Maiella Reviews

Stefany Jimenez 2025.12.15

     

We had our wedding at Maiella Restaurant, and it was absolutely perfect! Tyler, the manager, was incredible—so professional, attentive, and accommodating. He went above and beyond to make sure everything ran smoothly, and Maiella is truly lucky to have him on their team. The food was phenomenal—fresh, flavorful, and beautifully presented. Every single guest raved about the dishes, and we couldn’t have been happier. The atmosphere of the restaurant is warm and elegant, making it the perfect setting for a special occasion. Thank you to the entire Maiella team for making our wedding day so memorable—we couldn’t recommend this place more! Robby & Stefany Pagano!

Useful Report

Brian H 2025.12.15

     

I was really excited to dine in here but expectations wasn’t meant. I was told to take my hat off even though I noticed 3 different people dining in was wearing hats. The food came out lukewarm and cold but it was late so we didn’t even complain. The water was good. I just don’t think because it is late in the day that my food should have so many issues because I paid the same. And still tipped very well because I work in service. Over all 2/5 stars. I just feel that in 2025 the only color that should matter is green ( money being spent ).

Useful Report

Sara Raynor 2025.12.14

     

Food was FIRE! Just a bit too pricey for the serving size.

Useful Report

Kevon Gracie 2025.12.14

     

Overall great experience. Some of the food was a little blah, but the service was amazing.

Useful Report

Melissa Kempadoo 2025.12.14

     

Came here for my mom’s birthday and was very disappointed. The service is bad and you are waiting a long time to get drinks and food. I had to get up twice from my table to find the waitress. The eggplant appetizer was salty and most of our entrees were salty as well. I could barely finish my short rib meal due to the sodium. The atmosphere is nice and location is iconic with the skyline in the background but unfortunately I won’t be coming back.

Useful Report

Aurora Proverbio 2025.12.10

     

As Italian, I have to say they have one of the best Cacio and Pepe I’ve ever tried!

Useful Report

Carlos Luis Moreira 2025.12.10

     

Useful Report

Rhandy M. 2025.12.08

     

Verified

food was served cold. shrimp was not fresh. food was priced for hot and fresh. The atmosphere is pleasant however the food was cold.

Useful Report

Rhandy Maag 2025.12.07

     

Food was cold and bland

Useful Report

Karen X. 2025.12.03

     

Verified

It was very hard to find parking nearby but thankfully my family and I were able to get seated right away. I would say even though there were only a couple tables occupied before the dinner rush, the service was mediocre. I think with the quality of service and food, it's severely overpriced. Overall, dinner was just fine.

Useful (1) Report

Nc 2025.12.02

     

The food is just okay. The service is very bad. They try to be high end but are very far from the real standard. Hostess was extremely rude at the check out. I would only come back if i’m hungry and there’s nothing else decent nearby. Otherwise, so many better options in the area!!

Useful Report

Erik 2025.11.30

     

Consistently disappointing. Mediocre food. Subpar service.

Useful Report

Gulnur Alicanoglu 2025.11.28

     

We came here 3 people for Thansgiving fixed menu. As a starter we grilled shrimp with some kind of heavy sauce on it. I could only eat one piece because it was not cooked enough. My mom could not eat it either. My son tried to finish but he agreed as well. Main menu, two picked turkey and I had bronzini. Its a one piece bland fillet with lemon patatoes. The fillet is very small. After i scraped the skin off, there was so little fish left. Portions were very small for 78 dollar per person. Dessert was tiramusu which was not a wow. I had better ones. My son agreed at the end that we should have picked a neighborhood restaurant , Sunnyside, to eat. Nothing special at all.

Useful Report

Chris S 2025.11.28

     

Outstanding Thanksgiving dinner, excellent value.

Useful Report

T M 2025.11.24

     

We celebrated our daughter’s 16 with family and friends, a group of 25. Food, service and ambiance were perfect. Tyler was very patient and professional throughout the whole planning process.

Useful Report

Nelson Rosario 2025.11.23

     

I ordered a pizza today it was fantastic outstanding best pizza in Lic everyone needs to go a try it The host was so friendly and the young guy that was helping her gave me a cup of water thanks Great atmosphere

Useful Report

Les G. 2025.11.22

     

Verified

A fantastic dinner party! The food was amazing and so was the staff! Great view of the city and beautiful decor.

Useful Report

Stassa Johnson 2025.11.18

     

Order the Brussels sprouts PERIOD... The food is amazing and the ambiance is just a good... You cannot go wrong with anything on the menu... Please come see Eleonora #10/10, would recommend...

Useful Report

Diane Jules 2025.11.10

     

Useful Report

gina Washere 2025.11.09

     

This used to be my favorite place to go to but Not anymore. A few times recently I ordered their usual salmon and it tasted sooo old and no flavor. I thought maybe the cook changed for that day so he/she didn’t make it properly but I went back another day and same exact experience. The cook even put 2 pieces of the very bad tasting salmon instead of one and spread brussel sprouts all over with watery liquid said which literally had no taste. I then tried their margarita pizza and their salad and when I say the salt level was sooo high. I felt the need to write this review because I don’t know what is going on but their food sucks now. I hate when restaurants don’t focus much on the food when it’s pickup option. Only when people sit to eat. But overall, food is inedible from these past few experiences

Useful Report