Smart Roofing and Sheet Metal Company

Smart Roofing and Sheet Metal Company Reviews

Excellent rating
5.0 | 301 reviews
Trustindex Verified Company
Smart Roofing and Sheet Metal Company
Write a review

Smart Roofing and Sheet Metal Company rating: 5.0 out of 5 from 301 reviews

Trustindex 5.0 | 301 total

Rating breakdown

295 pcs
4 pcs
1 pc
0 pc
1 pc
Source filter

What customers say about Smart Roofing and Sheet Metal Company

Recent reviews

Zac Slavens
Zac Slavens 2026.11.21
Dale and Tom have been incredibly helpful with our roof replacement, going above and beyond to get a proactive leak fix in place right away and ahead of the full replacement for peace of mind. Great guys and great work, highly recommend going with Smart Roofing.
Report
Tesla Knight Productions
Tesla Knight Productions 2026.11.15
Dale did an amazing job. I was in a pinch before the winter and needed my dormer extension sealed up with the rest of the existing dormer, this included the roof, vents, skylight, and he even found siding that matched. He was incredibly professional, timely, and fun to chat with. All of his guys were hard workers, nice, and did a great job of cleaning up after. Will definitely recommend to everyone I know.
Report
Caleb Osborne
Caleb Osborne 2026.11.06
I can't recommend Smart Roofing & Sheet Metal Company highly enough! They recently completed a full asphalt shingle roof replacement on our 1921 duplex in Milwaukee's Bay View neighborhood, and I can confidently say this was the best experience I've ever had working with a contractor. Given the age of our home, we knew the project could be complicated. The team discovered multiple layers of old roofing, original cedar shake, and deteriorating roof decking left behind from previous roofing jobs. Rather than cutting corners, they carefully removed the old materials, addressed the underlying issues, and made sure our new roof was installed properly. Their knowledge, craftsmanship, and attention to detail gave us tremendous confidence that the job was being done right. What truly sets Smart Roofing apart is their communication and transparency. Joe was incredibly helpful throughout the estimating and planning process, thoroughly explaining our options and helping us make informed decisions. Dale, the owner, was on-site working alongside his crew every day, keeping us updated as unexpected issues were uncovered and explaining exactly how they were being addressed. My wife and I learned more about our home's roof in those few days than we had from years of working with other contractors. Despite the extensive tear-off and additional repairs, the crew finished in just 2.5 days, ahead of schedule. They were punctual, professional, and incredibly thorough with cleanup, even making multiple passes to check our driveway for nails and debris. Their pricing was competitive with other estimates we received, but the level of workmanship, communication, and care they provided was worth every penny. It's rare to find a contractor who puts this much effort into doing things the right way rather than simply taking the easiest approach. Our roof is now in better condition than ever, and we couldn't be happier! If you're looking for a knowledgeable, trustworthy roofing contractor in Milwaukee or southeastern Wisconsin, especially for an older home or complicated roof replacement, I wholeheartedly recommend Smart Roofing. Dale, Joe, and the entire crew have earned our trust and will be our first call for any future roofing needs!
Report
Reply from Smart Roofing and Sheet Metal Company 2024.12.12
Thanks for the review, happy to help ya with your roofing needs!!
Rob Noerenberg
Rob Noerenberg 2026.11.03
The owner Dale came out to check out my leaking chimney, he spent 2 hours up on my roof with tar and caulk and did not charge me for a thing. We had a nice conversation about his family business and he truly runs the company the way his grandfather did. In our conversation, he told me how the company's largest customer was earned by a free tube of caulk. He has earned my business and I will recommend him to everyone.
Report
Reply from Smart Roofing and Sheet Metal Company 2026.11.04
Thanks for sharing your experience Rob. Glad Joey was able to identify your problem and Dale handled repairing your chimney leak and other areas of concern.
Mike Armstrong
Mike Armstrong 2026.11.01
Dale and his team replaced a roof for our meeting hall and office we use for our charity work. They did excellent work, were professional, and were timely. I would highly recommend them for your roofing needs.
Report
TC
TC 2026.10.31
After dealing with ongoing water intrusion and the frustration of trying to find someone willing to tackle our complicated roof, I cannot say enough good things about Smart Roofing & Sheet Metal! Our home has a unique architectural design and finding someone with the expertise to identify the source of the leak was no easy task. I spent countless hours contacting roofing companies, only to be given the runaround or told they weren't interested in taking on the project. It was incredibly frustrating, especially when all I wanted was someone knowledgeable who would take the time to figure out the problem and help us fix it. Then I found Smart Roofing & Sheet Metal, Dale was responsive, knowledgeable, and, most importantly, willing to take on a challenge that others seemed to want to avoid. He took the time to thoroughly investigate our roof, successfully pinpointed the source of the leak, and completed the necessary emergency repair to stop the water intrusion. What impressed me most was that Dale actually listened to my concerns. He explained what he was finding, answered my questions, and treated me with respect throughout the process. I never felt dismissed or as though I was asking too many questions. After dealing with so much frustration, it was such a relief to finally work with someone who genuinely cared about finding a solution. As a homeowner, there is nothing more stressful than water coming into your home. Finding a contractor who has the knowledge, takes pride in his work, and is willing to tackle the difficult jobs makes all the difference. I wholeheartedly recommend Smart Roofing & Sheet Metal, especially if you have a complicated roof design, metal roofing, or a leak that others haven't been able or willing to figure out.
Report
Therese Schulz-Popp
Therese Schulz-Popp 2026.10.30
Searched online for roofers and found this gem! After having multiple estimates, Smart Roofing was my choice. Experienced, knowledgeable, honest, efficient and all for fair price. Crew was done in one day and thoroughly cleaned up. Went above and beyond expectations repairing and replacing roof. Highly recommend!
Report
Reply from Smart Roofing and Sheet Metal Company 2026.10.30
Thank you for sharing your experience Therese! Now that we installed a trusted shingle for this market you can have a peace of mind.
Joseph Hilger
Joseph Hilger 2026.10.20
Report
Reply from Smart Roofing and Sheet Metal Company 2026.10.30
Joseph! We appreciate the review! Glad we could assist you with your repair.
Terry Miller
Terry Miller 2026.10.17
We had received a referral from a close friend on the quality and conscientiousness of Smart Roofing. I called them and Joey came over and did a full inspection of our roof and identified a couple of things that should be done before winter. He suggested too that when looking at roofing jobs to plan for them in the spring. About a week later Dale and Joy came over and they recaulked our chimney flashing and did some preventative work on the spot. They both have been very responsive and we look forward to doing our roof project in the spring with Smart Roofing.
Report
Reply from Smart Roofing and Sheet Metal Company 2026.10.30
Thank you for the thoughtful review Terry! We're glad we could help you with the leak and other questionable areas.
Richard Domack
Richard Domack 2026.10.15
They were very prompt on the day expected. The crew was extremely efficient and knowledgeable. All work was done with extreme attention to quality. Everything was done in one day, without having to come back a second day to finish.
Report
Reply from Smart Roofing and Sheet Metal Company 2025.12.12
Thanks for trusting in our team to get it done right the first time! Let us know if you ever need anything down the road Richard!
leti chico
leti chico 2026.10.14
Thank you Dale for responding to our early-morning request to inspect a roof leak. You were responsive, knowledgeable, and professional. We appreciate you taking the time to return and complete the repairs despite your busy schedule.
Report
Reply from Smart Roofing and Sheet Metal Company 2026.10.30
You're very welcome Leti! Thank you for supporting Smart Roofing.
Paul Welter
Paul Welter 2026.10.08
We hired Smart Roofing after comparing a total of four estimates, they were not the least expensive but, as a small family owned contractor we felt that they would be the most reliable in the event of any problems that may arise in the future. The crew arrived at the time stated each day and went right to work, everyone had a job to do and they worked as a team. No wasted motion! Everyone was polite and respectful of our property and belongings. We were kept updated every step of the way, cleanup was ongoing throughout the 2+ day project and when the project was complete we found very little in the way of debris/nails. Dale the owner was on site and on the roof during the entire project, his diligence and attention to detail was outstanding. As homeowners since 1981 we have hired many contractors through the years, Dale and Smart Roofing are at the top of the heap! We have already recommended Smart Roofing to 3 different people who asked if we would recommend them and we do recommend them to anyone that has roofing needs.
Report
Reply from Smart Roofing and Sheet Metal Company 2026.10.30
Wow Paul, thank you for sharing your experience down to the gritty details. Those are what matter! It was a privilege to handle your roof replacement project. We appreciate your support.
joe kachelmeyer
joe kachelmeyer 2026.10.02
I had a leak in my roof and called smart roofing. Dale came shortly there after and found where the leaking shingles were. All good now and my impression of him to be honest, knowledgeable, hard working, and just a nice guy.
Report
Reply from Smart Roofing and Sheet Metal Company 2026.10.30
Glad to hear the leak is gone and we were able to service it for you Joe. Call us down the road when you need another assessment of the roof!
Ruud Lenssen
Ruud Lenssen 2026.10.01
We had a small leak in our sunroom and called the guys at Smart roofing for a quote on a potential repair/replacement. Joey came over to the house and after a thorough inspection said that he could replace the poorly installed old flashing but, it would cause damage to the siding of the house. He recommended a temporary repair to stop the leak and advised to have it permanently fixed when we replace the siding in the near future. He fixed it right away on the spot! What a class act! Old school service and genuinely wanted to help, not just make a quick buck. Great job, Joey!!
Report
Reply from Smart Roofing and Sheet Metal Company 2026.10.02
Thank you for sharing your experience! We’re thrilled to hear Joey provided helpful, honest service and a thoughtful solution. Your kind words mean a lot, and we’ll be sure to pass along your praise to him.
Ryan Siegler
Ryan Siegler 2026.09.29
Outstanding experience! I needed a roofing quote after another company I contacted for a siding estimate told me that I also needed a new roof. Joey came out, thoroughly inspected everything, and informed me that my roof was actually in good working order. He took the time to address all of my concerns and never tried to sell me something I didn’t need. If you’re looking for an honest quote from a trustworthy company—with reviews that back up their performance—this is the place to go. When the time does come for a new roof, they’ll be the first company I call. Thanks again, Joey! Highly recommend!
Report
Reply from Smart Roofing and Sheet Metal Company 2026.10.02
Thank you for sharing your experience! We're glad Joey could provide you with an honest assessment and address your concerns. We’ll be here whenever you need us for your future roofing needs.
William Cray
William Cray 2026.09.16
Dale at smart roofing is awesome! He inspected the roof on a property we were looking to buy and was really knowledgeable. While doing that inspection, I told him we had a small amount of water coming in our current home and he came right over to take a look. All the other roofers we had were complete sales guys just trying to sell us a new roof for 30k+. Dale said some simple repairs would suffice and to save the $. He's working up an estimate for us. It felt like he was advising and consulting us rather than just trying to suck as much money out of us as possible like the 2 other companies we had come look at our roof. Not to mention, when he was here he said he's pretty sure he figured out why the water was coming in and just put a handful of screws in and some caulk around a vent. He did it on the spot and didn't charge us. Just a really down to earth good guy.
Report
Reply from Smart Roofing and Sheet Metal Company 2026.10.02
Thank you for sharing your experience with Dale! We're thrilled to hear he provided honest advice and exceptional service. Your feedback highlights why we value his commitment to helping clients make informed decisions. Let us know if you need anything further!
Ashley Kline
Ashley Kline 2026.08.18
I am writing to share my appreciation for the excellent service we received recently. We had some flashing leaking on our chimney, and Dale went above and beyond to come to our house in an extremely timely manner. He went up on the roof, identified the exact problem, and fixed it immediately. Unlike the other contractors we had over, there was no guesswork involved. Smart Roofing will be handling all of our roofing needs from now on. I highly recommend their services to everyone.
Report
Reply from Smart Roofing and Sheet Metal Company 2026.10.02
Thank you for sharing your positive experience Ashley! We're thrilled to hear Dale provided timely and effective service. Your recommendation means a lot, and we look forward to assisting with your roofing needs in the future.
Charlie k
Charlie k 2026.08.10
I had a roof leak I couldn’t track down. Joe came out to take a look and had a tech come right over to solve the problem. Has been dry ever since!
Report
Reply from Smart Roofing and Sheet Metal Company 2026.08.13
Thanks, Charlie! I’m glad Joe was able to come out quickly and get a tech over to track down that leak and fix it fast. It’s great to hear it’s been dry ever since.
Gabby Bergeron
Gabby Bergeron 2026.08.03
Very responsive team, came to check our leaking skylight the same day when we contacted them late on a Friday, and Dale and team returned Sunday to start repairing the problem. Knowledgeable and helpful team and answered all our questions on other areas we were concerned with! Would absolutely recommend!
Report
Reply from Smart Roofing and Sheet Metal Company 2026.08.13
Gabby, thank you so much for the kind words and recommendation. We’re glad our team could get out quickly to take a look at your leaking skylight and get repairs started right away, even over the weekend. We appreciate you trusting Smart Roofing & Sheet Metal Company, and we’re happy we could answer your questions and help with the other areas you were concerned about.
Scott Morrell
Scott Morrell 2026.08.02
We discovered water damage on our ceiling, we were understandably concerned. Our roof had been installed six years ago, but the original roofing company was no longer in business, so we had no way to have the warranty honored. After seeing this company’s outstanding Google reviews, we decided to give them a call—and they absolutely lived up to their reputation. Dale returned our call within an hour and came to our home the very same day. He was honest, knowledgeable, and never pressured us. He took the time to explain the issue, gave us several options, and even shared ways we could potentially fix it ourselves. Since we’re much more comfortable staying on the ground than climbing onto a roof, we asked Dale to handle the repair. His pricing was more than fair and an incredible value. He completed the work the very next day and provided before-and-after photos so we could see exactly what had been repaired. It’s rare to find a company that genuinely makes you feel like they’re looking out for your best interests instead of trying to maximize the bill. We were so impressed with the quality of the service, honesty, responsiveness, and workmanship that we plan to use them again for some upcoming gutter work. We highly recommend this company to anyone looking for reliable, trustworthy, and reasonably priced roofing services!
Report
Reply from Smart Roofing and Sheet Metal Company 2026.08.13
Scott, thank you for the thoughtful review and for trusting Smart Roofing & Sheet Metal Company when you found that ceiling water damage. I’m glad Dale could respond quickly, walk you through the options without any pressure, and get the repair done promptly with clear before-and-after photos. We really appreciate the recommendation and look forward to helping with your gutter work when you’re ready.

Frequently asked questions about Smart Roofing and Sheet Metal Company

How many reviews does Smart Roofing and Sheet Metal Company have?

Smart Roofing and Sheet Metal Company has 301 reviews on Trustindex, collected from Google and Trustindex.

What is Smart Roofing and Sheet Metal Company's average rating?

Smart Roofing and Sheet Metal Company is rated 5.0 out of 5 based on 301 reviews. 98% of reviewers gave five stars.

Are Smart Roofing and Sheet Metal Company reviews verified?

Trustindex moderates every review and verifies that it was collected from a real, active review platform before it is published.

How do I write a review for Smart Roofing and Sheet Metal Company?

Use the "Write a review" button on this page to share your own experience with Smart Roofing and Sheet Metal Company.

Write a review for Smart Roofing and Sheet Metal Company

Write a review
Skyrocket Your Sales with Customer Reviews. No coding required.
Create a Free Account