Piccola Italia in Mauldin Reviews 2025 | Trustindex.io

Write a review

Reviews

4.7 | 943 total

5 stars

796 pcs

4 stars

79 pcs

3 stars

42 pcs

2 stars

12 pcs

1 star

14 pcs

Source filter

929 pcs

14 pcs

Verified

Maria Vacirca 2025.11.05

Useful Report

Nicci Talley 2025.10.31

Useful Report

T Maggio 2025.10.30

Solid NY Style pie!! Could taste the basil and parmesan, super thin and crispy! Ordered the pizza and it was ready in under 15 minutes. Atmosphere was warm and cozy. Definitely be going back

Useful Report

Dr Roberts 2025.10.29

Great food, great service and friendly staff. Highly recommended

Useful Report

Reply from Piccola Italia in Mauldin 2025.10.30

🇮🇹🇮🇹🍕🥂

Elisha McWatters 2025.10.27

Delicious! I was even given extra sauce for my leftovers. Small family atmosphere that was very charming.

Useful Report

Miller Perry 2025.10.26

Ummmmm, this little hidden gem hits on EVERY level. Food is crazy good and made from scratch by a guy from Naples! Service is like talking to friends and the atmosphere is just what you want in a little local apot like this! I can't wait to go back!!!

Useful Report

Lourdes Fernandez-Cabrera 2025.10.25

Excelente!!! 🍝🍕 cannot believe this place have been open for 3 years and we just discover it 👌🏻👌🏻 Highly recommended!!

Useful Report

Louie Newton 2025.10.24

First time there, best pizza I have had in a long time. Love the thin crispy crust and the wood fired oven flavor.

Useful Report

Lakeashia Simpson 2025.10.23

Useful Report

Marty Webster 2025.10.21

This guy is the real deal. I’ve had his pizza, lasagna, and meat cannolis and all three are amazing!

Useful Report

Nicole Culpepper 2025.10.18

Authentic food and sooo good. Family owned, and you'll know it because the owner will come out and talk to you and answer any questions.

Useful Report

Reply from Piccola Italia in Mauldin 2025.10.20

🇮🇹🇮🇹🥂🍕

Larry Brodsky 2025.10.17

Had a fabulous lunch with truly homemade sauce, Arrabiata. Service was friendly, attentive and prompt. Did a takeout pizza and it looks and feels perfect. But the crowning event was asking the owner if he could do real carbonara. He beamed and the short answer was, with one hour notice, absolutely YES. I'll be back! Edit, I just finished the pizza that I carried out. Perfect! The crust was crispy, thin and flavorful. The sauce was tasty. This is a gem.

Useful Report

Eddie B. 2025.10.16

Ambiance is wonderful The food was spectacular Love the owner. Service impeccable

Useful Report

Hannah Donahue 2025.10.11

One of my favorite pizzas ever! They use fresh ingredients that don't weigh you down. The crust is so crispy and the sauce is perfection. I thoroughly enjoyed meeting the owner and feeling the passion that he has for his food. It was a pleasure to eat here and we will be back many more times!

Useful Report

Reply from Piccola Italia in Mauldin 2025.10.13

🇮🇹🇮🇹🥂🍕👍

Miguel Casas 2025.10.09

Useful Report

Reply from Piccola Italia in Mauldin 2025.10.13

PICCOLA ITALIA IN MAULDIN 🇮🇹 🥂🍕

Cristen Duenas 2025.10.04

Authentic Italian. Everything is fresh and homemade, from the pasta, to the sauce, to the pizza dough. They use all Natural ingredients, no added salts or sugars. It is packed on Saturday nights for a reason. You know it's authentic most of the customers are italian. You can taste the love in their food. Very very good!

Useful Report

Jason Blalock 2025.10.04

Useful Report

connor mullan 2025.10.02

Useful Report

Kimberly Galeano 2025.09.27

Excellent meatballs! Friendly owner and staff, and already an amazing reputation because Piccola Italia was recommended to me. I wish them much deserved success, and I will be back! If you’ve been craving true Italian cuisine, your search is officially over! This hidden gem in the heart of Mauldin will be my go-to spot—not only for authentic Italian dishes, but also for delicious family-style meals to take home when I need a break from cooking. Every bite showcases the finest ingredients, and the sauce alone is worth the visit. A true star has arrived in Mauldin!