Rothmann's Steakhouse

Rothmann's Steakhouse Reviews

Good rating
     
4.4 | 1324 reviews
Trustindex Verified Company
Rothmann's Steakhouse
Write a review

Reviews

Trustindex

4.4

| 1324 total

922 pcs
203 pcs
97 pcs
42 pcs
60 pcs
Source filter
Al Halimi
Al Halimi 2026.05.17
     
Clearly so many people pointed issues with steaks overcooked not to mention they are steakhouse.One complaint regarding food poisoning.Rather to pass to get sick or be disappointed.
Michael Santa Maria
Michael Santa Maria 2026.05.11
     
I recently had my first trip to Rothmann’s Steakhouse. What a fantastic dining experience. First of all the atmosphere is very old-school. Servers are very well trained and are very knowledgeable about the menu. I ordered grilled octopus and baked clams for appetizers and they were all both delicious. My skirt steak was cooked to a perfect medium, rare with sides of brussels sprouts and truffle fries. I wish I had more time to indulgent their desserts, but we had a show to catch. I will definitely be back in the near future.
Anthony Erdogan
Anthony Erdogan 2026.05.03
     
Absolutely amazing from top to bottom. I had high expectations and everything exceeded any expectations I had. This is the best steakhouse I have been to on the North Shore.
Lorraine Wiesen
Lorraine Wiesen 2026.04.24
     
Sunday Brunch at Rothmans was outstanding! The service staff was very attentive and professional. And the range of food choices were diverse, including Sushi and the shell fish station as well as the dessert station. The nostalgic atmosphere is very comfortable. I will plan another Sunday brunch at Rothmans Steakhouse in the future.
Issei Kohama
Issei Kohama 2026.04.23
     
A classic steakhouse with relaxing luxurious restaurant atmosphere. A great space to celebrate or discuss business matters. Highly recommend for high quality restaurant experience.
Jimmy EL
Jimmy EL 2026.04.19
     
Cool place. Really big. Everything was good. Obviously expensive.
Jennifer Winters Runolfsson
Jennifer Winters Runolfsson 2026.04.02
     
Such a wide variety of fresh food. It was unlike any brunch I've ever been to. Definitely worth the money if you bring your appetite.
JaySan Avante
JaySan Avante 2026.04.01
     
Rothmans Steakhouse 6319 Northern Blvd, East Norwich NY 11732 Rothmann's is an upscale restaurant that has been consistent since day 1. Good food, good service in an old world setting. My wife has been pushing me for a while for another visit to Rothmann's- but this time for Brunch. As usual, all the options were on the table! Eggs however you'd like em! Pancakes, steak, donuts, you name it! Wow! Talk about a party of goodies! We filed our plates 2x and enjoyed our coffee. Im a big fan of fresh squeezed OJ, but i've found that not many restaurants are into the fresh squeezed scene, including Rothmann's. That being said, everything else was great! I must also note, the bathrooms were exceptionally clean & in good order for a very busy afternoon. There's plenty of parking and easy to get to. I highly recommend!
B A Bennett
B A Bennett 2026.03.21
     
They prepare the skirt steak to shear perfection. The fine dining atmosphere was excellent. There were lots of other great menu choices as well. I recommended this establishment to all of my friends. As fine dining goes, this restaurant is excellent.
D Bui (SaavyShopper)
D Bui (SaavyShopper) 2026.03.17
     
I had such an amazing brunch experience at Rothmann's Steakhouse on a Sunday with my friends! The variety and quality of the food completely exceeded my expectations. The seafood section was a standout—fresh lobster, clams, oysters, and shrimp cocktail all perfectly done. I definitely took full advantage of that station. The carving station was just as impressive, especially the skirt steak—it was so tender that I didn’t even need a knife. It literally melted in your mouth like butter. The prime rib was also excellent. They also had a sushi station, an omelette station, and plenty of other options, so there was something for everyone. Everything felt well-prepared and high quality. Overall, such a great brunch spot for both variety and flavor. Highly recommend checking it out!
Mark Fischl
Mark Fischl 2026.03.16
     
Always delicious. The porterhouse is excellent. Love the onion strings. Pre fixe dinner is a great deal

Skyrocket Your Sales with Customer Reviews. No coding required.

Create a Free Account