Bleecker Trading Reviews

Jon Gluvna 2026.04.24

     

I just completed my first online out of state order with Bleeker Trading. From the initial contact for assistance with available inventory to the speedy delivery of the "Fra-Gile-Le" contents (the item was 2 boxes of Christmas Story cards). They are A+++++ with service, highly recommend 😀

Useful Report

Reply from Bleecker Trading 2026.04.25

Jon!! Thank you very much for the kind review! We were glad that we could help assist you! Hope you visit us the next time you're in NYC!

Spiro Stanos 2026.04.18

     

Way too expensive for boxes some things at Bleecker that they sell is half the price at Barnes and nobles. Good for selling cards and buying individual cards. Nice staff

Useful Report

Reply from Bleecker Trading 2026.04.21

Hey Spiro, we are happy to hear that you enjoyed our staff and were able to find some singles! In regard to your comment about B&N, our box prices are always extremely competitive to the market price. We would be more than happy to explain this process to you in person the next time you stop by the shop! If you have any other questions, please reach out to team@bleeckertrading.com!

Kushtrim He 2026.04.18

     

We traveled all the way from Germany to visit Bleecker Trading — and I can honestly say it’s a place I will never forget. The moment you walk in, the atmosphere just hits you. Everything about it feels right: the music, the vibe, the layout. The seating area is incredibly cozy and welcoming, the kind of place where you just want to sit down and stay a while. And the back courtyard? Absolutely incredible. It’s been set up so thoughtfully — a perfect spot to relax, grab a drink, open some packs, play cards, and just enjoy the moment with good people around you. The selection of cards is outstanding. Whether you’re into Pokémon, sports cards, or other trading card games, they have you covered in a big way. But what really sets this place apart is the team running it. These guys know exactly what they’re doing — passionate, knowledgeable, and genuinely friendly. You can tell this is more than just a shop to them. I visited with my wife and our two kids, and we all had an amazing time. We spent quite a while there and didn’t want to leave. Luckily I took plenty of photos, because this is a memory I want to hold onto forever. If you’re even remotely into trading cards, this is a must-visit. Highest possible recommendation. 🙌

Useful Report

Reply from Bleecker Trading 2026.04.21

Wow, what a great review! Thank you so much for the kind words, this made our day! We are happy that you had such an awesome experience and we hope you stop by again on your next visit!

olivia grace arguelles 2026.04.12

     

A wide array and selection of cards and collectibles, the store was spacious, clean, and very organized, the employees were helpful and very knowledgeable as well, 5/5 trading card shop in NYC

Useful Report

Reply from Bleecker Trading 2026.04.13

Love reading reviews like this one! We are glad that you had a great time Olivia! Hope to see you again soon!

Corey Dugan 2026.04.09

     

Great spot for cards of all kinds. Huge selection of vintage packs (90s/80s) and a ton of singles organized by sport. Highly recommend to thrill the card enthusiast in your life!

Useful Report

Reply from Bleecker Trading 2026.04.10

Wooo! Thank you for the kind review! Hope you stop in again soon!

Matt Bridgett 2026.04.09

     

Friendly vibe. Got some boosters and cool pulls! Thanks again guys!

Useful Report

Reply from Bleecker Trading 2026.04.10

We appreciate you stopping by Matt! Congrats on the pulls!

Samir Musovic 2026.04.08

     

nice store with a good selection and friendly staff

Useful Report

Reply from Bleecker Trading 2026.04.08

Thank you for stopping by Samir! Hope to see you again soon!

agastya malhotra 2026.03.31

     

GO THERE ALL THE TIME AND I PULLED A DOWNTOWN I SWEAR. SAM LAPORTA DOWNTOWN I PULLED FROM THEM.

Useful Report

Reply from Bleecker Trading 2026.04.01

Let's goooo!!! Congrats on the pull!!!

Sunkissed 2026.03.31

     

Useful Report

Reply from Bleecker Trading 2026.03.31

🔥🔥🔥

Owen Dean 2026.03.30

     

If your looking for really nice selling cards, this is the spot

Useful Report

Reply from Bleecker Trading 2026.03.31

Let's go! Appreciate the support Owen! Hope to see you at the shop again soon!

Chris 2026.03.30

     

Best store in nyc for reasonable prices and great environment.

Useful Report

Reply from Bleecker Trading 2026.03.30

You're the best! Appreciate the kind review Chris!

Rielly Vlassis 2026.03.28

     

Love sports cards and people are nice and welcoming

Useful Report

Reply from Bleecker Trading 2026.03.28

We are glad that you enjoyed your experience Rielly! Hope to see you again soon!

Kyle Holden 2026.03.24

     

Matt & the guys at Bleeker Trading were great! Good selection of raw and slabbed Pokemon. Got my daughter her first slab, and of her “current favorite” Pokemon - Bulbasaur. Looking forward to visiting on return trips to NYC

Useful Report

Reply from Bleecker Trading 2026.03.24

Let's go! This is awesome to hear! Can't wait to see you guys again soon!

Thomas Mershon 2026.03.21

     

Charges 200 percent more on Pokemon cards then surrounding stores and buys from scalpers . Making it hard for hobbyists to enjoy and price gouging not because they have to but because they want to. Highest prices in the city

Useful Report

Reply from Bleecker Trading 2026.03.21

Hey Thomas, we’re sorry you didn’t enjoy your Bleecker Trading experience. Our prices are very competitive to the market. If you ever have any questions about pricing, our retail staff is more than happy to explain why a particular item is priced a certain way. If you have any other complaints, please reach out to team@bleeckertrading.com. We would be happy to answer any additional questions/concerns you may have.

Eliud Melendez 2026.03.20

     

Super friendly and Professional! If you’re looking to buy/sell Pokemon TCG highly recommended!

Useful Report

Reply from Bleecker Trading 2026.03.20

Happy to hear that you enjoyed your time at Bleecker! We appreciate the support!

Rahat Bathija 2026.03.16

     

Very cool shop. Pokemon artwork has gotten so good now. Cool lounge area in the back to play cards and sit down.

Useful Report

Reply from Bleecker Trading 2026.03.16

We are glad that you enjoyed your experience Rahat! Hope to see you again soon!

Pamela Williams 2026.03.02

     

They had a great event there i had fun i hope to go there again

Useful Report

Reply from Bleecker Trading 2026.03.02

Wooo! Happy to hear that you had a good time! Looking forward to seeing you again soon!

Eric Gilley 2026.02.17

     

Amazing place. Staff is helpful and willing to work with you in finding exactly what you want.

Useful Report

Reply from Bleecker Trading 2026.02.17

Happy to hear this Eric! We are glad that you enjoyed your Bleecker Trading experience!

Lucas 2026.02.07

     

This place sells bundles and singles for almost double what they're worth, you're much better ordering anything online, if you REALLY need to open a few packs, Pokecourt has much better prices. The singles selection here is also very mixed and often random cards no one wants.

Useful Report

Reply from Bleecker Trading 2026.02.09

Hey Lucas, our prices are very competitive to the market. If you ever have a question on pricing, our staff would be more than happy to explain to you why a certain card/bundle is priced where it's at. We hope you stop by again and give us another chance!

bristol briggs 2026.02.07

     

Amazing place with great prices. ! You gotta check it out asap.

Useful Report

Reply from Bleecker Trading 2026.02.09

We are glad to hear that you enjoyed your Bleecker Trading experience!