Holstein Grill Steak House Reviews

Excellent rating

4.9 | 407 reviews

Verified Company

holsteingrillsteakhouse.com Visit Holstein Grill Steak House

Write a review

Reviews

4.9

| 407 total

5 stars

256 pcs

4 stars

9 pcs

3 stars

8 pcs

2 stars

1 pc

1 star

1 pc

Source filter

275 pcs

Verified

Brian K 2026.03.21

Brought my wife and two adult children here for my wife’s birthday. The food was absolutely amazing and delicious. All 4 of us were very happy and content on the portion sizes. Our waitress Mimi was so polite and friendly. She was very informative and helpful as well. We will definitely be back soon and we have been telling everyone about the place since. We will be requesting Mimi the next time also!! She was just awesome.

Michelle K 2026.03.21

This is the second time we went to this place. Tonight we celebrated my birthday with 2 of my kids. What a great experience! Mimi was so sweet and attentive and our meals were out of this world. This is a hidden gem and somewhere we will frequent.

Gerry Valentine 2026.03.20

What a lovely Argentinian steak restaraunt !! 4 of us had the sausage and chirizo appetizer, followed by ribeyes, and 2 shared the meat only combo platter for 2. Excellent steak, excellent sides, and killer chimmuchuri sauces on the side. Service ....excellent !!...a small, intimate spot right behind Ralphs ices, and the staff was truly the best !!....I don't eat steak out that often, but I would have no hesitation coming back... EXCELLENTE !!👍👍❤️❤️

Useful (1) Report

Cecilia Larrea 2026.03.16

This is was a real treat! The food was delicious and Joe, our server, was courteous, helpful, and friendly. I highly recommend this hidden gem.

David Nieves 2026.03.15

New great restaurant…. A must in Ronkonkoma

Useful (1) Report

Dee Nuhh 2026.03.14

Hmm so strange I've reviewed this place many times and my lengthy review keeps disappearing so I'll do it again 😩 We found this place last yr on a whim let me tell you this place is our go too when we go to the movies .. DELISH..I have to find the pictures of the food I'll add later ..the quality of the meat alone melts in your mouth.thr meat platter for two as well delish !!

Useful (1) Report

Rosana Reade 2026.03.13

The best food this side of Buenos Aires!

Maureen Fitzpatrick 2026.03.08

This place is great!! Mimi was a wonderful waitress and the food was absolutely killer! A must try.

Julie 2026.03.06

I'm SO glad I found out about this little cozy restaurant! My family took me to celebrate my birthday. We chose it based on all the wonderful things we had heard. This is the place if you're looking for an enjoyable steak dinner at a very good price! All the meat was juicy and had excellent flavor! The garlic bread is awesome and the caesar salad was better than any restaurant I've been to... period! Servers Francesca and Miriam are amazing. They really take care of you! Little tip: make sure you have a reservation to ensure a table 😉

I'm SO glad I found out about this little cozy restaurant! My family took me to celebrate my birthday. We chose it based on all the wonderful things we had heard. This is the place if you're looking for an enjoyable steak dinner at a very good price! All the meat was juicy and had excellent flavor! The garlic bread is awesome and the caesar salad was better than any restaurant I've been to... period! Servers Francesca and Miriam are amazing. They really take care of you! Little tip: make sure you have a reservation to ensure a table 😉

I'm SO glad I found out about this little cozy restaurant! My family took me to celebrate my birthday. We chose it based on all the wonderful things we had heard. This is the place if you're looking for an enjoyable steak dinner at a very good price! All the meat was juicy and had excellent flavor! The garlic bread is awesome and the caesar salad was better than any restaurant I've been to... period! Servers Francesca and Miriam are amazing. They really take care of you! Little tip: make sure you have a reservation to ensure a table 😉

I'm SO glad I found out about this little cozy restaurant! My family took me to celebrate my birthday. We chose it based on all the wonderful things we had heard. This is the place if you're looking for an enjoyable steak dinner at a very good price! All the meat was juicy and had excellent flavor! The garlic bread is awesome and the caesar salad was better than any restaurant I've been to... period! Servers Francesca and Miriam are amazing. They really take care of you! Little tip: make sure you have a reservation to ensure a table 😉

I'm SO glad I found out about this little cozy restaurant! My family took me to celebrate my birthday. We chose it based on all the wonderful things we had heard. This is the place if you're looking for an enjoyable steak dinner at a very good price! All the meat was juicy and had excellent flavor! The garlic bread is awesome and the caesar salad was better than any restaurant I've been to... period! Servers Francesca and Miriam are amazing. They really take care of you! Little tip: make sure you have a reservation to ensure a table 😉

I'm SO glad I found out about this little cozy restaurant! My family took me to celebrate my birthday. We chose it based on all the wonderful things we had heard. This is the place if you're looking for an enjoyable steak dinner at a very good price! All the meat was juicy and had excellent flavor! The garlic bread is awesome and the caesar salad was better than any restaurant I've been to... period! Servers Francesca and Miriam are amazing. They really take care of you! Little tip: make sure you have a reservation to ensure a table 😉

I'm SO glad I found out about this little cozy restaurant! My family took me to celebrate my birthday. We chose it based on all the wonderful things we had heard. This is the place if you're looking for an enjoyable steak dinner at a very good price! All the meat was juicy and had excellent flavor! The garlic bread is awesome and the caesar salad was better than any restaurant I've been to... period! Servers Francesca and Miriam are amazing. They really take care of you! Little tip: make sure you have a reservation to ensure a table 😉

I'm SO glad I found out about this little cozy restaurant! My family took me to celebrate my birthday. We chose it based on all the wonderful things we had heard. This is the place if you're looking for an enjoyable steak dinner at a very good price! All the meat was juicy and had excellent flavor! The garlic bread is awesome and the caesar salad was better than any restaurant I've been to... period! Servers Francesca and Miriam are amazing. They really take care of you! Little tip: make sure you have a reservation to ensure a table 😉

I'm SO glad I found out about this little cozy restaurant! My family took me to celebrate my birthday. We chose it based on all the wonderful things we had heard. This is the place if you're looking for an enjoyable steak dinner at a very good price! All the meat was juicy and had excellent flavor! The garlic bread is awesome and the caesar salad was better than any restaurant I've been to... period! Servers Francesca and Miriam are amazing. They really take care of you! Little tip: make sure you have a reservation to ensure a table 😉

Useful (1) Report

Rosana Reade 2026.03.06

The steaks were amazing! Marinated and cooked to perfection. Dessert was delicious, lava cake was moist and delectable. Our server, Miriam was exceptional! Highly recommend!

Daniel Reade 2026.03.06

Great experience and great service

Lisa Montefusco 2026.03.06

Mariam & Rosalia were wonderful

Useful (1) Report

Darla Gamboa 2026.03.05

Amazing Steak !!!❤️❤️❤️❤️

Gong Jason 2026.02.23

douglas garcia 2026.02.22

I went to Holstein Grill yesterday and I ordered a ribeye steak. It was so juicy and tender, and I also order a piña colada which it was delicious. I recommend that place to whoever like steak

Veryto Calvachi 2026.02.21

Amazing food this is my new favorite place

Claudia Geoninatti 2026.02.19

Delicious! Service was phenomenal and the food was top notch. We will be back very soon! Miriam and Francesca were so warm and welcoming. Their attentiveness did not go unnoticed. I highly recommend!!!

Andres Medina 2026.02.18

😋 10 0f 10 mimi and Joe best service the food is 🔥 Delicious

Mariely Jimenez 2026.02.16

I have to say, this place really surprised me and exceeded my expectations. My husband and I have been trying to find a good steakhouse where we would want to continue going to and had not found it until last night. The food was amazingly delicious! We had the BBQ chicken wings as an appetizer, the mixed grill, lobster tail, garlic mash potatoes, roasted potatoes, sautéed asparagus, and a Caesar salad. Can’t forget the basket of garlic bread we got when we sat down...yummmmmyy! Everything was the perfect amount, perfectly cooked to our liking, hot and fresh. The place is small and intimate, great for a date night. The music set the mood and the hostess and waitress were very helpful and friendly. I can’t wait to go back again! Would definitely recommend to anyone looking for a steak night.

I have to say, this place really surprised me and exceeded my expectations. My husband and I have been trying to find a good steakhouse where we would want to continue going to and had not found it until last night. The food was amazingly delicious! We had the BBQ chicken wings as an appetizer, the mixed grill, lobster tail, garlic mash potatoes, roasted potatoes, sautéed asparagus, and a Caesar salad. Can’t forget the basket of garlic bread we got when we sat down...yummmmmyy! Everything was the perfect amount, perfectly cooked to our liking, hot and fresh. The place is small and intimate, great for a date night. The music set the mood and the hostess and waitress were very helpful and friendly. I can’t wait to go back again! Would definitely recommend to anyone looking for a steak night.

I have to say, this place really surprised me and exceeded my expectations. My husband and I have been trying to find a good steakhouse where we would want to continue going to and had not found it until last night. The food was amazingly delicious! We had the BBQ chicken wings as an appetizer, the mixed grill, lobster tail, garlic mash potatoes, roasted potatoes, sautéed asparagus, and a Caesar salad. Can’t forget the basket of garlic bread we got when we sat down...yummmmmyy! Everything was the perfect amount, perfectly cooked to our liking, hot and fresh. The place is small and intimate, great for a date night. The music set the mood and the hostess and waitress were very helpful and friendly. I can’t wait to go back again! Would definitely recommend to anyone looking for a steak night.

I have to say, this place really surprised me and exceeded my expectations. My husband and I have been trying to find a good steakhouse where we would want to continue going to and had not found it until last night. The food was amazingly delicious! We had the BBQ chicken wings as an appetizer, the mixed grill, lobster tail, garlic mash potatoes, roasted potatoes, sautéed asparagus, and a Caesar salad. Can’t forget the basket of garlic bread we got when we sat down...yummmmmyy! Everything was the perfect amount, perfectly cooked to our liking, hot and fresh. The place is small and intimate, great for a date night. The music set the mood and the hostess and waitress were very helpful and friendly. I can’t wait to go back again! Would definitely recommend to anyone looking for a steak night.

I have to say, this place really surprised me and exceeded my expectations. My husband and I have been trying to find a good steakhouse where we would want to continue going to and had not found it until last night. The food was amazingly delicious! We had the BBQ chicken wings as an appetizer, the mixed grill, lobster tail, garlic mash potatoes, roasted potatoes, sautéed asparagus, and a Caesar salad. Can’t forget the basket of garlic bread we got when we sat down...yummmmmyy! Everything was the perfect amount, perfectly cooked to our liking, hot and fresh. The place is small and intimate, great for a date night. The music set the mood and the hostess and waitress were very helpful and friendly. I can’t wait to go back again! Would definitely recommend to anyone looking for a steak night.

I have to say, this place really surprised me and exceeded my expectations. My husband and I have been trying to find a good steakhouse where we would want to continue going to and had not found it until last night. The food was amazingly delicious! We had the BBQ chicken wings as an appetizer, the mixed grill, lobster tail, garlic mash potatoes, roasted potatoes, sautéed asparagus, and a Caesar salad. Can’t forget the basket of garlic bread we got when we sat down...yummmmmyy! Everything was the perfect amount, perfectly cooked to our liking, hot and fresh. The place is small and intimate, great for a date night. The music set the mood and the hostess and waitress were very helpful and friendly. I can’t wait to go back again! Would definitely recommend to anyone looking for a steak night.

I have to say, this place really surprised me and exceeded my expectations. My husband and I have been trying to find a good steakhouse where we would want to continue going to and had not found it until last night. The food was amazingly delicious! We had the BBQ chicken wings as an appetizer, the mixed grill, lobster tail, garlic mash potatoes, roasted potatoes, sautéed asparagus, and a Caesar salad. Can’t forget the basket of garlic bread we got when we sat down...yummmmmyy! Everything was the perfect amount, perfectly cooked to our liking, hot and fresh. The place is small and intimate, great for a date night. The music set the mood and the hostess and waitress were very helpful and friendly. I can’t wait to go back again! Would definitely recommend to anyone looking for a steak night.

Jay Hernandez 2026.02.14

Spent Valentine’s Day with my family and every single thing we ate was absolutely delicious. We drove from Nassau County and it was worth every mile we drove.

Company activity

Claimed Profile
Displaying Reviews
Replied to 70% of reviews
Top Rated Certificate

About Holstein Grill Steak House

Holstein Grill Steak House

TOP 5 Trustindex Features

100+ Review Platforms

40 Breathtaking review widgets

Easy review collection

Review image generator

Review e-mail signatures

Create a Free account