Island to Island Charters Reviews

Stacey 2025.12.04

     

We visited in November. Captn Ally gave us an incredible boat ride on an overcast day. We saw many different stingray, water fowl, and even a nurse shark.... Plus dolphins playing and jumping right in front of the boat. Then, we spent time out of the boat in beautiful clear tranquil water... She knows where all the best areas are. We were blessed to take home a beautiful conch shell she had found the day before!! She went above and beyond, and I can't thank her enough. Five star service deserves a five star rating.. Thank you Ally, we will see you next year 🐬

Useful Report

Reply from Island to Island Charters 2025.12.04

Looking forward to seeing you next year thank you for taking your time and posting such a wonderful review.

Stephanie Montano 2025.11.18

     

4 of us took a private tour from 10am - 4pm…we had the most amazing time with ALLY! She knew exactly were to go and the water was absolutely perfect that day!! The water was cool and the shells were rocking! We filled 8 five gallon buckets !! There is only ethical shelling allowed!!!

Useful Report

Reply from Island to Island Charters 2025.11.29

Thank you please come back for another adventure

Danielle M 2025.11.18

     

We had such a great time on this charter! Allie was friendly and made us feel right at home. The boat was clean and had everything we needed for a chill, fun day out on the water.. Allie also was an expert at spotting sharks, conch, and turtles! Definitely recommend if you want a hassle-free, fun charter!

Useful Report

Reply from Island to Island Charters 2025.11.29

Thank you for the kind words. I am looking forward to showing you more of the Florida keys

Anthony Montano 2025.11.18

     

Useful Report

Reply from Island to Island Charters 2025.11.29

Thank you for taking time to give me a 5 star review

Jay 2025.11.13

     

Allie was an excellent Captain and host. We knowledgeable of the waters and environment. It was laughs, sandbars and all around great day. I will definitely be back in touch with her for another trip !

Useful Report

Shannon Jessee 2025.10.29

     

Captain Ally is hands down the best! I have taken multiple groups throughout the years on her boat, and it is always the highlight of the trip! Each trip has been different, and well catered to the interests of the group. The boat is clean, comfortable and Ally makes you feel right at home. Some of my favorite memories include stops at the sandbars and wildlife spotting (dolphins + turtles). I highly recommend booking a trip - it's a must do in Key West!

Useful Report

Reply from Island to Island Charters 2025.11.09

Thank you so much it is always a pleasure to share the beautiful water around key west

Matthias G 2025.10.26

     

Verified

A wonderful and personal boat ride in the keys of Key West A wonderful boat trip on the sunny afternoon four hours of nature watching in the waters of Key West. The Captn Allie is wonderful woman who knows everything about the keys and can answer all your questions you may have. She brought us to extremely nice areas but we had a wonderful time. Fun recommended for everybody who loves nature.

Useful Report

Brenda L 2025.10.19

     

Verified

Great Day on the Water This was a great charter to the beautiful backcountry sandbars Captain Ally pointed out any sea life and birds as we came upon them. My two granddaughters (4 & 6) first boat trip. The boat was very comfortable A beautiful 3 hr tour. Memories forever

Useful Report

Laura Griffin 2025.09.22

     

Absolutely hands down the best! Winds were challenging the week we were there. Ally did everything she could to accommodate us before our trip ended. She and Tony went above and beyond and we had an awesome experience! The day was perfect! Ally is so knowledgeable and shares that love and experience with her guests. Tony was at the dock before we left and after we got back. Both so attentive to every detail. We can’t wait to return!

Useful Report

Reply from Island to Island Charters 2025.09.26

Thank you for a great day and such a glowing review

LAURA STEWART 2025.09.20

     

If you’re ready for the most beautiful day on the water…book a tour with Island to Island. An adventure you’ll enjoy and remember. We had the best day of our trip to the Keys. Wish we hadn’t waited till our last day because we’d book a second tour! Thanks again Ally. Can’t wait to see you again.

Useful Report

Reply from Island to Island Charters 2025.09.21

It was a fantastic day and I am looking forward to our next adventure

Athena Gil 2025.09.20

     

This was our second trip out with Captain Ally, and she somehow made it even better than the first! She knows exactly where the animals live and gave us the most unforgettable tour. We saw dolphins, turtles, sharks, and even found stingrays, my kids were absolutely thrilled! What makes Captain Ally truly special is not just how much she knows, but how much she cares. She’s incredibly knowledgeable about the ocean and marine life, and she shares that passion in a way that’s fun and engaging. My kids didn’t just leave with incredible memories, they left with a deeper understanding of the ocean and its creatures. She even cleaned off the shells they found for us to take home. If you’re considering a trip, don’t hesitate. Book with Captain Ally she’s worth every second!

Useful Report

Reply from Island to Island Charters 2025.09.21

I love my repeats and I am truly blessed to take you and the family

Sam Ww 2025.09.19

     

Your looking at these reviews because your deciding which charter to choose... Let me help you out. Capt Tony is a legend... Super chill... Super knowledgeable. Dolphin spotting, fishing, shelling, sand bar chilling, snorkeling.... He's got you. Just book a trip.... You will not regret it!

Useful Report

Reply from Island to Island Charters 2025.09.21

Thank you it was great seeing you and the family

Anesia Parrish 2025.09.08

     

We have used them about 5 times so far and always a different adventure. Love Captain Alley and her husband. Great trip to book.

Useful Report

Reply from Island to Island Charters 2025.09.10

Thank you for the continual support and taking time to write a review. Looking forward to our next adventure

michele waters 2025.08.13

     

This charter was the BEST!! Tony was great, and very informative. He taught my son the basics of fishing and I even joined in. The sand bars were beautiful and relaxing. I highly recommend this charter for a fun day in the sun.

Useful Report

Reply from Island to Island Charters 2025.08.16

Thank you to you and the family it was a pleasure

Gina Koutros 2025.08.13

     

Great time with Captain Tony!

Useful Report

Reply from Island to Island Charters 2025.09.21

Thank you

Ellie 2025.08.12

     

This was so much fun!! The captain was amazing and even taught all of us how to fish. He was extremely accommodating and the boat itself was very comfortable. I absolutely recommend this to anyone looking!

Useful Report

Reply from Island to Island Charters 2025.09.21

It was my pleasure and I am glad you enjoyed your day

Pawel 2025.08.03

     

We had an amazing time and our captain was great. We caught fish, saw a lot of key west wildlife, and hung out in beautiful areas. I highly reccomend this charter

Useful Report

Reply from Island to Island Charters 2025.08.04

We appreciate the wonderful review

Robert K 2025.08.03

     

Verified

Snorkel, Sightsee and Sandbar ! Captain Tony was fantastic - perfect blend of sightseeing and spotting rays, nurse and lemon sharks, tarpon etc with snorkeling and relaxing on a sandbar. Best crew in Key West IMO

Useful Report

Amy Amy 2025.07.30

     

Wonderful experience with Ali. She took us snorkeling in shallow water, which was awesome. We found live sand dollars and starfish. Saw sea turtles. It was by far the best part of our trip and we all agreed that we would book a longer excursion next time.

Useful Report

Reply from Island to Island Charters 2025.08.01

That was an amazing trip and I am looking forward to our next trip. Thanks for taking the time to write this amazing review

clare l 2025.07.29

     

Verified

Hammerhead Dolphins Stingray we saw them Wow we had the most amazing trip with Ali, she is so incredibly knowledgeable about the sealife and the habitats around Key West. She is great to listen to and she wants to ensure that she delivers the experience that people are seeking and more!! Can't recommend doing a trip highly enough - you will regret it if you miss out.

Useful Report