Pies & Pints - Carmel IN

piesandpints.net

Pies & Pints - Carmel IN Reviews

Excellent rating
4.5
583 reviews Verified
Pies & Pints - Carmel IN
%title%

%offer%

Reviews ( 583 ) 4.5

Scot Stiles
Scot Stiles
2024.05.26
First off, the staff was amazing. We through our son's graduation party here, 40 people and it went smooth. Food was great as always, and Jessie (server) and Craig ( management) were great. You should consider this place if you have a get to together.
Atmosphere
Food
Service
Jay Sharma
Jay Sharma
2024.05.22
Atmosphere
Food
Service
Reply from Pies & Pints - Carmel IN 2024.05.22
Thanks, Jay!
Sophia Hartley
Sophia Hartley
2024.05.09
We are from out of town (Fort Wayne) and just got carryout. We ordered the pizza skins, and got a large pizza pie, half was the Nashville hot chicken and half peppadew and I would drive the two hours down here again JUST for the peppadew pizza! Deliciousssssssss. Please make a franchise to Fort Wayne IM BEGGING YOU
Food
Reply from Pies & Pints - Carmel IN 2024.05.14
Thanks for the great review, Sophia!
Tabitha Sutton
Tabitha Sutton
2024.04.26
It really didn't compare to the original one in West Virginia. Service was kinda slow. Waited at the front desk for about 10 minutes before any workers were seen including the hosts, waiters, and bartenders
Atmosphere
Food
Service
Danielle Ewing
Danielle Ewing
2024.04.19
I love their pizza usually, but was really disappointed in their service today. We did a call ahead for 6 people. when we called, they said it would be an additional 10-15 mins once we arrived. We arrived and they say it will be an additional 15-20. We waited in the front lobby for 45 minutes (in addition we were a ‘call ahead’). When the hostess was asked how much longer they said ‘maybe 10 mins’. 10 mins later we still weren’t sat. All the 6 tops had not even received their food yet, so it wasn’t going to be anywhere near the times they stated. I am fine with being told a 45 min or 1 hr wait, but to be told 10-15 and it was over an hour is completely avoidable with proper hostesses.
Service
Reply from Pies & Pints - Carmel IN 2024.04.22
Hi Danielle, I'm so sorry your experience was far below our usual standard. I'd like to discuss this further if you'd be willing. If so, please reach out to feedback@piesandpints.net. I hope to hear from you!
Brett Ottavi
Brett Ottavi
2024.04.19
Atmosphere
Food
Service
Reply from Pies & Pints - Carmel IN 2024.04.19
Thanks so much, Brett!
Brian Morlan
Brian Morlan
2024.04.01
great food
Reply from Pies & Pints - Carmel IN 2024.04.01
I'm so glad you enjoyed the food, Brian!
Alex L
Alex L
2024.03.27
Atmosphere
Food
Service
Reply from Pies & Pints - Carmel IN 2024.03.28
Thanks for the great rating, Alex!
Benjamin Myers
Benjamin Myers
2024.03.26
Some of the best pizza I've had. I question the amount of pineapple 😔 on the menu. Love the food and the pizza skins.
Atmosphere
Food
Service
Reply from Pies & Pints - Carmel IN 2024.03.28
Thanks for the great review, Benjamin! We can give you the option to add pineapple to anything you like. Feel free to get creative!
Doug Hart
Doug Hart
2024.03.24
Pizza skins were good, salad was good portion and lots of beer options to choose from
Atmosphere
Food
Service
Reply from Pies & Pints - Carmel IN 2024.03.28
Thanks, Doug!
Zeenat Joshi
Zeenat Joshi
2024.03.12
Visited this place almost a year later. Love the food and selection of beers n wine.love their potato skin pie. Jus so yummy, and they have good salads as well. The server was good and loved the casual atmosphere. Will definitely go back. It's my comfort food kinda place.
Atmosphere
Food
Service
Casie Smith
Casie Smith
2024.03.03
Holy smokes is this place good. Walked in for the first time with our four year old. They had a large beer and wine selection and the menu was beautifully simple yet expansive for all taste. My partner and I split a house salad and a 10" Margherita pizza. It was outstanding. The whole experience was great. Kids menu was reasonably priced. We will definitely be back.
Atmosphere
Food
Service
Dale Platt
Dale Platt
2024.02.28
I can't speak to cost because it was my partners treat... Food was great and so was the service... I just wish I could find a really good Chicago style pizza place myself...
Atmosphere
Food
Service
wendall hershberger
wendall hershberger
2024.02.17
Atmosphere
Food
Service
kruthi p
kruthi p
2024.02.10
Craig was amazing with the beer selection! All four of us loved his recommendations! Thanks Craig!!
Atmosphere
Food
Service
Eliana Ridenour
Eliana Ridenour
2024.02.02
Delicious pizza and great atmosphere. Had a wonderful date night and will definitely be returning!
Atmosphere
Food
Service
Whitney Stiles
Whitney Stiles
2024.01.15
Excellent spot! Pizza was great, service was even better. Highly recommend if you are traveling with a sports team! They have it down!
Paul Duplessie
Paul Duplessie
2023.12.30
I was looking for a new pizza to try and I've always ate nearby and wanted to give this place a try. As a prior resident of New Haven CT I came across "New Haven" style pizza and to say I was curious was an understatement. I placed my order on doordash and wasn't expecting much, to be honest I haven't found a pizza I've truly enjoyed from Indiana so my expectations were incredibly low and as someone who spent 18 years living in the New Haven area, I wasn't taking that claim lightly. My pizza arrived and the char looked familiar, it lacked the same level of Mozzarella I'm used too but nonetheless I was still excited to try it. The garlic set it off, so did the oregano. I ordered without the Romano cheese because I personally feel it's a very overpowering flavor if not used lightly. If there was a little more Mozzarella this place would hit the New Haven taste right on the head. The sauce is great, the pizza is the most comparable to home that I'll absolutely be coming to the restaurant to try it fresh. The "Apizza" taste has found its way to my home in Indianapolis and I couldn't be more happy!
Food
Wayne Bright
Wayne Bright
2023.12.22
Fun place with excellent food. If you are looking for something different then give this a try. Bring a driver because you will want to sample the dozens of craft drinks here.
Atmosphere
Food
Service
Jimmy DuBois
Jimmy DuBois
2023.12.18
The Italian specialty pie was great. I would also suggest a "double cut" for more pieces, if sharing.
Atmosphere
Food
Service