Posh Pizza Reviews 2026 | Trustindex.io

Write a review

Reviews

4.7 | 181 total

5 stars

145 pcs

4 stars

8 pcs

3 stars

5 pcs

2 stars

4 pcs

1 star

4 pcs

Source filter

166 pcs

Verified

Svetlana Sholomova 2026.05.03

We come to Posh Pizzeria very often and also use them for catering. The food is always delicious and consistent, and it’s a favorite for our whole family—my daughter especially loves it, which makes it even more special for us. Service can sometimes be a bit hit or miss, but tonight we had Chaim as our waiter and he truly stood out. He was kind, professional, attentive, and made us feel very well taken care of. His positive attitude and helpfulness really elevated our entire experience.It was such a pleasant surprise, and he is truly a great addition to the team.

Useful Report

Reply from Posh Pizza 2026.01.06

Thank you Svetlana ❤️

Heidi Kasher 2026.04.30

Useful Report

yefim 2026.04.29

Useful (1) Report

Avinoam Mizrachi 2026.04.23

Great ambience very chill with polite staff and fresh food

Useful Report

maria 2026.04.19

Cute restaurant, staff were very attentive and friendly. Food quality not the best. I feel the price per dish is overpriced and come out loop warm.

Useful (1) Report

Julie s. 2026.03.27

Whenever I get pizza pie it is never fresh. They heat up a day old pizza that is stale. So disappointing.

Useful Report

Reply from Posh Pizza

Hello Julie. We make all of our pizza daily and fresh. We don’t keep any pizza from the day before and we always try to keep the best quality of our food at all time. We apologize for your disappointment in your last order. Please ask for management at your next visit we will be happy to assist you. Thank you!

Adam Arabov 2026.03.24

Useful Report

Ronit Silver 2026.03.15

Our waiter, Chaim, was great! The food was all outstanding. We had the sea bass, fettuccine Alfredo, and pizza. The pistachio cannoli was out of this world! We had a great experience!

Useful (1) Report

Reply from Posh Pizza

BH thank you Ronit!!

Beatrice 2026.03.08

Wow delicious food!!! I ordered the salmon skewers with mashed potatoes and grilled vegetables, cheese ravioli with vodka sauce, and carrot cake for delivery, all were outstandingly great. I’m excited to try more next time.

Useful (1) Report

Reply from Posh Pizza

Thank you so much Beatrice!

Juda Rutenberg 2026.02.19

Useful Report

Orly Alaev 2026.02.15

Don't bring your kids to the new cafe, apparently it's 21+ .... on a Sunday afternoon. Great food as always but had to kick out a party of 6 which included 2 kids under 10 (very quiet and obedient kids who were eager to eat), after we already got settled and ready to order. Suggestions: make a sign that says 21+ so we are not under the impression that you can sit wherever you'd like, or maybe make that rule apply after a certain time like 4pm?

Useful Report

yuriy davydov 2026.01.12

Excellent pizza 🍕 really good food Fresh, Cafe is very nice, really good frappe

Useful (1) Report

Reply from Posh Pizza 2026.01.13

Thank you Yuriy

rodion pinkhasov 2026.01.04

The best foodand pizza in nyc. The service was incredible.

Useful Report

Lana Niyazova 2025.12.31

Useful Report

Elinora Amin 2025.12.25

We came here for a birthday at around 11:45am. We didn’t want the breakfast menu but we had to wait until 12 to get the lunch menu. Our waitress said we could order the lunch menu when she would put it in at 12 we waited 45 minutes just to get a salad and then they waited every 15 minutes to bring something else that was small and then when we got dessert for the birthday they bring it to us and the candle came out twice. The service was a very terrible don’t recommend and it’s kind of overpriced.

Useful (1) Report

David Paxton 2025.12.10

Definitely a stand out restaurant. Everything is done with "posh" for sure.

Useful (1) Report

Ruslan Musheev 2025.11.30

Manager and staff was amazing. Food and dessert was phenomenal . Service was impeccable . Atmosphere was perfect. Seated our group of 15ppl in the pergola np, we didn't wait long for the food . Drinks were great. Only thing could have been better was the coffee and espresso . Everything else was perfect . Would definitely come back for the vibes.

Useful (1) Report

Reply from Posh Pizza 2025.12.01

Thank you Ruslan. We will definitely work on improving our coffees. So happy overall it was a great night.