Nottingham Guide Service Reviews

E Smith 2026.10.06

     

It was my birthday and hands down one of the best I’ve ever had! Captain Keenan is the best he put us on the fish and the bite never stopped. Everything was top notch from the beginning to the end. I’m planning my next trip and would recommend to everyone I know to do the same if they want a great experience on Lake Oconee 😎

Useful Report

Grant Shumate 2026.08.18

     

Keenan took the time to teach me along the way, and was very professional and kind. I would highly recommend him. We caught many fish on my crappie trip, and I am also looking at doing a hybrid/striper trip with him now, too. You won't be disappointed.

Useful (1) Report

Vicki A 2026.07.06

     

Expert guidance and great fishing! We had an amazing fishing trip! Mr. Nottingham's expertise about the lake and fishing techniques made the day enjoyable and productive. His guidance ensured a successful and fun experience for everyone. I am already looking forward to planning our next outing!
Date of experience: 06 July, 2026

Useful Report

Heidi Kilby 2026.05.04

     

Best day ever So glad that Captain Keenan was able to take us fishing. We caught over 60 stripers and had a great time. He is very skilled at finding the fish!
Date of experience: 03 May, 2026

Useful Report

Ricky Haney 2025.04.06

     

Went on my first guided fresh water trip & it was amazing caught a lot of fish and definitely plan to do it again Top notch 👌

Useful Report

James Lakeman 2025.03.21

     

If you are looking to catch a few fish don’t call Keenan, few is not in his vocabulary. Consider yourself lucky when he breaks out his top secret weapon the “Whopper Flopper” after you sign the required Nondisclosure agreement. A select few of his customers are entrusted to operate the “Thumper Bumper” system after successfully completing training and certification. Failure to operate properly will quickly lead to revocation of certification. Keenan is a tier 1 guide on Lake Oconee his pontoon boat offers plenty of space to accommodate several passengers in comfort. He knows where the fish are. We always enjoy spending the day catching a cooler full of fish with Nottingham Guide Service.

Useful Report

Scott Brantley 2025.03.19

     

I had a great time with a couple friends on Lake Oconee Fishing, we had been recommend to Nottingham Guide Service from several friends. We had a blast and caught several fish, I would highly recommend.

Useful (1) Report

Vickie Nottingham 2024.09.11

     

Useful Report

Monica Stewart 2024.07.01

     

Had so much fun 😊 will definitely be doing this again...highly recommend

Useful Report

Mike 2024.07.01

     

Great time. Very knowledgeable and helpful 🙂 caught some nice ones..would definitely do this again

Useful Report

TANIS POWERS 2024.04.15

     

Caught lots of fish and got to spend time with my co workers. The guide did everything for us. We just pulled them in and had alot of fun. Keenan was very knowledgeable and was a great host.

Useful Report

Matthew Starnes 2024.04.15

     

Awesome guide!!! Caught alot of fish. Will do it again.

Useful Report

Chris Carter 2024.04.15

     

Awesome guide. Put us on fish all day!

Useful Report

Mo Mac 2023.09.19

     

Useful Report

Dwayne Ansley 2023.06.16

     

Went on a guided trip with Keenan last week. My first time on a guided trip and first time on Lake Oconee. Great experience and caught a lot of fish. Keenan provides a comfortable enjoyable environment and is very helpful and patient with less experienced fishermen. Keenan has the experience, equipment and technology to locate the fish and help you catch them. Highly recommend if you want to experience great fishing on Lake Oconee.

Useful Report

joanne savicki 2023.01.23

     

Would forsure recommend 👍Had a great time. Caught lots of fish. Very friendly. Took us to the 🐟 🐠 🎣

Useful (1) Report

Devin Madgett 2022.12.08

     

I had an awesome trip crappie fishing with Keenan today. This was my first time fishing on Lake Oconee. Not only is Keenan a super nice guy his boat was very comfortable and we found Crappie on top of tree structure and trolling with jigs. Thanks again Captain Keenan! Devin Madgett

Useful Report

Chris Atkins 2022.07.24

     

Took my 7 year old grandson fishing with Keenan, we had a great fishing trip, thanks for helping us make some great memories!! Will go again soon!!!

Useful Report

chad nottingham 2022.07.11

     

We had a great time. Guide was very professional and was very knowledgeable. He also took the time to teach my sons about fishing. Very pleasant experience. Well worth it.

Useful Report

Mark Rayo 2022.07.11

     

Captain Keenan took myself, my daughter and her boyfriend out fishing on July 10, 2022 and the entire trip was wonderful. I can't say enough about how enjoyable and successful the day was. His boat was perfectly set up, neat and organized. I will definitely take a trip with him again and highly recommend him!

Useful Report