmersión luego de certificarme y fue un lujo! Vimos tiburones, tortugas y todo tipo de peces. Espero repetir pronto la experiencia!

Useful Report

Reply from Under the Sea Diving | Playa Potrero Dive Center 2025.11.27

¡Muchísimas gracias por tomarse el tiempo de compartir su experiencia!

Nos alegra enormemente saber que su día de buceo en las Islas Catalina fue tan especial. Nuestro equipo trabaja con mucha dedicación para ofrecer seguridad, profesionalismo y un ambiente relajado, así que nos llena de orgullo saber que lo sintió así. José estará encantado de saber que hizo que su primera inmersión post-certificación fuera tan memorable.

Qué dicha que pudieron ver tiburones, tortugas y tanta vida marina — ¡un verdadero lujo de bienvenida al Pacífico!
Será un placer recibirles nuevamente cuando quieran repetir la aventura. ¡Aquí los esperamos para más burbujas y buenas experiencias!

Jonah 2025.11.26

     

Great dive, saw lots of cool fish. Staff very professional and very knowledgeable about safety procedures.

Useful Report

Reply from Under the Sea Diving | Playa Potrero Dive Center 2025.11.26

Thank you for your kind words – they mean the world to us!
We're overjoyed that your time with us was memorable and that our team put your mind at ease every step of the way. Safety is at the heart of everything we do, and it's rewarding to hear it shone through.
Can't wait to dive deeper with you again soon – the sea has endless surprises in store.

The Under the Sea Diving Team!

Kacper Kwapisz 2025.11.22

     

Absolutely a 10/10 experience! Jose, our instructor, was incredibly professional, fun, and friendly — exactly the kind of person you want to dive with. The owners were just as welcoming and kind, creating a super positive atmosphere from the moment we arrived. The booking is very easy and efficient through whatsapp. The Discover Scuba session in the pool was perfect: very detailed, clear, and well explained. During our two dives in Islas Catalinas we saw baby sharks, guitar fish, cornet fish, rays, eels and a lot of other beautiful fish. Their equipment is all new and high quality, which makes you feel safe and comfortable from the start. A great bonus is how convenient everything is — the pool is right at their office, and the beach/boat pickup is just there, so you don’t need to drive anywhere. After the dives, we had a detailed briefing going through all the species we saw, which made the experience even better. Additionally, you can take a shower after the dive which is not always the case. Highly recommended — amazing team, great setup, and truly memorable dives!

Useful Report

Reply from Under the Sea Diving | Playa Potrero Dive Center 2025.11.22

Thank you so much for taking the time to share such a thoughtful and detailed review. It means a lot to our whole team. We’re thrilled to hear that your Discover Scuba experience felt smooth, welcoming, and memorable from start to finish — that’s exactly what we aim for.

Jose will be delighted to know his professionalism and energy made a difference. We’re also glad the convenience of our setup, from the on-site pool to the beach pickup, helped make your day easy and enjoyable. Hearing that you felt comfortable with the equipment and well-supported throughout the dives is especially important to us.

The Catalinas gave you a fantastic show — baby sharks, guitarfish, rays, eels — it sounds like a beautiful day underwater, and reviewing the marine life afterward is one of our favorite parts too.

Thank you again for diving with us and for such a warm recommendation. We hope to welcome you back for more adventures soon!
The Under the Sea Team 🌊🐢

Christian Dahm 2025.11.21

     

Fantastic experience from start to finish. Booking was easy via WhatsApp, did all the paperwork easy and online, got to the Dive Centre and saw immediately it’s a well equipped, professional operation. José, our dive master tailored our experience perfectly to our skill level, the Catalina dives were gorgeous, reef sharks, eagle and other rays, guitar fish, lobster, moray eels, nudibranches, huge schools of fish…In between dives we had great chats with the dive centre crew over delicious fresh pineapple.

Useful Report

Reply from Under the Sea Diving | Playa Potrero Dive Center 2025.11.21

Dear Christian,
Thank you so much for your wonderful review – it genuinely made our day!
We're delighted everything ran smoothly from start to finish, that José looked after you so well, and that you enjoyed the dives (and the pineapple!). Feedback like yours is the best reward for the entire team.
We'd be thrilled to have you back on board anytime – there's always more to explore.
Warmest regards and safe bubbles,
The Under the Sea Diving Team!

Raphael Tessier 2025.11.19

     

Useful Report

Reply from Under the Sea Diving | Playa Potrero Dive Center 2025.11.20

Thank you so much for the 5-star rating! 🌟
We really appreciate you taking the time to share your support, and we’re glad you had a great experience with us. If you ever return to the area, we’d love to welcome you back for more adventures! The Under the Sea Team

Keana V 2025.11.16

     

Verified

Great experience! Fun, knowledgeable diving guides Jose and Wally. They made sure we were briefed and ready to go before each dive and gave good feedback after. They made the experience very comfortable and exciting. Thanks again!

Useful Report

Reply from Under the Sea Diving | Playa Potrero Dive Center 2025.11.17

Thank you so much for taking the time to share your experience with us! We’re really glad to hear you enjoyed your dives and felt well taken care of throughout the day. Jose and Wally are fantastic at what they do, and it’s great to know their briefings, guidance, and feedback helped make your dives both comfortable and exciting.We truly appreciate you choosing to dive with us and hope we’ll have the chance to welcome you back for more underwater adventures in the future. Safe travels until then! 🌊🤿

Lena Schmidlechner 2025.11.15

     

Very nice staff, we dived with Wally and Jose and it was a super smooth and nice experience!

Useful Report

Reply from Under the Sea Diving | Playa Potrero Dive Center 2025.11.16

Thank you so much for taking the time to share your feedback—it truly means the world to us! We're thrilledn that Wally and Jose made your dives so memorable, and it's always rewarding to hear how our crew brings that extra spark to the ocean. Can't wait to host you again for more epic explorations below the surface.
Dive safe and see you soon!
The Under the Sea Team!

Mario Lopez 2025.11.14

     

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Experiencia increíble de scuba diving Tuve una experiencia espectacular haciendo scuba diving. Desde el inicio, José y Wally fueron extremadamente profesionales, pacientes y atentos. Explicaron todo con claridad, transmitieron mucha seguridad y lograron que la experiencia fuera divertida y tranquila. El equipo estaba en excelentes condiciones, los puntos de buceo fueron increíbles y en todo momento me sentí acompañado y seguro. Se nota la pasión y el conocimiento que tienen por lo que hacen. Recomiendo esta experiencia al 100%. ¡Gracias José y Wally por hacer de este día algo inolvidable!

Useful Report

Reply from Under the Sea Diving | Playa Potrero Dive Center 2025.11.14

¡Muchísimas gracias por compartir tu experiencia!
Nos alegra enormemente saber que tu día de buceo fue tan especial. José y Wally son realmente dedicados a crear un ambiente seguro, relajado y lleno de buenos momentos bajo el agua, y saber que lo sentiste así nos llena de orgullo.

Gracias por recomendarnos y por confiar en nuestro equipo. Ojalá tengamos la oportunidad de bucear contigo nuevamente muy pronto.
¡Pura vida!
The Under the Sea Team

Mario L 2025.11.13

     

Verified

5 star underwater experience ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Amazing scuba diving experienceI had a spectacular experience doing scuba diving. From the beginning, José and Wally were extremely professional, patient and attentive. They explained everything clearly, conveyed a lot of security, and made the experience fun and calm.The equipment was in excellent condition, the dive spots were incredible and I felt accompanied and safe at all times. You can see the passion and knowledge they have for what they do.I recommend this experience 100%. Thank you José and Wally for making this day unforgettable!

Useful Report

Eleanor Bruce 2025.11.09

     

I am so glad that we found under the sea! The staff were so friendly and welcoming. Altogether there was only 4 of us on the boat with 3 dive masters. All of which were great people with wonderful attitudes. The owner Erin was very knowledgeable and passionate about the ocean. Hannah was an absolute rock star!! The vis was not great but that’s what happens at this time of year. The staff still made it a great experience and found us plenty of cool things to look at !! Including white tip sharks and shark teeth, octopus, lots of eels, scorpion fish, various rays, a lone pilot whale swimming on the surface plus a load of jumping devil rays !! We didn’t see any manta.. José said it’s Erin fault 😬 (Jks) Jose took load photos for us, which are great and well worth the $50 bucks! Can’t wait to go back! Thank you for a great experience 🙏🏽

Useful Report

Reply from Under the Sea Diving | Playa Potrero Dive Center 2025.11.09

Thank you so much for taking the time to share your glowing review—it's feedback like yours that keeps our team energized and passionate about what we do! We're thrilled to hear that Aaron, Hannah, and José made your adventure unforgettable, even with the seasonal visibility challenges. Spotting those white-tip sharks, eels, scorpionfish, rays, and that majestic pilot whale sounds like a highlight reel we all wish we could relive. (And we'll take the playful blame for the elusive mantas—next time, we'll rally the ocean on your behalf!)
We're especially grateful you enjoyed the photos; José has a knack for capturing those magic moments. It was a pleasure hosting your group of four, and we can't wait to welcome you back for more underwater wonders. Safe travels until then!

Warmly,
The Under the Sea Team

Compass571786 2025.11.09

     

Verified

So much sea life Great diving experiences- thank you Andy! You made us feel very at ease with your knowledge and experience. Really recommend!

Useful Report

Reply from Under the Sea Diving | Playa Potrero Dive Center 2025.11.10

Thank you so much for your kind words! We're thrilled you had such a great diving experience and felt comfortable throughout. We truly appreciate your recommendation! We look forward to seeing you again. Team at Under the Sea Diving

Heath Rouse 2025.11.06

     

The whole team at Under the Sea is awesome. I had two great dives at the Catalina’s. I can’t say enough positive things about this experience.

Useful Report

Reply from Under the Sea Diving | Playa Potrero Dive Center 2025.11.06

Thank you so much for your kind words! We’re thrilled to hear you had such a great experience diving with us at the Catalinas. Our team truly loves what we do, and it means a lot to know that came through during your dives. We hope to welcome you back soon for more underwater adventures!

The Under the Sea Team 🌊🐢

Trucold 2025.11.05

     

Verified

Highly recommended. The team at Under the Sea is incredibly dedicated and passionate about providing the best possible experience to the divers, experienced or learning. I highly recommend them if you’re interested in a great diving experience.

Useful Report

Reply from Under the Sea Diving | Playa Potrero Dive Center 2025.11.06

Thank you so much for your wonderful review and recommendation! We’re really happy to hear you felt the passion and dedication of our team — that’s exactly what we strive for on every dive. It was a pleasure having you with us, and we hope to see you again soon for more great underwater experiences!— Aaron & the Under the Sea Diving Team

Peter Read 2025.10.27

     

Top-Notch Scuba Shop with Incredible People! I had an absolutely amazing experience with this scuba shop! From start to finish, everything was smooth, professional, and fun. Aaron, the owner, is fantastic — knowledgeable, welcoming, and clearly passionate about diving. He’s recently added a brand new boat custom-built for scuba diving that will be so nice when it can be put to use! It’s spacious and perfect for exploring the beautiful dive sites in the area. Hannah, the office manager, is a ray of sunshine! She’s super responsive, cheerful, and made booking and logistics a breeze. Her friendly attitude and attention to detail really stood out. And Josue, our dive guide, was phenomenal. He’s experienced, patient, and made every dive feel safe and exciting. He went above and beyond to make sure everyone had a great time. If you’re looking for a dive shop that combines professionalism, warmth, and top-tier equipment, this is the place. I can’t recommend them enough — I’ll definitely be back!

Useful Report

Reply from Under the Sea Diving | Playa Potrero Dive Center 2025.10.28

Thank you so much for your thoughtful and detailed review! It really means a lot to all of us to hear you had such a great experience from start to finish. We’re so glad you felt well taken care of — Hannah, Josue, and I all appreciate your kind words. We take pride in keeping things professional, organized, and fun while creating a relaxed, friendly atmosphere both on land and underwater. Hearing that it all came together for you makes our day. We can’t wait to have you back for more great dives and good vibes here in Costa Rica!
—The Under the Sea Team 🌊🐢

Ina Rose 2025.10.26

     

Great diving center located directly at the beach. Very easy going for the divers since the instructors already loaded all equipment to the boat upfront. The equipment is brand new, high quality and taken good care of. Our instructor, José, was fun and a happy guy who obviously loves his job. But he was also very serious about the dive briefing which we liked. He kept the perfect balance of humor and sense of responsibility - he just made us feel comfortable at all times and we had an excellent time both under and above the water. We went to La Pared and Dos Sombreros and saw white tip reef sharks in both spots as well as murenas, octopus, tuna, some fish swarms and loads of very pretty sea stars 💫 We would definitely recommend this place to our friends 👌🏼

Useful Report

Reply from Under the Sea Diving | Playa Potrero Dive Center 2025.10.26

Thank you so much for your wonderful review! We’re really happy to hear you enjoyed your dives with us and that you appreciated the little details we focus on — from preparing the gear in advance to keeping our equipment in top condition. José will be thrilled to know he helped make your dives both fun and comfortable; he truly loves what he does and it shows underwater.

La Pared and Dos Sombreros are beautiful sites, and it sounds like you had a great mix of marine life out there — sharks, octopus, tuna, and even sea stars always make for a special day.

We really appreciate your recommendation and hope to welcome you back for more dives soon!
—The Under the Sea Team 🌊🐢

Rich Smith 2025.10.18

     

Useful Report

Reply from Under the Sea Diving | Playa Potrero Dive Center 2025.10.19

Thank you for taking the time to rate us Rich, we had a great time diving with you.
—The Under the Sea Team 🌊🐢

Eric Scharf Taitelbaum 2025.10.06

     

We spent the last weekend diving with Under the See Diving, both in Catalinas and Bat Islands. It was a pleasure diving with his owner Aaron and his great and professional staff. The experience was absolutely incredible! Their service is of the highest level, putting attention to all details needed by divers to enjoy the experience and make our lifes easier. Their equipment is in great condition (contrary to other dive centers I have been with). They are super focus on safety for the divers, with extended breifings of each dive (also very different to the basic breafings I have seen in other places). In summary, Aaron and his team are very professional, friendly, client oriented and safety focused. Super recommended!

Useful Report

Reply from Under the Sea Diving | Playa Potrero Dive Center 2025.10.06

Thank you so much for taking the time to share this Eric, it truly means a lot. Diving the Catalinas and Bat Islands in the same weekend is a big adventure, and we’re really glad you chose to do it with us. We put a lot of care into every detail to make sure our guests are safe and comfortable— from equipment maintenance to safety briefings — so hearing that it all made a difference in your experience is incredibly rewarding for our whole team.

It was a pleasure spending those dives with you, and I’ll be sure to pass your kind words on to the crew. We hope to see you back underwater soon for more great dives (and maybe a few more bull sharks!).

—The Under the Sea Team 🌊🐢

Eric 2025.10.06

     

Verified

GREAT diving experience! We spent the last weekend diving with Under the See Diving, both in Catalinas and Bat Islands. It was a pleasure diving with his owner Aaron and his great and professional staff. The experience was absolutely incredible! Their service is of the highest level, putting attention to all details needed by divers to enjoy the experience and make our lifes easier. Their equipment is in great condition (contrary to other dive centers I have been with). They are super focus on safety for the divers, with extended breifings of each dive (also very different to the basic breafings I have seen in other places). In summary, Aaron and his team are very professional, friendly, client oriented and safety focused. Super recommended!

Useful Report

Reply from Under the Sea Diving | Playa Potrero Dive Center 2025.10.08

Thank you so much for your wonderful review!It was a real pleasure diving with you over the weekend — both at the Catalinas and the Bat Islands. I’m really glad to hear you enjoyed the experience and appreciated the extra attention we put into briefings, safety, and equipment. We always try to make every dive as smooth, safe, and memorable as possible, so hearing your feedback means a lot to both me and the entire team.The Bat Islands trip is always a special one, and it was great to share those moments underwater with such an enthusiastic and experienced diver. On behalf of everyone at Under the Sea Diving, thank you again for choosing to dive with us and for taking the time to write such thoughtful words. We hope to see you back soon for more adventures beneath the surface!—The Under the Sea Team 🌊🐢