Verified Company
We held a welcome dinner for a group of over 30 guests. The food selection was great, with the entrées and desserts standing out in particular. However, we did feel that there were not enough staff or servers to accommodate our group. The restaurant itself offered a comfortable ambiance and plenty of space for everyone to move around and mingle. We were also allotted a generous four hours for our private dinner, which made the evening feel relaxed and enjoyable.
If you’re looking for a place for dinner in Westbury, this place is a must. The staff is very nice and the food is excellent. I highly recommend the pork chop and the rack of lamb. They have a very extensive menu and other dishes I’ve had is just as good. Five stars.
Reply from Casa di Fratelli
2025.10.28
Thank you so much for the wonderful 5 star review. Our team takes a lot of pride in making sure everything's excellent. We can't wait to welcome you back for more delicious meals. Grazie mille and see you soon!
Casa di Fratelli - Review
Casa di Fratelli is a cozy Italian restaurant known for its warm ambiance and authentic Italian dishes.
Pros:
- Classic Italian flavors with fresh ingredients
- Delicious pasta and wood-fired pizzas
- Friendly and attentive staff
- Comfortable and inviting atmosphere, great for families and date nights
Cons:
- Slightly higher prices compared to casual Italian spots
- Limited parking in busy hours
Overall, a solid choice for genuine Italian dining with good service and tasty food.
Rating: 4/5
Reply from Casa di Fratelli
2025.10.25
Thank you so much for your kind words! We're thrilled you enjoyed our dishes. Our team always loves making sure every guest feels right at home. We can't wait to welcome you back for another wonderful meal soon!
Fresh cooked, delicious food; lovely, comfortable, atmosphere; excellent, attentive but not pushy service. Highly recommend!
Reply from Casa di Fratelli
2025.10.25
Thank you for such a wonderful review. We're so happy you enjoyed the food. We always aim to be attentive so it's fantastic to hear that we hit the mark. Can't wait to have you dine with us again soon!
A hidden gem in Long island , everything they have is over the top and I visit restaurants all over i being their customer for like 7 years already everything is delicious
Reply from Casa di Fratelli
2025.10.25
Thank you so much for being such a loyal guest! We're beyond thrilled that you've been enjoying everything for so many years. It really means the world to us. We can't wait to keep serving you more delicious meals for many more years to come!
Great experience and worth every penny. The prices are fair and the service was exceptional. I would definitely come here again. I would recommend the lobster ravioli and the cannolis.
Reply from Casa di Fratelli
2025.10.25
We're absolutley delighted you found everything worth it. It means the world to us that you'd recomment us and we can't wait to welcome you back again soon!
This location is the perfect spot for special occasions and quality of good Italian food. In addition, we've been here several times- this weekend we came for a birthday dinner. We sat at the table and less than a minute we were asked for our drink order. We told the server, we just sat, give us a minute. The older Caucasian male with white hair became upset, walked away and said "whatever." I've never been told whatever in regards to a drink order. We asked for the wine list and informed the male, no wine list was given because we wanted a bottle of wine, which we ordered. The male got into a back and forth with us. We kept asking for a supervisor and was met with resistance from staff. Again, this service was terrible, we informed staff it was a birthday, no one came and sang happy birthday, none of this. In addition, finally at the end, we were told Tina was the fill in manager. Tina was apologetic for this terrible server's behavior and her staff members being deceiving with the manager working and not working. We had duck, pasta, chicken marsala and steak and lobster.
We were ready to stop coming to location and Tina made it right by offering a gift certificate to continue with our business. We spend usually $300-$400 whenever we grab dinner here.
