Pies & Pints - Carmel IN Reviews 2025 | Trustindex.io

Write a review

Reviews

4.5 | 676 total

5 stars

484 pcs

4 stars

129 pcs

3 stars

30 pcs

2 stars

13 pcs

1 star

20 pcs

Source filter

676 pcs

Verified

Jim McDonald 2025.12.10

Found the place via "Restaurants near me" search and was truly worth the backtrack we made. Quick service and good food. Draft root beer is outstanding. If you're sodium restricted, ask them to hold the salt dusting on the crust.

Useful Report

Gina Haskett 2025.12.06

Always awesome! Reasonable prices and the pizzas are soooo good!

Useful Report

Bre S 2025.12.05

Useful Report

Christine Soviak 2025.11.29

Useful Report

Don 2025.11.26

Rude service for the 2nd time (I never come here) I am a polite 20 yr old coming in to eat with my mom. I took two sips from my moms beer to try it. Bartender somehow sees and confronts passive-aggressively. Approach was unprofessional. Of course I obliged to stop; however, the nitpick ruined my sense of privacy! and I could see that she was talking about it with coworkers–paranoia is not an ideal customer experience. I am just upset with how fast I was VILIFIED. Bits of advice: (1.) Verify deliberate unfaithfulness to law before patronizing a chill dude. (2.) If I am such a criminal, call the police! (3.) Learn some poise and tact. Idk I'm just tired of rude service workers. Accountability is important!

Useful Report

Scott Paul 2025.11.25

The pizzas were amazing ! So much good flavor and possibility of being best pizzas around !

Useful Report

Erin Whittington 2025.10.26

Useful Report

Alan Atlas 2025.09.28

Pizza was great. Chicken, grilled onion and goat cheese. A large 16" pie. 2 of us could only eat half of the pizza. Took home the rest and warmed it in the air fryer. Great!

Useful Report

Paige Williams 2025.09.25

We love the smoke on the wings and the unique pizzas. I can't get enough of the gorgonzola dip. Chefs 👩‍🍳 kiss...5 🌟 🌟🌟🌟🌟

Useful Report

A S 2025.09.21

Always excellent pizzas and wings. We love this place and service is always friendly.

Useful Report

Reply from Pies & Pints - Carmel IN 2025.09.22

Thanks so much!

XeoFalcon M. Shields 2025.09.11

Great food and prices. Lots of food and drink choices.

Useful Report

Reply from Pies & Pints - Carmel IN 2025.09.11

Thanks so much!

Prem Sankar G 2025.09.09

Useful Report

Reply from Pies & Pints - Carmel IN 2025.09.09

Thanks, Prem. We'd love to have you back for a chance to earn that fifth star!

Paula Coburn 2025.09.06

Great pizza. Large craft beer selection. Good service.

Useful Report

Dodd Berry 2025.09.05

Pizza was very good. Staff is very friendly. Love trying new places. We will be visiting again soon! Edit: Such consistency in food, quality and service. So much fun and tons of atmosphere.