City Barbeque

City Barbeque Reviews

Good rating
     
4.4 | 1563 reviews
Trustindex Verified Company
City Barbeque
Write a review

Reviews

Trustindex

4.4

| 1563 total

1082 pcs
273 pcs
97 pcs
51 pcs
60 pcs
Source filter
Jeff Bugher
Jeff Bugher 2026.08.28
     
The 2 stars for Food is not about quality or taste. It's to represent my disappointment with either the corporation or local management, whoever is responsible, for consistently running out of some of the meats prior to my occasionally showing up to order a City Sampler in the 7-7:30PM timeframe. I understand the concept of cost controls, but, really?
Dina Brooks
Dina Brooks 2026.08.26
     
Reply from City Barbeque 2026.08.27
Thank you for the shout out about our 'que! We hope to see you again soon!
Chris Robinson
Chris Robinson 2026.08.26
     
Reply from City Barbeque 2026.08.27
Thank you for the shout out about our 'que! We hope to see you again soon!
Lotus Elise
Lotus Elise 2026.08.26
     
The brisket is as good as it looks. The staff are wonderful and kind and the food came so quick. I had never had the brisket before so they were kind enough to let me try some before buying it. I definitely recommend this City BBQ to anyone who enjoys good food.
Reply from City Barbeque 2026.08.27
Thank you for the shout out about our 'que! We hope to see you again soon!
Marilyn Ostendorf
Marilyn Ostendorf 2026.08.25
     
This is a dine in or take out. You order at counter and wait to be called to get your food. Great BBQ food.
Reply from City Barbeque 2026.08.25
Thank you for the shout out about our 'que! We hope to see you again soon!
Mike Newman
Mike Newman 2026.08.22
     
Reply from City Barbeque 2023.06.13
Glad to hear that you had a positive experience! Download our app to earn rewards for each visit!
Brent Koenig
Brent Koenig 2026.08.20
     
Reply from City Barbeque 2026.08.20
Thank you for the shout out about our 'que! We hope to see you again soon!
Kyle Ellis
Kyle Ellis 2026.08.18
     
Reply from City Barbeque 2026.08.19
Thank you for the shout out about our 'que! We hope to see you again soon!
Hannah Pacheco
Hannah Pacheco 2026.08.18
     
Carmel City Barbecue is the best!! Awesome service from Caroline & Giselle. Best ribs & brisket ever!
Reply from City Barbeque 2026.08.19
Thank you for the shout out about our 'que! We hope to see you again soon!
Ramoan Dugan
Ramoan Dugan 2026.08.18
     
Great customer service was given by Caroline. Very accommodating
Reply from City Barbeque 2026.08.19
Thank you for the shout out about our 'que! We hope to see you again soon!
jessie perez
jessie perez 2026.08.18
     
You must try the ribs with potato salad and a side of corn bread pudding !! It’s the perfect combination, I promise you won’t be disappointed! On my dine experience I was greeted and helped by Giselle and Caroline they make a great team in there ! The place was clean and the service was a 10/10 !
Reply from City Barbeque 2026.08.19
Thank you for the shout out about our 'que! We hope to see you again soon!
Marcos Perez
Marcos Perez 2026.08.18
     
Carmel City Barbecue is where it’s at guys !!! Exceptional service from both GISELLE & CAROLINE, now go get you some delicious ribs !!!
Reply from City Barbeque 2026.08.19
Thank you for the shout out about our 'que! We hope to see you again soon!
Yvette
Yvette 2026.08.18
     
Reply from City Barbeque 2026.08.18
Thank you for the shout out about our 'que! We hope to see you again soon!
Doug Daubenspeck
Doug Daubenspeck 2026.08.15
     
Reply from City Barbeque 2026.08.16
Thank you for the shout out about our 'que! We hope to see you again soon!
Liz Escoffery
Liz Escoffery 2026.08.12
     
Top knotch BBQ. Family pack is a steal!!!!
Reply from City Barbeque 2026.08.13
Thank you for the shout out about our 'que! We hope to see you again soon!
Audrey Thompson
Audrey Thompson 2026.08.10
     
Reply from City Barbeque 2026.08.10
Thank you for the shout out about our 'que! We hope to see you again soon!
Lauren Williams
Lauren Williams 2026.08.08
     
We submitted an online order. Waited 30 minutes past the time we were told it would be ready. Then was told they ran out of food and couldn’t fulfill the order. What BBQ place runs out of meat on a Saturday at 6pm?? There were 6 people “working” in the back with only 1 cook actually working. So now we have to contact customer service for a full refund. Poor service and the floors were sticky and gross. Won’t be returning.
Reply from City Barbeque 2026.08.17
We're sorry to hear about your experience, Lauren. I can assure you we dont like when we sell out of items earlier than expected. Unfortunately, sometimes we receive large orders with no notice. Because we smoke our meats fresh each day, this can lead to us being short. In addition, due to the time it takes to smoke our meats, we aren't able to recover quickly like other restaurants that specialize in grilling, frying, etc. While we dont like to sell out, ensuring we dont sacrifice quality is more of a priority. I can understand its frustrating when it happens. We hope you will give us another try in the future.
Scott Schultz
Scott Schultz 2026.08.05
     
The food is always good if they actually have some to sell. The problem is they are always sold out of many items at this location before 7pm. This is the 3rd time in a row. If you consistently run out of items hours before closing, don't you think you should prepare more in the future so you don't run out?
Reply from City Barbeque 2026.08.07
Thanks for sharing your feedback, Scott. We’re glad to hear you enjoy the food! We understand how frustrating it is to find items sold out, and we're working on improving our stock levels to ensure everyone can enjoy their favorites. Your input is valuable to us!
Dennis Chmielewski
Dennis Chmielewski 2026.08.04
     
Order was correct and delivered to my car promptly.
Reply from City Barbeque 2025.03.28
Dennis, we’re thrilled to hear you enjoyed the Texas Reuben and our Pepsi! Your enthusiasm is contagious and makes our day. Thanks for sharing your experience—hope to see you back for another delicious meal soon!
Liz
Liz 2026.08.01
     
Out of brisket?! On at least several recent trips there, they tell us they're out of brisket. It was not late at night either. Both times were during the afternoon to late afternoon. I can understand that from time to time, restaurants may run out of certain dishes, but this is what they do. Brisket is kind of their main dish. If they're out, the least they can do is post it on their website and put a sign on the door. It is super inconvenient to wait in a long line and spend over an hour of drive time round trip, to be told only when you finally make it to the register!
Reply from City Barbeque 2026.08.02
We appreciate your feedback, Liz. We understand how frustrating it is to find out we’re out of brisket after a long wait. Due to how we smoke our Brisket fresh each day, we may not always be out for the entire day. We may be waiting for more to come off the smoker. I do understand how frustrating it can be to not see this on the website before you head to see us. We will work on being more proactive when we are getting low on product instead of waiting until it is completely sold out. We would love to make it up to you. Please email me at jpriepot@citybbq.com so I can help. I look forward to hearing from you.

Skyrocket Your Sales with Customer Reviews. No coding required.

Create a Free Account