Circo's Pastry Shop Reviews

Excellent rating

4.6 | 765 reviews

Verified Company

circospastryshop.com Visit this website

Reviews

4.6

| 765 total

5 stars

624 pcs

4 stars

71 pcs

3 stars

17 pcs

2 stars

8 pcs

1 star

45 pcs

Source filter

765 pcs

Verified

Pat Voorhees 2025.12.13

This is my 2nd order from Circos and I can't say enough about their cookies and biscotti some of which I have never seen before. These are old time Italian delicious as i remember them. The packaging was meticulous; I live in NJ and not one cookie was broken nor were sprinkles all over the place in the delivery.. wish we had one of your bakeries in Toms River. I froze the cookies for the holidays and they were just as delicious a week later. I will be a repeat customer. Pat V.

Bob Phillips 2025.12.13

Salvatore Climenti 2025.12.13

I live in Florida and was craving a taste of home. I ordered a pound each of large Fig and sesame cookies. They arrived in 3 days perfectly boxed and shipped. They take great pride in their product and it shows. The cookies were delicious and very fresh. I will be ordering again soon for Christmas.

I live in Florida and was craving a taste of home. I ordered a pound each of large Fig and sesame cookies. They arrived in 3 days perfectly boxed and shipped. They take great pride in their product and it shows. The cookies were delicious and very fresh. I will be ordering again soon for Christmas.

I live in Florida and was craving a taste of home. I ordered a pound each of large Fig and sesame cookies. They arrived in 3 days perfectly boxed and shipped. They take great pride in their product and it shows. The cookies were delicious and very fresh. I will be ordering again soon for Christmas.

Chris McCombe 2025.12.13

Ordered biscotti for Christmas, for myself and an order to go to my parents. Shipping was timely, biscotti taste amazing- however I did have quite a few broken. I’m hoping the gift to my parents is not broken like mine. Otherwise it would be 5 stars.

Josephine Tarangelo 2025.12.10

UPDATE: I was so happy that someone from the bakery reached out to me. We talked and after a nice discussion the bakery sent me another order of honey balls. They are going to arrive today. Yesterday my order of fig cookies arrived and I want to tell everyone THEY ARE DELICIOUS . I was not disappointed at all. I hope one day after the busy holiday to take a ride to Brooklyn to actually visit the bakery and pick up some other goodies. Thank you Circo's for hearing me and making things even better!! Merry Christmas. My anticipated order arrived today and I’m totally disappointed. I purchased 2 trays of honey balls and they were stale. I was very shocked by this. Anyway I tried to email directly but was unable . My hope is that they contact me to make this right

UPDATE: I was so happy that someone from the bakery reached out to me. We talked and after a nice discussion the bakery sent me another order of honey balls. They are going to arrive today. Yesterday my order of fig cookies arrived and I want to tell everyone THEY ARE DELICIOUS . I was not disappointed at all. I hope one day after the busy holiday to take a ride to Brooklyn to actually visit the bakery and pick up some other goodies. Thank you Circo's for hearing me and making things even better!! Merry Christmas.

My anticipated order arrived today and I’m totally disappointed. I purchased 2 trays of honey balls and they were stale. I was very shocked by this. Anyway I tried to email directly but was unable . My hope is that they contact me to make this right

UPDATE: I was so happy that someone from the bakery reached out to me. We talked and after a nice discussion the bakery sent me another order of honey balls. They are going to arrive today. Yesterday my order of fig cookies arrived and I want to tell everyone THEY ARE DELICIOUS . I was not disappointed at all. I hope one day after the busy holiday to take a ride to Brooklyn to actually visit the bakery and pick up some other goodies. Thank you Circo's for hearing me and making things even better!! Merry Christmas.

My anticipated order arrived today and I’m totally disappointed. I purchased 2 trays of honey balls and they were stale. I was very shocked by this. Anyway I tried to email directly but was unable . My hope is that they contact me to make this right

Reply from Circo's Pastry Shop 2025.12.09

We are very surprised to hear this as we are constantly making them fresh. Please email us directly with your order number so we can investigate this issue immediately. Please email info@circospastryshop.com

Lord Raijin 2025.12.10

This place is like if desserts were heaven on earth. I am constantly frustrated by Italian cookies such as rainbow and other jam filled cookies not having so much as a slight scraping of preserve. Circo's does not do this and rather gives you all the jam and chocolate spread you could dream of. They make the most delicious cookies ever and their pastries are to die for. Some may argue they are too sweet but that is exactly what I want out of a sweets and pastry shop. 5 Stars.

Mishka Backer 2025.12.08

All roads lead to Circo's! Having had tried multiple Italian pastry shops, this still remains my go-to. I've only ever ordered through delivery services, but I can imagine in person is just as perfect! I plan on ordering online for family out of state some time into the near future, they're THAT good.

Marcella Pettorossi 2025.12.07

Thank you Circo’s Family. Very pleased with all that we purchased and quick delivery. The Circo Fig cookies are amazing. Flavor, texture and professional presentation more than expected. Will be ordering more for Xmas.

Nicholas Demaree 2025.12.06

Excellent cookies, we have ordered them for Christmas 2 years in a row now and we will definitely order them again next year.

Reghan Williams 2025.12.04

My parents got to keep my first order as UPS did not get it delivered in time, so I ordered a second. Purchased the Struffoli, 2lb assorted cookie box, and Holy Cannoli Donuts and all of them are fantastic. We decided as a family this will become a tradition!

My parents got to keep my first order as UPS did not get it delivered in time, so I ordered a second. Purchased the Struffoli, 2lb assorted cookie box, and Holy Cannoli Donuts and all of them are fantastic. We decided as a family this will become a tradition!

My parents got to keep my first order as UPS did not get it delivered in time, so I ordered a second. Purchased the Struffoli, 2lb assorted cookie box, and Holy Cannoli Donuts and all of them are fantastic. We decided as a family this will become a tradition!

Will Kelley 2025.11.28

I had the pleasure of meeting Nino and one of his sons and chatting with them both mentioning I was on a short vacation in NY from Maine and stopping by Circo’s was on my list, they were thrilled I came by, everything was spectacular and fresh. Best of the best. 10/10

Jasonhenry309 2025.11.26

My family loves this place. My wedding cake was made from here and it was delicious. Best cake I ever tasted. I moved out of state a few yrs ago and when my family, who still lives in the state, said they were coming to my house for Thanksgiving, I asked them to please bring some items from Circo’s with them. And when I say out of state, I mean Georgia. My family picked up some of the best pastries my family and myself ever tasted and brought them to my house. I want to say I love this place.

Chris Lewis 2025.11.25

Wow takes me back to my childhood when my Italian grandmother would make these cookies, absolutely delicious can't be more happy with my order Thank you!

Wow takes me back to my childhood when my Italian grandmother would make these cookies, absolutely delicious can't be more happy with my order Thank you!

Wow takes me back to my childhood when my Italian grandmother would make these cookies, absolutely delicious can't be more happy with my order Thank you!

Cait DUGAN 2025.11.25

Sandra Hughes 2025.11.23

Delicious! I was so happy to see the cookies delivered when they were scheduled and they were perfect.

John Morony 2025.11.22

I can't say enough good things about the quality and service of Circo's. This is now a must visit if you are anywhere near Brooklyn and if not, you won't find better mail order service anywhere. The quality of the pastries and cookies cannot be beat! This is a delicious step back in time to my childhood and is an absolute favorite.

I can't say enough good things about the quality and service of Circo's. This is now a must visit if you are anywhere near Brooklyn and if not, you won't find better mail order service anywhere. The quality of the pastries and cookies cannot be beat! This is a delicious step back in time to my childhood and is an absolute favorite.

I can't say enough good things about the quality and service of Circo's. This is now a must visit if you are anywhere near Brooklyn and if not, you won't find better mail order service anywhere. The quality of the pastries and cookies cannot be beat! This is a delicious step back in time to my childhood and is an absolute favorite.

Paul Galasso 2025.11.20

Tommy Fedele 2025.11.19

Peter J. DiRocco 2025.11.19

I recently ordered Struffoli and an assorted Italian cookie box from Circo’s Pastry Shop and had them shipped all the way to Hawaii. The care they put into packaging was unbelievable — they even lined the cookie box with bubble wrap, and not a single cookie arrived broken. That alone deserves five stars. What really struck me was the nostalgia. It’s been about 25 years since I’ve had these cookies, and the first bite instantly transported me back to my childhood. I brought them over to my parents’ house, and it was a throwback for them too. My mother grew up around the block on Irving Avenue and remembers when the family took over the bakery so seeing these cookies again brought back memories. I’m so grateful that Circo’s ships all the way out here to Hawaii. My kids tried the cookies for the first time in their lives and are completely hooked. And please — consider opening a shop on Oʻahu. You already have fans waiting. (We will crack into the Struffoli next week)

I recently ordered Struffoli and an assorted Italian cookie box from Circo’s Pastry Shop and had them shipped all the way to Hawaii. The care they put into packaging was unbelievable — they even lined the cookie box with bubble wrap, and not a single cookie arrived broken. That alone deserves five stars.

What really struck me was the nostalgia. It’s been about 25 years since I’ve had these cookies, and the first bite instantly transported me back to my childhood. I brought them over to my parents’ house, and it was a throwback for them too. My mother grew up around the block on Irving Avenue and remembers when the family took over the bakery so seeing these cookies again brought back memories.

I’m so grateful that Circo’s ships all the way out here to Hawaii. My kids tried the cookies for the first time in their lives and are completely hooked. And please — consider opening a shop on Oʻahu. You already have fans waiting. (We will crack into the Struffoli next week)

I recently ordered Struffoli and an assorted Italian cookie box from Circo’s Pastry Shop and had them shipped all the way to Hawaii. The care they put into packaging was unbelievable — they even lined the cookie box with bubble wrap, and not a single cookie arrived broken. That alone deserves five stars.

What really struck me was the nostalgia. It’s been about 25 years since I’ve had these cookies, and the first bite instantly transported me back to my childhood. I brought them over to my parents’ house, and it was a throwback for them too. My mother grew up around the block on Irving Avenue and remembers when the family took over the bakery so seeing these cookies again brought back memories.

I’m so grateful that Circo’s ships all the way out here to Hawaii. My kids tried the cookies for the first time in their lives and are completely hooked. And please — consider opening a shop on Oʻahu. You already have fans waiting. (We will crack into the Struffoli next week)

I recently ordered Struffoli and an assorted Italian cookie box from Circo’s Pastry Shop and had them shipped all the way to Hawaii. The care they put into packaging was unbelievable — they even lined the cookie box with bubble wrap, and not a single cookie arrived broken. That alone deserves five stars.

What really struck me was the nostalgia. It’s been about 25 years since I’ve had these cookies, and the first bite instantly transported me back to my childhood. I brought them over to my parents’ house, and it was a throwback for them too. My mother grew up around the block on Irving Avenue and remembers when the family took over the bakery so seeing these cookies again brought back memories.

I’m so grateful that Circo’s ships all the way out here to Hawaii. My kids tried the cookies for the first time in their lives and are completely hooked. And please — consider opening a shop on Oʻahu. You already have fans waiting. (We will crack into the Struffoli next week)

Mike 2025.11.18

Pignoli cookies are to die for outstanding

Company activity

Claimed Profile
Displaying Reviews
Replies To Reviews In 1 Day
Replied to 9% of reviews
Top Rated Certificate

About Circo's Pastry Shop

Circo's Pastry Shop is trusted by over 715 happy customers, earning a 4.6-star rating! Explore real reviews and share your own experience.

TOP 5 Trustindex Features

100+ Review Platforms

40 Breathtaking review widgets

Easy review collection

Review image generator

Review e-mail signatures

Create a Free account