Agi's Counter

Agi's Counter Reviews

Excellent rating
     
4.6 | 642 reviews
Trustindex Verified Company
Agi's Counter
Write a review

Reviews

Trustindex

4.6

| 642 total

505 pcs
66 pcs
18 pcs
12 pcs
21 pcs
Source filter
allie
allie 2026.03.08
     
You probably weren’t thinking of getting the Celery Root Schnitzel, but I’m vegetarian so that’s what I got. It’s pretty good, a panko fried veg with sauce on top. Kudos for thinking outside of the box
Matthew Stanley
Matthew Stanley 2026.03.04
     
Such a great experience. Service was intentional and everything we ate was exceptional.
Kaya Fridman
Kaya Fridman 2026.03.01
     
Food and coffee are just fine. Overhyped. Honestly this place sucks. Same gentrifier atmosphere and attitude. Front of house staff… *shrugs shoulders.* Skip the hype of this spot and find other neighborhood gems.
Michael Aroney
Michael Aroney 2026.02.28
     
The food was pretty terrible and the service was overbearing to the point of it being unbearable. Would not recommend in any circumstances. There are so many other interesting restaurants in nyc that deserve to be visited.
Katherine
Katherine 2026.02.21
     
Great tuna melt. Flavorful and well-made. The server was super friendly and went out of their way to help us out. Would come back for the food and the hospitality!
Wendy Zhou
Wendy Zhou 2026.02.13
     
A very homey interior that serves amazing comfort food - love how they highlight the Eastern European palate while keeping the dishes light and balanced. Came for lunch specifically for the sandwiches and they did not disappoint.
Laura Klein
Laura Klein 2026.02.13
     
I love everything about Agi’s Counter ❤️
Price Trosin
Price Trosin 2026.02.11
     
Very nice staff, food was great. I even had chicken liver and it was good 🤯. Loved the neighborhood!
Carter Henderson
Carter Henderson 2026.02.08
     
just like not good - flavorless salty and oily; not a generous portion of tuna with the tuna melt could barely taste it. and very expensive as well? i don’t know, really disappointed with the food and the service is not great either. the space is cute and the andes chocolates are nice.
Mallory Herb
Mallory Herb 2026.02.05
     
I discovered Agi’s Counter after an influencer mentioned the business was struggling financially and encouraged people to support. Third time’s the charm- I tried to go twice before but arrived during their break (they’re closed from 3 to 5:30 PM), so definitely check the hours before heading over. I finally made it in on a Sunday when I was craving a tuna melt. I called ahead hoping to place a to-go order but they told me to just order it when I got there since it would be ready quickly. I ended up waiting at least 15 minutes, which I wouldn’t consider fast, but the tuna melt was absolutely delicious and I’d 100% order it again. I noticed the sides were slightly different from what I see in other photos, mine came with a full small pickle and a few peppers, while others seem to get coleslaw. Not a big deal, just a small inconsistency to note. From what I could see, business seemed to be doing well, which is great to see. I’m glad I finally got to try it and would come back just maybe not when I’m in a rush.
Melanie Fidler
Melanie Fidler 2026.02.01
     
I came back to agis for brunch after scoring a reservation a month in advance and sadly had a lackluster experience.I hadn't been in over a year and wanted to support them. I'm sorry to say that it will be my last time. The menu and service had changed significantly. There's are a lot more sandwiches on the menu, no egg dishes and they got rid of the coveted devil eggs. The highlights of the meal were the small hash brown plate over sour cream, similar to a deconstructed latke and the candied grapefruit. The sandwich de jour was roast beef which was soaked in a plate of oil, one small slice of roast beef and many other flavorless textured veggies of sorts. I didn't taste any horseradish and for $20, I'd expect more meat. Probably should went with the tuna melt. The devil eggs are now called "jammy eggs" which was one soft boiled egg cut in half face down in a sea of mayo and green oil. We added chicken skin, thinking to add a salty bite, but it was more like a long, hard piece of bark. I used to LOVE the deviled eggs with anchovies, this was cold and not appetizing. I wish they'd bring back the old simplified menu, it was fantastic, and the warm hospitality. Overall we left disappointed, hungry and bummed by the outcome.
kathy merritt
kathy merritt 2026.02.01
     
The vibe at AGI’S CORNER is so relaxed & the service impeccable. The menu offerings are seasonally “sensitive”, varied and not overwhelming in number or price! The dishes are aesthetically pleasing to the eye, scintillating to the tastebuds, nutritious, not skimpy & respectful of their cultural heritage. Heartbroken beets (homemade chamomile vinegar, mild tasty, smooth blue cheese), chicken liver mousse (homemade crackers off the chart perfect pairing), chicken parikas (grandmother AGI’S recipe we were told), roast hake, Bableves (hearty healthy tasty Hungarian bean soup) w buttered bread AND cheescake with delicate fresh fruit were shared AND all enjoying were amazed at the quality of each dish! It was great to meet team members so welcoming, so engaging. Mack & team members we met (Amanda, Sara, Nico, David, Mason, Lewis) were professional, friendly, seemed to be genuinely engaged and each contributed to our very memorable, positive experience. I am sending gift certificates to my children so they can experience AGI’S CORNER and if as pleased as their mother, I hope they will share the love and introduce others to this hidden gem!
Dana Fennell
Dana Fennell 2026.02.01
     
I can't remember the last time I enjoyed a meal as much as I did this one. First of all, the heartbroken beets, could have eaten only that all night! The Chicken Paprikas was delicious! And that cheesecake! Oh, goodness! Also, our server, Amanda was a sweetheart and was very good at helping us decide which meal by explaining the ingredients and flavors. (Who knew blue cheese and beets might work!) Also very pleasant Nico, Devon, and Sarah! We sat at the bar so had a chance to say hi to the Chefs, Mason, Louis, and David, and Our Sous Chef , "Mac" (who also explained some about the dishes!) was marvelous! The room was warm and friendly, great experience! I'll be back to NYC for this culinary experience as soon as I can! Yes, Chef!
Truth Gem
Truth Gem 2026.02.01
     
This is a lovely Hungarian restaurant with a warm and cozy atmosphere. Although the space is small, the vibe feels intimate and welcoming, and the staff are genuinely friendly and attentive, which makes the whole dining experience very comfortable. The food is well-executed and thoughtfully balanced. The chicken liver appetizer with crispy chips, celery, and pickled cherries was a standout — incredibly smooth and rich, while the cherries added just the right acidity to cut through the heaviness and leave a clean, satisfying finish. The pork chop was also very good. It was slightly on the firmer side, but the peach sauce paired with it beautifully, adding a subtle sweetness that kept the dish from feeling greasy. The fries were crispy and flavorful, though a bit salty — a minor issue that didn’t take away from the overall enjoyment. The biggest surprise was the New York cheesecake. Served with blueberry sauce and fresh blueberries, it wasn’t overly sweet at all. The fruit balanced the richness of the cheesecake perfectly, creating a light and elegant finish to the meal. Overall, this restaurant clearly excels at using fruit to balance rich flavors. A highly recommended spot if you’re looking for a refined and enjoyable Hungarian dining experience.
Ren D
Ren D 2026.01.23
     
Had the tuna melt and it was absolutely worth stopping by. The vibes were great.

Skyrocket Your Sales with Customer Reviews. No coding required.

Create a Free Account