Verified Company
Visited for the first time yesterday. Delicious and very fresh meats that were amazing. Also- probably the best beef jerky I’ve ever had! I’ll definitely be back.
Reply from Joes Butcher Shop and Fish Market
2026.01.07
Awesome, we are thrilled that you are thrilled! We think our house made jerky is a bit of a secret. Small batch , just 3 flavors , it’s a great item to have in your car or gym bag for a protein packed snack. Appreciate the 5 stars and please shop with us again! Joe - owner
Just wow.. I’m usually not the type of person to leave comments unless it was about something really good or really bad. And I must say the “Aji Amarillo Flank Steak” sandwich was probably the best tasting sandwich I’ve eaten in the US to date. Really amazing and so fresh and tasty. Def will start ordering it a lot from now on 😋
Reply from Joes Butcher Shop and Fish Market
2026.01.03
Thank you for the five star review. The flank is one of our favorites as well! Sincerely, appreciate you taking the time to give feedback. Joe - owner
Disappointing cubano, mojo pork had poor flavor and overpowered the rest of the sandwhich. Otherwise nice atmosphere and other items looked good, so 4 stars.
Reply from Joes Butcher Shop and Fish Market
2025.12.31
Thanks for the review. Email me joe@joesbutchershop.com to tell us what you didn’t like about the pork flavor . The garlic mustard is usually the culprit for those that feel it has a strong flavor. Joe - owner
I just had a very frustrating experience at Joe’s. I preordered 10+ lbs of meat and seafood. Went to the register to pick up and waited in line, to be told that I needed to wait in the counter line to pick up. Did that and waited in the register line again, to discover my meat wasn’t in the bag. Was told to go back to the counter line again. Did that and waited in the register line again. I complained and got a weak apology. We have been customers since opening but I am not feeling the customer love.
Reply from Joes Butcher Shop and Fish Market
2026.01.01
Sorry for your inconvenience. We've had the same pre-order and pick up procedure for the 20 years you have been a loyal customer (order via phone or email, pick up at the counter from an associate, check out with the cashier). There are no excuses, we can only attribute it to a crowded New Years Eve store with an early close. Seafood is always procured and cut the same day as pick up and its incumbent on our staff to make sure the seafood gets associated with the same customers meat order for common pick up of both, obviously that did not happen. We will work harder on our training our staff in that regard and offering a more sincere remedy in store (perhaps hand carrying your order to the cashier and placing you first after waiting). Joe - owner
Great fresh meat selection. You can also buy to go stuff to eat. I saw they had sandwiches and sides. Everything looked amazing. Big dinning area. Nice large restrooms.
Reply from Joes Butcher Shop and Fish Market
2025.12.25
Thanks for recognizing our rest rooms, kind of an odd reply by a restaurant I agree… but we really did design them with purpose to offer our guests a better experience. Appreciate your 5 star review! Joe - Owner
Never a disappointment. Their Norwegian salmon is always fresh. Selection of meats and other fish are wonderful. The staff are always helpful.... Especially Kevin.
Reply from Joes Butcher Shop and Fish Market
2025.12.07
Thanks for your business, so glad our tenets of quality, service, and value are shining through. We agree! Kevin is simply the best! Joe - owner
Turkeylicious! We got 2 13lb Kuck Farms turkeys that were amazing! So tender, so much meat! This one in the photo is being spatchcocked; we did the other the normal way.
Reply from Joes Butcher Shop and Fish Market
2025.12.06
Karl, Stewart and their dad Ted Kuck have raised turkeys specifically to Joe’s standards for us for 13 years.
Hormone and antibiotic free, fed non-GMO grain, moved on and off pasture, Heritage Black crossbreed , and raised to global animal welfare standard 4/5. We process them literally a week before they come to you, they are truly fresh , not USDA standard fresh(that allows a turkey to be sold as fresh as long as it hasn’t been below 26° for more than six months). They are amazing birds and we wouldn’t be able to do it without our farming family the Kuck’s. Thanks so much for your support of Joes and small farmers! Joe - owner
Hormone and antibiotic free, fed non-GMO grain, moved on and off pasture, Heritage Black crossbreed , and raised to global animal welfare standard 4/5. We process them literally a week before they come to you, they are truly fresh , not USDA standard fresh(that allows a turkey to be sold as fresh as long as it hasn’t been below 26° for more than six months). They are amazing birds and we wouldn’t be able to do it without our farming family the Kuck’s. Thanks so much for your support of Joes and small farmers! Joe - owner
The main street meatloaf sandwich is the best sandwich I've ever had, hands down. The food is great ever time i order it!
Reply from Joes Butcher Shop and Fish Market
2025.11.21
Thank you so much! I believe the meatloaf sandwich is the most underrated sandwich on the entire menu. It never gets the love it deserves! Sincerely, appreciate your business and your review. Joe - owner
Whoa!! I had a friend tell me Joe's has the best sandwiches in the state of Indiana… I'm not sure I can argue this claim. This place will not let you down!
Reply from Joes Butcher Shop and Fish Market
2025.11.09
Thanks, we saw an instagram on just that claim this week , pretty lofty and we are humbly flattered. We do truly care about service and quality. We appreciate you sharing your review and granting us your business! Joe - owner
This place has the absolute best BLT in the entire WORLD if you haven't come to this place you need to and try their BLT, I have no relationship to this place what so ever. My coworker bought me a sandwich from this place 2 weeks ago got me the BLT and loved it and got him to try it for the first time thinking nothing of it and now he gets it ever other day for the past 2 weeks and I can't stop eating this BLT as well. 5/5 stars just doesn't do it justice it is a 1000 stars out of 5. MUST TRY THEIR BLT!!!
Reply from Joes Butcher Shop and Fish Market
2025.11.07
That's a high bar to live up to! Thanks so much for recommending us to a friend, that is the highest compliment that we could achieve! If you ever see us failing or slipping please let us know! Joe - owner joe@joesbutchershop.com
Amazing selection of everything you could ever need! Couldn’t recommend enough. Thanks Joe!
Reply from Joes Butcher Shop and Fish Market
2025.10.16
Thank you for your business and the kind review. We certainly have fun serving our customers, glad you think enough of us to share your opinion!
Joe - Owner
Joe - Owner
Best sandwiches in the state of Indiana. This is the lunch spot I ALWAYS recommend & have gotten many of my friends addicted as well. You can’t go wrong with any sandwich on the menu. And the staff is always welcoming and helpful. Long Live Joe’s!
Reply from Joes Butcher Shop and Fish Market
2025.10.14
Wow, that's high praise and we are sincerely appreciative. A double thanks for telling your friends and family about us that is the highest compliment we can get and honestly is probably the one metric that matters the most! Glad our staff was super too! Joe - Owner
The sandwiches at the deli are phenomenal. My favorite is the banh mi and the rich boy. However, you can’t really go wrong with the sandwiches. The cole slaw and other sides are fine, but the sandwiches are the best I’ve ever had.
The grocery section is pricy but worth the cost.
Reply from Joes Butcher Shop and Fish Market
2025.09.27
Thanks for the 5 stars, much appreciated. We have over 130 scratch recipes for our sandwiches, prepared foods, and sides.! Joe- owner