Verified Company
As a California resident with a complex tax situation, I sought a highly competent tax professional. I discovered this firm through a Google search, and following our consultation, their meticulous attention to detail and precision in preparing my tax return made my decision clear. I intend to engage their services exclusively moving forward. Their performance was, quite simply, exceptional. I particularly commend Justin for his remarkable patience in addressing my numerous inquiries throughout the process.
For years I have struggled with finding local CPA's qualified to do crypto taxes. With all the new tax requirements coming to the crypto space in 2026, I needed to up my game. I found Justin Macari's, Mac Tax.
It has been a pleasure working with Justin, and his team. Fast professional service. Any questions, Justin often personally responds. Multiple staff members review your tax documents to eliminate any mistakes. In addition, he had a history working with my crypto-tracking service, making the whole process easier yet. All crypto and personal income tax done. No more stress, at a fair price.
Thank you, Justin
I cannot say enough great things about A Nezaj CPA PLLC. They have truly been a lifesaver for me and my business. Their level of professionalism, knowledge, and attention to detail is exceptional. In an industry where trust and accuracy are everything, they consistently deliver with integrity and precision.
What really sets them apart is how responsive and supportive they are. They take the time to explain things clearly, guide you through complex tax and financial matters, and always make sure you are making the best decisions for your business. As someone running a construction company with multiple moving parts, having a CPA team like this gives me incredible peace of mind.
If you are looking for one of the best CPA firms in the New York area, I highly recommend A Nezaj CPA PLLC. Their expertise, dedication, and reliability are unmatched.
Highly recommended.
Frank Gocaj
HI Group + Management
Reply from Mac Tax CPA
Hello, this is a very nice well written review. Based on your review I think the firm you are looking for is https://share.google/dLy8VM7H71w2sLjk3 to share this review with. I think you may have clicked on our firm by mistake.
I had a great experience working with Claude at Mac Tax CPA. He was professional, responsive, and very easy to work with. Claude helped identify and fix a mistake made by my previous accountant, which gave me a lot of peace of mind. I highly recommend Mac Tax CPA to anyone looking for reliable and knowledgeable tax support.
Wow! Incredible turnaround on my federal and state tax returns. MaxTax handled my crypto losses and even found refund $$$! All in a one day turnaround (I did provide all necessary docs first week in February) and even more incredible results! I am elated. Couldn't be happier. So glad I engaged MacTax.
I can’t say enough good things about Justin Macari “Mac Tax CPA” and his team! They seriously know their stuff when it comes to business taxes, personal taxes, and crypto taxes. I’m all the way out in Washington State, and he’s based in New York, but it’s never been a problem. He’s licensed in multiple states and everything runs super smooth working virtually.
They’re quick to respond, always take the time to explain things clearly, and actually communicate (which is rare these days). I’ve thrown them plenty of curveballs between my businesses and crypto investments, and they’ve handled it all like pros.
If you’re looking for a smart, responsive CPA firm “near me”, or one that’s great with multi-state tax filings, small business accounting, and crypto reporting, these are your people. Highly recommend!
I highly recommend Mac Tax CPA for anyone seeking honest, high-level tax guidance — especially if you're dealing with complex assets like cryptocurrency.
Justin has a deep understanding of crypto reconciliation and tax implications, and his communication throughout the process was clear, professional, and efficient. He quoted a fee range of $250–$500 for added specialized work — and came in at the low end. That’s a class move, and it really reflects his integrity and fairness. He could have easily justified the higher end, but chose not to.
I also appreciated seeing that he’s a Ramsey Endorsed Local Provider. That carries weight with me — I’ve followed Dave Ramsey since his early days, and I know that endorsement is reserved for professionals who truly align with the values of trust, competence, and client-first service.
If you’re looking for a principled CPA with real expertise — especially in today’s rapidly changing financial landscape — you’re in good hands here.
Mr. Macari and his team are very professional. They helped me tremendously with my crypto taxes and how to file them the right way. They diligently went over all transactions and provided me with sound advise.
I worked with Justin on my taxes and he saved me lots of money and time. He knows everything about crypto taxes and can assist you with all your needs. I would highly recommend his office. Thank you Justin! Voytek, Honolulu
I've been a customer of Mac Tax for two years now and they've exceeded my expectations. Communication is handled very well, members of the staff are all professional and knowledgeable, even with complex tax situations involving cryptocurrency. Great experience with Justin and his team, looking forward to working with them again in the future.
Big fan of Justin and his team! They handled my taxes this past year. What I really appreciated about Justin was
1/ he is super professional and on top of it. Generally very fast response times on any questions I ask
2/ deep knowledge about taxes as well as crypto taxes in particular
3/ process itself was super painless. After I submitted everything to him, everything was very efficiently processed.
All in all, couldn't have asked for a better new accountant and am very happy that I'm working with him. Would definitely recommend!
