We ordered 4lbs of the colossal stone crabs. They were phenomenal!!! The claws arrived perfectly packed; super cold and fresh.
My wife and I had a party tonight. 🎉🎊
I just came back from Boca Florida 3/27. I couldn't find anything close to what we wanted. So while I was in Boca I ordered the colossals to New Jersey today 3/28. You guys run a truly amazing business 👏♥️
TY MITCH KURTZER
I was made aware of Keys Fresh from watching Aaron (the waterman). Finally ordered some fish and very glad I did! Great quality fish!! Excellent packaging and overnight shipping was perfect!! I expect to be ordering from them on a regular basis!
Thank you
received my 2nd order and am just as pleased with this order nothing better than being able to purchase fresh seafood from my hometown...Key West. ahhh so good.
Anita, That means so much to us, thank you! There’s truly nothing like a taste of home from Key West.
We’re honored to bring a little piece of it to you and look forward to fulfilling future orders for you.
Bob Fugate2026.03.26
Seafood is packaged well and arrives fresh every time. Before my order went out, I got a call from Carmen because a selection was out of stock. She helped me select an alternative and I still received my order on time. Great customer service!
Hi Dan! Wow, thank you so much! That truly means a lot, especially coming from a longtime stone crab fan. We really appreciate your support!
Marilyn Stefani2026.03.23
Red Shrimp was absolutely delicious! We bought
3 lbs of cleaned & deveined Red Shrimp .. sauté with butter , garlic , sherry & dark rum. Served over linguine .. mouth watering delicious!!👍👍
Save us a plate! That sounds incredible, thank you so much for sharing! We’re thrilled you loved the red shrimp, and that recipe sounds absolutely mouthwatering.
We truly appreciate your support and hope to send more your way soon!
Our experience was terrific, EXCEPT-I just had shoulder replacement surgery and forgot to ask for pre-cracked! Kinda embarrassing but we overcame. Highly recommended.
Thank you for the kind words, William! We wish you a speedy recovery and remember we are always happy
to accommodate our customers needs! - The Keys Fresh Team
Ken Sheeks2026.03.18
Excellent quality, very fresh will definitely order again
Found you on Key West Watermen and Luke’s YouTube channels
Hey Ken! Thank you so much for your kind words! We’re thrilled to hear everything arrived fresh and that you’ll be ordering again.
And we love that you found us through Key West Waterman and Luke, huge thanks for the support. We truly appreciate you being part of the Keys Fresh family!
Chad Fine2026.03.16
Keys Fresh Seafood has great customer service. I ordered stone crabs from them and Fedex had issues getting inside a gated community in which I reside in hot Arizona therefore by the time I got them the crabs were warm and not safely edible. I called Keys and it certainly was not their issue but they were kind enough to replace them free of charge.
On top of that the new crabs I got where shipped perfectly and tasted great. I would highly recommend Keys for quality and customer service.
-Chad Fine
Hi Chad! Thank you so much for your kind words and understanding. We really appreciate it. While some shipping issues are out of our control, we always do our very best to make things right.
We’re so glad your replacement arrived perfectly and that you enjoyed the stone crabs. Your support means a lot to us!
Update 3/14/26: these are officially the most consistent, freshest, highest quality stone crab claws I’ve ever had, even after being shipped overnight. I am extremely impressed with every aspect of this business, and will be a customer for life!
The freshest stone crab I’ve ever had delivered overnight. The sales manager, Michelle, is as great as everyone says she is in the reviews. I will never order from anywhere else going forward. Unfortunately this discovery is not great for my pocket, but it’s worth it!
Hi Kara! Thank you so much for the amazing review! We’re thrilled to hear the stone crab arrived fresh and that your overnight delivery experience was a great one. That’s exactly what we work hard to deliver every day.
And thank you for the kind words about Michelle, our entire team truly cares about making sure every order is handled the right way from start to finish. We’re so glad you found us.
We know stone crab can become a delicious habit once you start ordering it, and we’re honored to be your go-to. Thanks again for supporting Keys Fresh Seafood Market, and we look forward to sending more fresh claws your way!
Debbie Oshatz2026.03.14
the stone crabs came delivered fresh the next day packaged with ice packs.. They were delicious !! Highly recommend..
We love when our customers have options! Team mustard and team butter, the best of both worlds!
So glad you enjoyed the stone crab claws, and thanks so much for your support, Glen!
Heidi Hutchison2026.03.11
The stone crab claws with mustard dipping sauce were amazing, as was the crab dip!! Highly recommend this business not only for amazing seafood, but also excellent customer service!
Hi Heidi! Thank you for the awesome feedback! We’re so glad you loved the stone crab claws, mustard dipping sauce, and stone crab crab dip.
We truly appreciate your support and are grateful for the recommendation! 🦀
Bill Peyton2026.03.10
I ordered yellow tail and stone crab claws. Everything was professionally packaged and shipped. The quality of their products was also awesome!! Will order again for sure!!
Verified Company
