Dog Day Afternoon Reviews

Colin Thompson 2025.12.03

     

Perfect in every way!

Useful Report

Nicole Brancato 2025.11.30

     

Useful Report

Briana Fahey 2025.11.11

     

Useful Report

Aishwarya Singh 2025.11.05

     

Legit Chicago dogs in NYC. The sport peppers are real and the tomatoes are sliced. Physically it's just a cute little hot dog stand, but there's a few outdoor seats. Recommended.

Useful Report

Dana Albert 2025.10.08

     

This is the best hotdog I've ever had. And the owners are so wonderful.

Useful Report

Mariano Iglesias 2025.10.07

     

Honestly, these are the best hot dogs in all of New York. The bun, the sausage, the mix of flavors, the way they’re prepared… everything is truly on another level. The person who served us —I imagine he’s the owner— was super friendly. You can really tell when people put passion into what they do. Highly recommended!

Useful Report

B 2025.10.06

     

$9 for a Chicago dog is ridiculous. There’s no way around it. For context, you can get a Chicago dog from Portillo’s with the exact same toppings for $3.89.

Useful Report

Bill Zhao 2025.09.29

     

Useful Report

John W 2025.09.27

     

The Chicago Dog and Chili Cheese Dog were some of the best hot dogs I've ever had. The hot dog links have a smokiness that elevates the flavor to another level. It's a little pricy, but I think you get what you pay for. I'd highly recommend checking it out if you have the chance.

Useful Report

Christopher Z 2025.09.19

     

I'm happy that I finally found a place that serves great Chicago dogs in NYC. I'll definitely return to try the other options on the menu.

Useful Report

Lorenzo Phillips 2025.09.17

     

Great dog

Useful Report

MX 80 2025.09.17

     

Useful Report

Ethan Messenger 2025.08.31

     

It’s hard to find a solid Chicago dog outside of Chicago, but they did it here. No inside seating but there’s a new spots outside which is clutch.

Useful Report

viki akki 2025.08.23

     

A local institution!!

Useful Report

luh relle dee 2025.08.11

     

Useful Report

drew l 2025.08.10

     

Useful Report

Monica Murphy 2025.08.09

     

Useful Report

michael gluck 2025.07.30

     

Useful Report

Jordan Owens 2025.07.25

     

I love this place! Been coming since they opened. Everything is awesome! I love when I have the jambalaya. Literally can’t go wrong with anything!!

Useful Report

Abby Grosslein 2025.07.23

     

Had a yummy New York dog with ketchup instead of mustard (plus sauerkrat and caramelized onions). The dog had a great snap to it. Made for a delicious bite! Easy quick lunch with an A&W root beer in a frosty can. ♡ loved it

Useful Report