Garys Pizza

Garys Pizza Reviews

Excellent rating
     
4.8 | 112 reviews
Trustindex Verified Company
Garys Pizza
Write a review

Reviews

Trustindex

4.8

| 112 total

100 pcs
7 pcs
2 pcs
1 pc
1 pc
Source filter
Randy
Randy 2026.01.25
     
Unique, tasty, fairly priced. I live just three blocks from Gary’s and we have many alternative pizza places to choose from. Gary’s is our monster favorite. The large unique Roman style brick pizzas are fabulous with crisp crust, strong bread, generous toppings, and rich flavors. I like how instead of just ordering whole pizzas you can customize the mix of slices to appeal to different tastes. My favorites are mushroom with extra pecorino and a taste of truffles, as well as the good old fashioned pepperoni snd cheese . The focaccia bread is also fabulous with its olives, garlic and dried tomatoes. They are unique in adding final toppings after reheating their already-warm fresh slices just before boxing. It guarantees that they will be hot. I also like how they add different pizzas each week to give you variety. We have used it three times for takeout for Patriots games, impress our guests, and just keep wanting more.
Brandon Hopkins
Brandon Hopkins 2026.01.25
     
Incredible pizza, new favors regularly, impressively sophisticated for the price
Christopher James Rodrigue
Christopher James Rodrigue 2025.12.23
     
One of the best pepperoni pizza I have ever had.
Amy G
Amy G 2025.12.22
     
Cute shop and yummy pizza. Just be aware that there isn’t anywhere to sit inside so it has to be for takeout
Ana M
Ana M 2025.12.21
     
Have ordered twice and twice deliciously served. Most recently had a slice of Kurobata Sausage (excellent bread and toppings) a HUGE Meatball sub, Greek salad (super fresh) and chocolate gelato which will keep my husband coming back! Order was ready on time and staff was friendly. Great addition to the neighborhood!
Reply from Garys Pizza 2025.12.21
Thank you for dining with us, Ana.
Wonderful to read that you enjoyed yourselves. Consider trying the Mushroom pizza as well. It’s delicious!
We appreciate you!
Elizabeth H
Elizabeth H 2025.12.20
     
The pizza is delicious with a soft foccacia-like dough, and they load up the pizzas with the toppings. The cookie is great too! We were so impressed with the service - our delivery order was missing a few slices. When we called, they were so nice about it and made a second delivery (and wouldn't accept a tip for the extra effort!). Huge shout out to Chase for going above and beyond to ensure we enjoyed our rainy evening in. We were already happy with the addition of a pizza option in the area but now we'll be sure to keep coming back with more friends!
Reply from Garys Pizza 2025.12.21
Thank you for dining with us, Elizabeth. I am sorry to read items were missing; however, thankful Chase was able to rectify.
We of course aim for zero missing items in our orders so we will work on that.
We look forward to your next order.
Regards!
Christopher Marshall
Christopher Marshall 2025.12.18
     
Pepperoni is a must have
Reply from Garys Pizza 2025.12.21
Thank you for the order and kind 5 star post, Christopher.
We look forward to your return!!
Tara Nejaimey
Tara Nejaimey 2025.12.05
     
Gary’s Pizza is absolutely delicious! Don’t miss there sandwich’s. Truly my favorite in the North End. Once you have their breads you’ll be hooked! Perfection.
Reply from Garys Pizza 2025.12.12
Hi Tara
Thank you for the great review! Happy to hear you loved it. All the sandwiches in addition to the pizza is worth the trip. For clarification so others don't get confused, we are actually in the South End on Washington St. Hope to see you again soon.
Jazdiannet Shackford
Jazdiannet Shackford 2025.12.04
     
Reply from Garys Pizza 2025.12.12
Thank you for the 5 stars Jazdiannet. Hopefully you ordered in advance so you could just run in and out. We offer a great takeout & delivery service. Hope to see you again soon.
C T
C T 2025.12.03
     
Hands down the best pizza in the South End. Staff is very nice. Not a sit down joint. A bit pricey but worth it.
Reply from Garys Pizza 2025.12.12
Thank you for the great review CT. Look forward to welcoming you back again soon. Don't forget dessert.
Shane Gray
Shane Gray 2025.11.28
     
Reply from Garys Pizza 2025.12.12
Thank you Shane. Please spread the word and don't forget the desserts. See you soon.
S PJ
S PJ 2025.11.17
     
Take out pizza The people at the counter did not speak any English and could not answer my question All in all in the confusion I ended up with an extra slice of pizza 🍕 Now the pizza I loved it Not the traditional pizza as the base is like focaccia bread creating a very airy dough They also made an effort to grate some extra parm cheese on top together with some sauce $6 per slice

Skyrocket Your Sales with Customer Reviews. No coding required.

Create a Free Account