McMahon Insurance Agency Reviews

Patty Bombolevicz 2026.05.04

     

Isabel Sartre-Dasti has been my insurance agent for many years. She promptly answers any questions I have and works with me to get my costs down. I highly recommend her and the McMahon Insurance Agency!

Useful Report

Reply from McMahon Insurance Agency 2026.05.05

Hi Patty - Thank you so much for the kind words and recommendation. We’re glad Isabel has been able to support you over the years and help with your insurance needs. We truly appreciate your trust in Isabel and the McMahon Insurance Agency.

Deborah Klock 2026.05.02

     

Staff are very responsive . Kara is always helpful. Great service team . For many years Thanks for being there.

Useful Report

Reply from McMahon Insurance Agency 2026.05.03

Hi Deborah - Thank you for your kind words. We’re glad Kara and our team have been helpful and responsive over the years.

Barbara Moyer 2026.04.28

     

Kara has always quick to respond to any questions, as she patiently explains the details of our policy, costs and coverages.

Useful Report

Reply from McMahon Insurance Agency 2026.04.29

Barbara - Thank you for the kind review. We’re glad to hear Kara has been responsive and helpful in walking you through your policy, costs, and coverage details. We appreciate your trust and are always here when you have questions.

Robert Edgar 2026.04.05

     

I've been with the McMahon Agency for the past 11 years. Recently I reach out to Christine to see if I could lower my premiums some how as home insurance everywhere has been increasing. She laid out all the possible scenarios and looked into other providers for me. In the end we agree to increase my deductible which lower my premium for the year by a couple of hundred dollars. Thank You Christine

Useful Report

Reply from McMahon Insurance Agency 2026.04.06

Hi Robert, thanks for being such a loyal client for 11 years! We're glad Christine could help you find a better rate. We appreciate your trust in us.

Paul P 2026.04.03

     

Useful Report

Reply from McMahon Insurance Agency 2026.04.04

Thank you for the review, Paul!

john wachter 2026.04.01

     

Carmen takes good care of our homeowners and flood insurance needs.

Useful Report

Brian Ward 2026.03.31

     

Loved the service and especially Carmen LoVerde. She is extremely knowledgeable and very trustworthy. Ask for Carmen.

Useful Report

Reply from McMahon Insurance Agency 2026.04.01

Hi Brian, thanks for the 5-star review! We're happy to hear Carmen provided such knowledgeable and trustworthy service. We'll be sure to pass your kind words along to her. We appreciate your business!

Frank Weisbecker 2026.03.31

     

Kara was great to work with and timely in her response for securing property insurance on our shore condo. Very happy

Useful Report

Reply from McMahon Insurance Agency 2026.03.31

Hi Frank, thank you so much for the review! We're thrilled to hear that Kara was great to work with and provided a timely response for your property insurance. We appreciate your business and are happy we could help with your shore condo!

Danielle Swenson 2026.03.30

     

Useful Report

Reply from McMahon Insurance Agency 2026.03.31

Thank you, Danielle!

Sally Cornell 2026.03.30

     

I was in the market for a new insurance company and McMahon was the one I chose. I leased a new car and Christine was able to get the necessary papers to us quickly.

Useful Report

Reply from McMahon Insurance Agency 2026.03.31

Hi Sally, thank you so much for the review! We're glad to hear Christine was able to get your new car's papers to you quickly and make the process easy. We appreciate your business and welcome to McMahon Insurance Agency!

john spodofora 2026.03.27

     

Bonnie is very responsive and helpful. She does a great job. Overall a great business to work with.

Useful Report

Reply from McMahon Insurance Agency 2021.10.04

Thank you for the review, John! We appreciate your positive feedback!

Carly LoVerde 2026.03.27

     

Carmen is fantastic to work with and extremely knowledgeable. She answers all of your questions and makes you feel calm throughout the process.

Useful Report

Reply from McMahon Insurance Agency 2026.03.30

Hi Carly, thank you for the 5-star review! We're so glad to hear that Carmen's knowledge and support made the insurance process easy and stress-free for you. We appreciate your kind words and your business!

Robin Chou 2026.03.25

     

Useful Report

Reply from McMahon Insurance Agency 2026.03.27

Thank you, Robin!

Dara Eisenman 2026.03.25

     

We have been using McMahon insurance for years. Christine is our contact and she is efficient and always available for our insurance needs. I highly recommend using their Agency.

Useful Report

Reply from McMahon Insurance Agency 2026.03.27

Hi Dara, thank you for being a long-time client! We're so glad to hear that Christine has been such a reliable resource for your insurance needs over the years. We truly appreciate your high recommendation!

Annamarie Robb 2026.03.25

     

We have been McMahon clients for over 25 years. The agents-representatives have been very professional and reliable. We currently work with Bonnie Ash for several years. Bonnie works to provide us the best coverage at a competitive price.

Useful Report

Reply from McMahon Insurance Agency 2026.03.31

Hi Annamarie, thank you so much for the 5-star review! We're honored to have had you as a client for over 25 years. I'll be sure to pass your kind words along to Bonnie and the rest of the team. We appreciate your continued trust in McMahon Insurance Agency!

Gerald Chirichella 2026.03.25

     

Dealing with McMahon Insurance Agency was a good experience. Christine Karl was very helpful in responding to my concerns. She was able to resolve my request in a very timely manner. Thank you Christine!

Useful Report

Reply from McMahon Insurance Agency 2026.03.27

Hi Gerald, thank you for the 5-star review! We're glad to hear that Christine was able to resolve your concerns in a timely and helpful manner. We appreciate your business and kind words!

Sea Owl 2026.03.25

     

Renee thank you very much the customer service is beyond exceptional.

Useful Report

Reply from McMahon Insurance Agency 2026.03.27

Wow! Thank you for the positive, detailed review! We're so happy to hear that Renee delivered for you!

Luca Mattei 2026.03.25

     

Christine Karl was a major help setting my mom up with home insurance. She answered all of my questions, and the transition was smooth & easy with her help. Quick communication and great customer care. I highly recommend!

Useful Report

Reply from McMahon Insurance Agency 2026.03.27

Hi Luca, thank you so much for the 5-star review! We're thrilled to hear that Christine provided such great care and made the transition to home insurance smooth and easy for your mom. We appreciate your recommendation!

Dennis Kane 2026.03.25

     

Christine was very helpful in answering my questions. She listened carefully and has a great knowledge of the LBI area and the specific issues. Provides honest answers and advice that are best for clients.

Useful Report

Reply from McMahon Insurance Agency 2026.03.25

Hi Dennis - Thank you for your kind words. We are so glad Christine was helpful and took the time to answer your questions carefully. Her knowledge of the LBI area and commitment to giving honest, client-focused advice mean a lot.

Joe Drygas 2026.03.25

     

Useful Report

Reply from McMahon Insurance Agency 2026.03.25

Thank you Joe for the review!