The Tin Fish Newburgh

The Tin Fish Newburgh Reviews

Excellent rating
     
4.5 | 1493 reviews
Trustindex Verified Company
The Tin Fish Newburgh
Write a review

Reviews

Trustindex

4.5

| 1493 total

901 pcs
273 pcs
80 pcs
40 pcs
29 pcs
Source filter
Don Vos
Don Vos 2026.03.07
     
Hate to rate service low as it is NOT due to the people working there. They had prices listed menus and came out to the line to give us menus. Then at the counter when we ordered they tried to charge each of us $3 more than the menu stated. Tried to say they were old menus but even at the counter the price was what we were seeing and these were specifically made for Lent..and it is during Lent so how old could they be? Finally took a little off our total but make sure you watch what they try to charge.
Ada Mason
Ada Mason 2026.03.04
     
Tin fish has fallen into the fast food trap of mediocre food and service. Far different from the old place where they used to be.
Taylor B.
Taylor B. 2026.02.28
     
Trustindex Verified
Best chicken tenders. Nice and thin. Fast service. Nice staff. Great outdoor atmosphere. 10/10
Jason Russler
Jason Russler 2026.02.21
     
Not good Worst meal ever. I had almost no fish on my taco. Definitely not worth the money and we will not return .
Date of experience: 20 February, 2026
Mark Martinez
Mark Martinez 2026.01.28
     
Ordered to go. Friendly service but what happened to the portion size? Haven't been there in over 9 months and the the fish and chips is not worth the price anymore.
Lori Ann
Lori Ann 2026.01.13
     
Great food. Service was a bit odd, ordering at the counter and they didn't ring up everything we ordered. But it was definitely worth the wait.
Steve D
Steve D 2025.12.21
     
Helpful staff. Clean restarant. Most important, they know how to perfectly cook seafood. Best oysters I've had outside louisiana. This place is worth going out of your way.
Jason and Regina Stephenson
Jason and Regina Stephenson 2025.11.30
     
We love, love the Sunday brunch that is still advertised on the website but the restaurant isn’t doing anymore apparently. We’ve been in several times, including today, hoping for the Brunch menu since the website hasn’t been updated. Their regular menu is ok, brunch menu is fantastic.
Pamela W.
Pamela W. 2025.11.26
     
Trustindex Verified
We have been going to the Tin Fish for several years. The food has always been good. One of our favorite memories is taking our grandson since he was a baby and watching him enjoy a meal.
Debbie Moore
Debbie Moore 2025.11.13
     
My husband, daughter and I went for lunch. It wasn’t very crowded. You go up to the counter and order. They have delicious slaw and fries. The fried fish was decent. I ordered red snapper. It was not cheap and I was very disappointed. It had very little flavor and was very dry. I would go back for the fish and fries. The shrimp and clams are both very good, but the snapper was a big letdown.

Skyrocket Your Sales with Customer Reviews. No coding required.

Create a Free Account