Just Rennie's Cafe & Cookie Company Reviews

Jennifer 2025.09.26

     

We hosted our leadership meeting at Just Rennie's and we could not have been more pleased. The room was perfect for 30 people, the dinner was amazing, and the desserts were excellent! Not to mention the service team. Highly recommend!

Useful Report

Reply from Just Rennie's Cafe & Cookie Company 2025.09.26

Thank you so very much for using Just Rennie's Tuscan Wine Room. We appreciate it very much! Chef Doug

Ashley Reynolds 2025.08.08

     

The BEST cookies, hands down!! Doug and Katie are amazing to work with!! If you enjoy a local chef that has the best sweets around Indiana, stop by!

Useful Report

Reply from Just Rennie's Cafe & Cookie Company 2025.08.08

Thank you Ashely for your 5-Star Review. We appreciate it very much! I will pass this along to Katie. Chef Douglas Rennie

Brett Lewis 2025.08.08

     

Useful Report

Reply from Just Rennie's Cafe & Cookie Company

Thank you Brett for taking the time for your 5-Star Experience. We appreciate it very much! Chef Doug

Ann Schulz 2025.07.11

     

Doug recently catered our event at a home in Newburgh! He and his crew did a fantastic job! Nothing was left undone. As far as the food, it was superb! Could not have gone to a restaurant and had anything close to what chef Doug Rennie made us. I highly recommend for your catering needs! Restaurant is great as well!

Useful Report

Reply from Just Rennie's Cafe & Cookie Company 2025.07.11

Good Morning!
Thank you very much! What a Fun Birthday Party! We appreciate it very much!

Amy N Banet 2025.05.10

     

Turkey, Bacon, Ranch panini was so yummy! But my FAVORITE was the pesto salad!

Useful (1) Report

Reply from Just Rennie's Cafe & Cookie Company 2025.05.10

Thank you so very much and stopping for lunch. We appreciate your business and your great review. Have an Awesome day!
Chef Doug

Cathy Graper 2025.03.27

     

Chef Doug catered our work lunch and did not disappoint! He was helpful during the ordering process, delivered the food on time and it was very good! Everyone enjoyed their lunch and of course the delicious cookies for dessert. The price was also reasonable. Highly recommend Just Rennie's!

Useful Report

Reply from Just Rennie's Cafe & Cookie Company 2025.03.27

Thank you so kindly on the review. We are glad that all enjoyed their lunch. Chef Doug

KaCee Kemper 2025.03.05

     

First time trying Just Rennie's as I was downtown and hungry. Small little place, very comfy feeling, and easy to find. I was a bit overwhelmed by all the desserts, so I passed on them. But I will be back to try some!!! Menu was interesting; lots of different salads, chicken, pasta, and fruit. They also had pre-made sandwiches or make your own sandwiches. I just tried turkey sandwich, made my own. It was delicious and priced perfectly for the quality of food. I'll definitely be back to try more food and desserts!!

Useful (1) Report

Reply from Just Rennie's Cafe & Cookie Company 2025.03.05

Good Morning KaCee! Thank you very much for the kind review and I am glad that you enjoyed your experience. We make everything from scratch and we have a Wonderful Pastry Chef. I am so glad that you stopped by for lunch. Chef Douglas Rennie/Owner

Tyler 2024.09.04

     

Always great options for food. The staff are always friendly and nice.

Useful (1) Report

Reply from Just Rennie's Cafe & Cookie Company 2024.09.04

Thank you very much for stopping by for lunch. We appreciate it very much!
Chef Douglas Rennie

Dave Maddox 2024.06.22

     

If you are ever in downtown Evansville you need to stop in . Best sandwiches, reasonably priced, smiling faces .

Useful (1) Report

Reply from Just Rennie's Cafe & Cookie Company 2024.06.22

Thank you very much David for stopping by at Just Rennie's Cafe & Cookie Co. We appreciate it very much!
Chef Douglas Rennie

Stacy Crevello 2024.06.10

     

We love Just Rennie’s ! Doug was so accommodating to help us with our mom’s cerebration of life event. Doug worked with us on the menu! Everything was absolutely perfect! The food was absolutely incredible! We highly recommend Just Rennies for any event ! The chocolate Grenache cake was beyond amazing, delicious and was the star of the party.

Useful Report

Reply from Just Rennie's Cafe & Cookie Company 2024.06.10

Thank you very much and it was nice meeting you! Chef Douglas Rennie

Edward Creek 2024.04.10

     

I first encountered Just Rennie’s at the Banterra bank parties, I have been going to them for years. I decided to have a party and did not want to prepare the food, so I turned to Chef Doug. He was very helpful in the planning he sat down with me and told me how many items as well as quantity for a party of 35 people. He also allows his staff to work directly for the host of the party and they receive 100% of the wage and tips. If you are thinking of a party or an event this is the place to go. Look at their catering menu it is wonderful. I have also started buying their deli sandwiches are they are good too.

Useful (1) Report

Reply from Just Rennie's Cafe & Cookie Company 2024.04.11

Thank you very much Ed for hosting your party with Just Rennie's Catering. We appreciate it very much! Chef Doug

Eric Martin-Taylor 2024.04.08

     

Place is cozy and the food is great. The paninis and BBQ chicken salad were all delish.

Useful (1) Report

Reply from Just Rennie's Cafe & Cookie Company 2024.04.08

Thank you very much for stopping by ay Just Rennie's. Happy Eclipse Day!
Chef Doug & Marla Rennie

Jordan Nelson 2024.04.08

     

Came to Evansville for the eclipse and had lunch and this nice little neighborhood bistro. Very friendly folks, great service, and great food! Cookies were excellent of course and they even had rugelach!

Useful (1) Report

Reply from Just Rennie's Cafe & Cookie Company 2024.04.08

Thank you very much for stopping by at Just Rennie's today. We appreciate it very much! Chef Douglas Rennie

Alberta Bosela 2023.11.28

     

Cute little shop. The chocolate chess bar was so goood definitely my favorite from there out of what I tried. Also tried cookie and brownie bars. The brownie bars were a bit on the too sweet for me personally but not gonna change the score on that people like diff amounts of sugar. If someone likes really sweet they can go for that lol. Just a suggestion though. But omg the chocolate chess bar was goood repeat. Fair amount of sweet and flavor. First time having one. The cookies were a good level of texture. Thank you.

Useful (1) Report

Reply from Just Rennie's Cafe & Cookie Company 2023.11.28

Thank you Alberta for stopping by our shop. We appreciate it very much. Have a Wonderful Holiday Season. Chef Douglas Rennie/Owner

melanie tracy 2023.09.15

     

I tried on of their apple pie muffins today. Life changing. I would highly recommend to anyone looking to taste the flavors of fall.

Useful Report

Karen Walsh 2023.07.06

     

Food selection is above spectacular! Great service, food, and customer service! Highly recommend them!

Useful (1) Report

Dawn Manges 2023.07.03

     

SMH Horrible people

Useful Report

EV81 driver 2023.06.30

     

Absolute best lunch experience in downtown Evansville. Love love love this place!!!!

Useful Report

Julia Lee 2022.12.10

     

The most AMAZING dessert for our corporate Christmas party! Hazelnut Torte with French Buttercream & Belgium Chocolate Ganache

Useful Report

Reply from Just Rennie's Cafe & Cookie Company 2022.12.10

Thank you very much for enjoying your dinner and our special Hazelnut Torte. Have a Wonderful Christmas Season.
Chef Douglas Rennie

Karen Morris 2022.12.05

     

Just Rennie's catered our daughter's wedding this past weekend at Friedman Park event center. The experience was over the top! The evening began with Rennie's staff serving appetizers to our guests at the cocktail hour, followed up with a delicious meal. The feedback from our guests was overwhelming on a beautiful meal. Doug coordinated a lovely meal and served with his staff. We have around 250 guests and all were served within about 30 minutes. Doug went beyond in that his staff waited tables, bussed tables and later assisted with the cutting and serving of the cake. it was a delightful evening. Kevin and I could not have been happier with the event. If you want to enjoy your special day with the peace of mind that your bases are covered and the smallest of details are being seen to, reach out to Doug and Marla. Again, thank you, thank you, thank you. You helped make the day a fantastic event. The food, presentation and execution were all top notch. Sincerely, Kevin and Karen Morris

Useful Report

Reply from Just Rennie's Cafe & Cookie Company 2022.12.05

Thank you very much Karen. The Wedding Reception was absolutely BEAUTIFUL! We are so glad to have been a part of your Daughter's Special day!!!!!