Tires Plus Reviews

Anthony Turner 2026.03.07

     

Henry and Melissa knocked it out of the park. I was supposed to get my tire replaced at another business; however, they ran out of my sized tire and I was screwed till Monday. I called these guys and they not only had the tire I was looking for in stock but they also made sure to get it installed in a timely manner. I’d recommend these guys for sure and I am coming back for my other tire

Useful (1) Report

Reply from Tires Plus

Taking the time to leave a five-star review really means a lot to us. We go the extra mile so your car can, too. Thanks for choosing us for your complete auto care.

Kaeden Gebhart 2026.03.06

     

Mathew was awesome, got me in on short notice and took care of me with amazing customer service.

Useful Report

Reply from Tires Plus

We love hearing about your great experience at our location! Next time you need an oil change, tire rotation, engine maintenance or any other tire or auto services, we’ll be here to offer the same five-star complete auto care experience.

Michael Young 2026.03.04

     

Got me in quickly and made the repair for a great price.

Useful Report

Reply from Tires Plus

Hey there, thanks for the great review. We know there are plenty of auto care options out there, so we appreciate the chance to show you the complete auto care experience. Thank you for choosing our location— we’ll see you next time.

H M 2026.03.03

     

Matthew was above and beyond with everything. He helped me with the detailed explanation while being patient and answering all my questions. All other staff were good too.

Useful (1) Report

Reply from Tires Plus

Hi, thanks for taking some time to leave us a five-star review! We work hard to offer a complete auto care experience, and we’re glad we were able to help.

Nicole 2026.03.02

     

Useful Report

Reply from Tires Plus

Hi, thanks for taking some time to leave us a five-star review! We work hard to offer a complete auto care experience, and we’re glad we were able to help.

Ann Sullivan 2026.02.24

     

Friendly staff, always upfront and honest about repairs/ not necessary items

Useful Report

Reply from Tires Plus

Hey, we’re so glad you had a five-star complete auto care experience. We hope you’ll keep us
in mind the next time you need quality tires or expert service. Thanks for choosing our location!

lu sanders 2026.02.24

     

I was in a pinch and these guys came to my rescue! Treating me with nothing but respect, and the price was the best price that I could find around town! Would definitely recommend this shop to anybody.

Useful (1) Report

Reply from Tires Plus

Hey, we’re so glad you had a five-star complete auto care experience. We hope you’ll keep us in mind the next time you need quality tires or expert service. Thanks for choosing our location!

Fern Dillon 2026.02.17

     

Had a flat tire from hitting a pothole while traveling through Caramel Indiana. We got there right before closing and the employee, Jackson, was able to replace it! He was great!!

Useful Report

Reply from Tires Plus

Hey, we’re so glad you had a five-star complete auto care experience. We hope you’ll keep us in mind the next time you need quality tires or expert service. Thanks for choosing our location!

Jerry Little 2026.02.02

     

Useful Report

Reply from Tires Plus 2026.02.02

Hi, we really appreciate the excellent review. When you next need tires or auto care, we look forward to helping you out again.

Priss Michel 2026.01.19

     

my family and i have been trusting this location with all of our car needs. everyone’s so nice i’ve been to other car shops and they have these huge egos but not here! helpful and kind people

Useful Report

Reply from Tires Plus 2026.01.19

Hi, thank you so much for the five-star review! From brake service to new tires to engine inspections and more, we’ll be here whenever your vehicle needs us.

Lauren Wilinski 2026.01.16

     

Matthew the manager saved day after I was driving from Chicago to Carmel. Got a flat tire with my rental car, and he was able to help me out quickly and safely. Got back to Chicago in one piece thanks to him.

Useful Report

Reply from Tires Plus 2026.01.17

Taking the time to leave a five-star review really means a lot to us. We go the extra mile so your car can, too. Thanks for choosing us for your complete auto care.

Ethan Credit 2026.01.13

     

Very professional and personable. Enjoyed their service!

Useful Report

Reply from Tires Plus 2026.01.13

Hi, thanks for taking some time to leave us a five-star review! We work hard to offer a complete auto care experience, and we’re glad we were able to help.

Melissa C 2026.01.09

     

I’m so thankful for the team here. They replaced my tires and also took me in for a last-minute oil change, even though the poor planning was on my part. They were kind, accommodating, and didn’t make me feel rushed at all. The prices are very reasonable too. I truly appreciate the great service and would definitely recommend them.

Useful (1) Report

Reply from Tires Plus 2026.01.10

Taking the time to leave a five-star review really means a lot to us. We go the extra mile so your car can, too. Thanks for choosing us for your complete auto care.

Jake Colee 2026.01.04

     

Recently went in on a Sunday to have my tire put on a new rim after Indianapolis roads did their worst. They promptly greeted me and gave me a reasonable time frame. I dropped off the wheels and they knocked them out quick. Said it was the first room they’d ever seen. They even installed out on my car for me and without asking noticed the lug covers in my cup holder and installed those. It was the first tire shop of been to that didn’t lose one of the covers.

Useful (1) Report

Reply from Tires Plus 2026.01.05

Hi, we really appreciate the excellent review. When you next need tires or auto care, we look forward to helping you out again.

Dechez Edmonds 2025.12.31

     

Great service

Useful Report

Reply from Tires Plus 2025.12.31

We love hearing about your great experience at our location! Next time you need an oil change, tire rotation, engine maintenance or any other tire or auto services, we’ll be here to offer the same five-star complete auto care experience.

melissa 2025.12.28

     

I had three lights on my dash, Jackson and Suan hot me in scanned and fixed pretty quickly. Thanks guys

Useful Report

Reply from Tires Plus 2025.09.29

Taking the time to leave a five-star review really means a lot to us. We go the extra mile so your car can, too. Thanks for choosing us for your complete auto care.

Barry Hart 2025.12.23

     

Listen,I cannot believe how helpful these guys are. Not only did they do a good job on my oil change and extra Services but they kept me informed the whole time. I also watched them work with an elderly lady who had a big engine oil leak. They towed her car in, fixed the leak for free, since it was just a bad plug from another shop. They had arranged a rental car for her - she did not need it so they did the leg work of canceling. They even offered to get her an UBER if she could not get into the shop to pick up her car. They treat everyone well and professionally. It is so rare to have a place that you can trust.

Useful Report

Reply from Tires Plus 2025.12.23

We love hearing about your great experience at our location! Next time you need an oil change, tire rotation, engine maintenance or any other tire or auto services, we’ll be here to offer the same five-star complete auto care experience.

Destiny Willis 2025.12.22

     

Quick, helpful and efficient!

Useful Report

Reply from Tires Plus 2025.12.22

Hey there, thanks for the great review. We know there are plenty of auto care options out there, so we appreciate the chance to show you the complete auto care experience. Thank you for choosing our location— we’ll see you next time.

David Matillo 2025.12.16

     

Matthew was fantastic. Less expensive than when I got a tire from Discount.

Useful Report

Reply from Tires Plus 2025.12.17

Taking the time to leave a five-star review really means a lot to us. We go the extra mile so your car can, too. Thanks for choosing us for your complete auto care.

Allison Pope 2025.12.16

     

Great service as always. Super convenient and they were very conscientious of checking with me before additional services were applied. Will definitely continue to go back.

Useful Report

Reply from Tires Plus 2025.12.16

Hi, thanks for taking some time to leave us a five-star review! We work hard to offer a complete auto care experience, and we’re glad we were able to help.