Lou Malnatis Pizzeria Reviews

Lou Malnatis Pizzeria Reviews

3.8

Good - based on 78 reviews

loumalnatis.com/greenwood
is verified by Trustindex

We guarantee all reviews are 100% real.
What's Trustindex?
%title%

%offer%

Reviews (78)
ron justice
ron justice
2023-08-29
The best pizza in the state.The staff is excellent and the business is always spotless.
Miss H
Miss H
2023-08-26
Best pizza in the state!!! Puts everyone else to shame. Finally!
Marshall Tucker
Marshall Tucker
2023-08-24
Nathan ONeal
Nathan ONeal
2023-08-22
Adam Kane
Adam Kane
2023-08-18
Originally I'm from the chicago-land area. I've had their pies and thin crust and always enjoyed it. Picked up a couple of their frozen thin crusts from their store for a little under 40 bucks... tasted like garbage. My wife actually spit it out and we pitched it. Had a pepperoni and a sausage. Both tasted awful. Quality control is severely lacking. I hope they don't get someone seriously ill. Nice lady at the counter. Not writing off their deep dish but this was a terrible experience.
Mark Sink
Mark Sink
2023-08-15
Matt Worland
Matt Worland
2023-08-13
The pizza was great. Really delicious. It took 45 minutes instead of the 30 we were quoted so we hung out in the store for 15 minutes. But the pizza was great.
Snake Leader
Snake Leader
2023-07-27
Would rank higher but it's take out of delivery only. The pizza is still top notch if your craving deep dish!
Jim Casey
Jim Casey
2023-07-16
Ed Sherman
Ed Sherman
2023-07-05
Steve Striedinger
Steve Striedinger
2023-06-28
I really wanted to like this place. The pizza has all the right components, but the crust lacks flavor. The sauce is good, but again, it needs something more. It might be a pure version of a deep dish, but I need more flavor. Everything else is perfect though.
Reply from Lou Malnatis Pizzeria 2023-06-29
Hi there! We love hearing feedback from our valued guests. Thank you so much for giving us yours! Feedback is always appreciated as it helps us to improve our service for you and for all of our guests. We are so sorry to hear about your experience. Please feel free to give us a call at the number listed below. Best wishes, General Manager 317-249-8840
Jason Asher
Jason Asher
2023-06-09
First time trying Lou Malnati's. It was good! Got the deep dish double pepperoni, garlic bread, and cookies. The staff were great too! Thank you!
James Bailey
James Bailey
2023-06-03
Couldn't tell if it was open or not driving by on 135, so I just kept going. Didn't want to pull in, or double back if I wasn't sure if it was open. Tried to check Google while I was at the light, but the light was quick, and this place was not quick to find on Google maps. Maybe add a more visible signage 🤷‍♂️
Erik Van Dyck
Erik Van Dyck
2023-05-29
Roshera Banks
Roshera Banks
2023-05-04
Second time visiting. Chicago pizza is very good. Also have salads, lasagna, and desserts. Wait time is typically 30 minutes.
Eric Mayes
Eric Mayes
2023-04-18
Suzanna Dailey
Suzanna Dailey
2023-04-09
Good food but half hour later than the pick up time. We had on line carry out order. They did give us free cookies for the excessive wait time.
John Davis
John Davis
2023-03-30
I'm not even going to try it. I'm just going to go by a buyer's word. There's no way?
Chuck Swing
Chuck Swing
2023-03-21
I'm from Chicago and I can't get good pizza anywhere in Indy until Lou came to town. Finally some good pizza the thin crust is awesome the deep dish with crumble sausage amazing. The service fantastic my pizza is always ready on time.
Gary Graham
Gary Graham
2023-02-27