From Lucie Reviews

A.C. Lambert 2025.12.12

     

~Disappointing $17 mini cup cake~ Come here from all the hypes but left underwhelmed. While carrot cup cake is beautifully decorated with real flowers, it is a simple carrot muffin. Its texture is doughy like basic muffins. Definitely doesn't justify $17 price tag. The size and weight is not more than a cup cake. It's pretty for photos but that's that. The place is cramped. Not very comfortable to be inside. When the hype winning down, I wander how this place would survive? I don't believe it will survive long term.

Useful Report

Kelsey Yin 2025.12.10

     

Small but mighty bakery with amazing pastries and incredibly decorated floral cakes! Will sure be the talk of the party and is the best cake to get for a special event/gathering.

Useful Report

Loren O 2025.12.08

     

The most beautiful cakes for any celebration in NYC - and they actually taste as good as they look. The vegan citrus cake was just as good as any non-vegan cake I’ve ever had, and the chocolate cake with espresso buttercream was truly to die for. I also love that they offer the option to order a set of mini cakes - such an elevated, shareable, and incredibly cute way to celebrate.

Useful Report

Kubes Family 2025.12.08

     

Such an adorable shop! Grabbed a latte & a mini chocolate cake! It was perfect! Loved how small it was and being able to see the girls in the back building amazing cakes! Will come back again!

Useful Report

Leticia Oliveira 2025.12.05

     

I tried this bakery for the first time and loved everything! I got two cakes and a cookie — all were delicious, but the chocolate mousse was definitely my favorite. The bakery itself is super nice and clean, and even the packaging was cute. Everything felt thoughtful and high-quality. Highly recommend!

Useful Report

Viviana Sanchez 2025.12.05

     

I ordered the carrot cake for my birthday, and it was perfection. The pickup was seamless, and the cake itself was rich, flavorful, and beautifully made. As a true carrot cake fan, I can honestly say this is the best one I’ve ever had!

Useful Report

Lauren Silverstein 2025.12.04

     

Probably one of the best chocolate chips cookies in the city (and I’ve tried A LOT). If you like a thin cookie this is a must try. Even if you don’t like thin cookies….it’s amazing. It was so good that I walked out of the bakery, took a bite, and immediately turned around to go buy another one. I also tried the mini carrot cake and it was everything I wanted it to be!! I don’t get the negative reviews other than it might be pricy but what isn’t. Just try this place you probably won’t regret stopping in

Useful Report

Brian S. 2025.12.02

     

For every occasion, I get my cake from From Lucie, and they are simply the best! I’ve tried all their flavors, but the lemon olive oil is my personal favorite. Highly recommended!

Useful Report

Anushka Mankunath 2025.12.02

     

We were in the area looking for a sweet treat and came across From Lucie. Initially we were only going to try the chocolate chip cookie but the almond croissant cookie sounded too intriguing to ignore. The chocolate chip cookie was good, I’m personally not a fan of salt on top of cookies but I know it’s a popular thing. The almond croissant cookie was amazing in my opinion. I thought it was perfectly sweet and a great fusion treat. Their other pastries look good too and I’d love to come back and try more!

Useful Report

I J 2025.12.02

     

Not sure what the big deal is. Was so excited to try but the cake was so dry. Flavor profile has potential though

Useful Report

L Wolfe 2025.11.30

     

I tried the chocolate chip cookie, its good...but I've found better. I would come back to try the cake slices. This place sells out fast & is often mobbed.

Useful Report

Enaas Sultan 2025.11.29

     

Such a lovely little bakery. I got a mini carrot cake which was one of the best carrot cakes I’ve ever had. I went in the spring, so the outside seating was set up and the street was calm and pleasant. Will be visiting whenever I’m back in manhattan.

Useful Report

Cassia Seixas 2025.11.26

     

one of the best in the city. They have one of my favorite cookies and the carrot cake is amazing!

Useful Report

Stefania Belussi 2025.11.25

     

Very lovely place with great service and delicious cakes. The cakes are not only beautiful but rich in flavour. Creative flavours, definitely recommend!

Useful Report

Napakaporn Sanguanhong 2025.11.21

     

Their Lemon Olive Oil Cake is so good! so light, moist, and perfectly citrusy. You can taste the quality in every bite. It’s the kind of cake you think about days later. Such a cozy little spot too. Always feels like a treat stopping by!

Useful Report

jose chavarria 2025.11.20

     

Had the carrot cake for a friend’s birthday party and it was delicious! Still thinking about it a week later.

Useful Report

Amna Rana 2025.11.18

     

This is a cute little shop nestled away in a quiet street in east village. The inside is such a vibe - fresh flowers, beautiful cakes. Everything is just… beautiful! I’ve been stopping by here every few days after my morning walks and grabbing a slice of cake. The flavors are so fresh, and so delicious. UGH more people need to try! The stout cake and banana bread are DIVINE.

Useful Report

Cassidy C 2025.11.14

     

Useful Report

Celina Prentiss 2025.11.14

     

As a sweet treat connoisseur, I have tried a lot of treats around NYC. & can confirm that the cakes and sweets @ From Lucie’s are at the TOP of my list!! Must must get the carrot cake + lemon bar. Such a cute little spot.

Useful Report

Margaux Seffar Blake 2025.11.11

     

I ordered my wedding cake from Lucie, and she and her team were incredibly kind and professional. The cake was an absolute dream: stunning and delicious. Une vraie artiste. 📸 : Cheyanna De Nicola

Useful Report